The best wizards and magical characters in comics are, at the top, Doctor Strange , Zatanna , John Constantine and Scarlet Witch. This tier list ranks the magic wielders of the comic book universe according to their importance, their stories and their power. Facts (publisher, creation) verified, no invented ratings; each character refers to its file.
Magic is a separate part of the comics universe, with its own rules and cult figures. This tier list ranks wizards and witches according to their narrative importance and the richness of their stories: from Sorcerer Supreme to second-rate mage. Criterion: the weight of the character, not just its raw power.
Editorial Ranks, Facts verified. Each character refers to its file when it exists.
Collecting this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7 day trial.
Start my trial →Tier S: the great masters of magic
Doctor Strange (1963) is Marvel's Sorcerer Supreme, the absolute reference of the genre. Zatanna (1964), who casts her spells in reverse, is DC's flagship magician. John Constantine (1985), the occultist trickster from Hellblazer, embodies adult, cynical magic. And Scarlet Witch (1964), capable of rewriting reality, is one of the most powerful in the entire Marvel Universe.
Tier A: major magicians
Doctor Fate (1940), Nabu's Helmet and Ordered Magic, is a founding figure of DC. Raven (Teen Titans), Doctor Voodoo (former Sorcerer Supreme) and Nico Minoru (Runaways) each bring a distinct and modern magic.
Tier B: experienced practitioners
Baron Mordo , Strange's nemesis, Wiccan (Young Avengers), Mrs. Xanadu and Morgan le Fay complete the gallery of great magic wielders, between heroes and antagonists.
Tier C: secondary wizards
Sargon the Sorcerer , The Enchantress (Asgard), Dr. Occult (one of the very first DC characters, 1935) and Shaman (Alpha Flight) are more discreet but well-anchored figures.
Tier D: esoteric curiosities
Ibis the Invincible (1940), Felix Faust and Wotan close this selection: wizards from the Golden Age or minor villains, real but rarely highlighted.
To remember
- Doctor Strange and Zatanna are the two iconic faces of magic at Marvel and DC.
- Constantine embodies the “mature” magic of the Vertigo label.
- Scarlet Witch blurs the line between magic and cosmic power.
- Strange Tales #110 (1st of Doctor Strange) is a major key issue in the genre.
Frequently asked questions
Doctor Strange (Sorcerer Supreme) and Scarlet Witch (capable of rewriting reality) are the most powerful at Marvel. On the DC side, Doctor Fate and the Specter reach comparable levels.
In Strange Tales #110 (1963), a key issue sought after by collectors, even more so since the success of the films.
Yes. Created in Swamp Thing then star of Hellblazer (Vertigo), John Constantine is part of the DC universe, especially via its magical and mature branch.
Do you own Strange Tales #110 or another magical key issue? Estimate its value for free with our tool based on current eBay listings.
A timeline of magic in comics, from 1935 to 2005
Ranking sorcerers by tier is one thing; knowing when they were born is another, and it is what guides a collector to first-appearance issues. Here are the creation markers from the list, by period.
The Golden Age: the founders (1935-1941)
- Dr. Occult (1935): one of the very first DC characters.
- Doctor Fate (1940): the helmet of Nabu and orderly magic, a founding figure of DC.
- Ibis the Invincible (1940) and Wotan (1940): Golden Age sorcerers, real but rarely brought to the fore.
- Sargon the Sorcerer (1941): a more discreet figure but well anchored.
The Silver Age: the explosion (1962-1964)
- Felix Faust (1962): a minor DC villain.
- Doctor Strange and Baron Mordo (1963): the Sorcerer Supreme and his nemesis at Marvel. Strange's first appearance is in Strange Tales #110, a major key issue of the genre.
- Zatanna (1964): the DC magician who casts her spells backwards.
- Scarlet Witch and The Enchantress (1964): one able to rewrite reality, the other from Asgard.
The Bronze Age: magic diversifies (1973-1983)
- Doctor Voodoo (1973): a former Sorcerer Supreme.
- Madame Xanadu (1978) and Raven (1980): the latter from the Teen Titans.
- Shaman (1983): a member of Alpha Flight.
The modern era: adult and young magic (1985-2005)
- John Constantine (1985): created in Swamp Thing then star of Hellblazer at Vertigo, he embodies adult, cynical magic.
- Nico Minoru (2003), of Runaways, and Wiccan (2005), of Young Avengers: a new generation of characters.
How to use it for collecting
This timeline shows that the oldest first appearances belong to the Golden Age, while most of the icons the general public knows date from the 1960s. If you are starting out, it is natural to begin with Strange Tales #110 for Marvel, then look for the first appearance of a DC character such as Zatanna or Doctor Fate.
Keep two reflexes. First, always check the condition before buying, particularly for 1960s issues. Second, remember that a character ranked in a low tier (Ibis, Felix Faust, Wotan) can have real historical importance even if rarely brought to the fore: they are often the most discreet pieces of a magic collection.