The best adaptations of comics into TV series are, at the top, The Boys , Watchmen (HBO), Daredevil (Netflix) and Invincible. This tier list classifies series based on comics according to their success and their fidelity to the original spirit. Facts (series, dates) verified, no odds invented; each entry refers to the source comic file when it exists.
The television series has become an ideal adaptation ground for comics: the long format allows the characters to be developed. This tier list ranks the best series according to their quality and their respect for the original material.
Editorial Ranks, Facts verified. Each entry refers to the source comic file when it exists.
Collecting this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7 day trial.
Start my trial →Tier S: exceptional series
The Boys is television's most biting superhero satire. Watchmen (HBO) brilliantly continues Moore's work. Daredevil (Netflix) remains the reference for street-level television, and Invincible faithfully adapts Kirkman's comic.
Tier A: the great successes
The Walking Dead launched the wave, WandaVision et Loki renewed the Marvel format, and The Umbrella Academy offered a stylish adaptation.
Tier B: gender values
Arrow et The Flash built the “Arrowverse” universe. Preacher et Legion dared to be visually audacious.
Tier C: the notable series
Jessica Jones , Doom Patrol , Peacemaker and Sweet Tooth complete the selection with very varied tones.
Tier D: adaptations to discover
Y: The Last Man, iZombie and Constantine close this tier list: more confidential but real series.
To remember
- The Boys and Invincible show the vitality of indie adaptations.
- The serial format allows for in-depth character development.
- A successful series revives demand for source comics.
- Each entry refers to the source comic file when it exists.
Three waves of comic-based series and what they mean for readers
The series in this tier list did not arrive all at once. Placing them by launch date reveals three successive waves, each with its own logic, and helps you decide where to approach the source comics.
2010 to 2015: clearing the ground
The Walking Dead leads the way in 2010, followed by Arrow in 2012, then The Flash and Constantine in 2014, and Daredevil, Jessica Jones and iZombie in 2015. This is when television proves that the long format suits comic characters. Superhero series build a shared universe, while others take up darker characters.
2016 to 2019: formal daring
Preacher (2016) and Legion (2017) dare a strong visual identity, then 2019 brings The Umbrella Academy, The Boys, Watchmen and Doom Patrol. Several of these series do not try to illustrate a comic page by page: they extend or reinterpret. That is precisely the case of Watchmen, which extends Moore's work instead of remaking it.
2021 and after: back to the text
WandaVision, Loki, Invincible, Sweet Tooth and Y: The Last Man arrive in 2021, Peacemaker in 2022. Invincible faithfully adapts Kirkman's comic, which makes it the most direct entry point to its original issues.
How to go from screen to page
- Closed work or long-running series? Watchmen is a twelve-issue maxiseries published from 1986 to 1987: you can read it in full. The Walking Dead or Arrow, by contrast, rest on a far larger body of material, where you have to choose an entry point.
- Read first, collect later. First read the start of the comic in a collected edition to see if the tone suits you, then look for the original issues if the urge to collect arrives.
- Expect differences. Even a faithful adaptation changes scenes, names or chronology; rereading them side by side is part of the fun.
- Spot first appearances. When a series builds on an older character, like Daredevil or Constantine, the source comic's entry shows where the character first appears.
Following this thread, the tier list becomes a reading map: each rank points to a specific comic, and each wave to a different way of diving in.
Frequently asked questions
The Boys , Watchmen (HBO) and Daredevil (Netflix) are among the most acclaimed, each faithful to the spirit of its original comic.
Often, yes: the long format allows the plot and the characters to be further developed. Invincible and The Walking Dead closely follow their comics.
Yes: the announcement of a series often raises demand for the character's key numbers. Always check the actual rating, as the effect may be temporary.
A series makes you want to collect the original comic? Estimate the value of its key numbers with our tool based on current eBay listings.