The first issue of Spécial Strange is dated 10 July 1975 and was published by Éditions Lug. The catalogue associates it with a story titled "Le Penseur Fou" (The Mad Thinker), with texts credited to Gerry Conway, Len Wein and Steve Gerber, and art credited to Jean Frisano, John Buscema and Ross Andru. It is the starting point of a series that would reach 59 issues under Lug, and the only issue number one that exists for this title.
You open a listing, you read "Spécial Strange n° 1", and the photo shows a painted cover. Before you decide, only one question really matters: is this the copy dated 10 July 1975, or has the seller confused it with one of the many neighbouring items the Lug stable produced around this title? This article is about the object itself, not the history of the magazine: what it contains according to the available data, how to recognise it, and why an honest copy remains hard to find.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact. The analysis is our own, with no reproduction of any panel or protected dialogue.
The issue of 10 July 1975, as the catalogue describes it
The cover date is precise: 10 July 1975. It matters to a buyer, because it is enough to settle most identification disputes: no other issue carrying this title and this number bears that date. If the date legible on the object is different, you do not have issue number one in front of you, and you should say so to the seller before paying rather than after.
The story title recorded for this issue is "Le Penseur Fou". The texts are attributed to Gerry Conway, Len Wein and Steve Gerber; the art to Jean Frisano, John Buscema and Ross Andru. These names are given for the issue as a whole, with no indication from the catalogue of who worked on what, or who drew the cover rather than the interior pages.
A practical consequence follows, and it is the most useful point in this article: the available listing gives only one story title per issue, whereas a magazine of this format contained several. The full contents of issue number one are therefore not documented here, and you cannot reconstruct them from memory. The only reliable way to know what a copy contains is to ask for a photo of the contents page or of the first pages of each story.
Three writers and three artists for a single issue
Six names credited on a newsstand issue already tell you how the magazine was made: by assembly. French publishers of the period bought episodes at different dates, translated them, re-cut them to the format they wanted, and dressed the whole thing in a cover produced in-house. That is why a creator list this long indicates not a collaboration but a compilation.
The presence of Jean Frisano on the list deserves a separate mention, because his name recurs across a large part of the series, often at the head of the artist list. The in-house illustrators produced the painted covers that built the visual reputation of the Lug magazines, and that is the element buyers look at first. Even so, the catalogue does not explicitly state that he signed the cover of issue number one: if the question matters to you, check the signature on the object, which is sometimes legible in a corner.
On the American side, the three credited writers were all active in the mid-1970s across several titles at once, which makes any deduction about the exact episode reused hazardous. We therefore assert no match with a specific American issue: the sources disagree on the details of the reworking carried out by the French publisher, and such a claim could not be verified on the basis of what we have.
What sets it apart from the issues that follow
The second issue is dated 10 December 1975. Five months separate the first two releases, a longer gap than the series would keep later. For you, the meaning is simple: issue number one was not printed to the rhythm of an established series, but to that of a trial whose continuation was not yet scheduled.
Another tangible difference: the story title recorded on issue number one is a story title, whereas several later issues carry headings that point to other publications of the publisher, such as "Album Conan n° 3" or "Kabur n° 5". These entries betray the presence of promotional pages or ancillary content, and they remind you that a newsstand issue was not only a collection of episodes.
The consequence for the buyer: on an issue number one, attention rests entirely on the cover and on the integrity of the booklet. On later issues, it must also cover the games and feature pages, which readers of the time often filled in or cut out. Issue number one exposes you less to that risk, but more to wear, because it has lived longer.
Recognising a genuine issue number one in a listing
Proceed by elimination, in this order, asking for the photos that are missing. First, the exact title on the cover: it must carry both words, not the single word Strange. Then the number, followed by the date of 10 July 1975. Finally, the publisher's name, which must be Éditions Lug and not that of a later taker-over.
Many listings are satisfied with a hand-typed title and a front-on photo of the cover. That is not enough: the front face shows neither the back, nor the edge, nor the condition of the centre of the booklet. Ask for three additional images, namely the back cover, the edge seen at an angle, and the central fold opened flat. A seller who refuses these three photos for an object fifty years old tells you something without saying it.
Be wary, finally, of listings that describe a precise content without showing it. As the full contents of this issue are not documented publicly in any structured way, a detailed description of the content is either copied from elsewhere or made from the object. In the second case, the seller will agree to photograph the page they describe.
The possible confusions, and there are many
The first comes from the neighbouring title. The magazine Strange, from the same publisher, began with an issue number one dated 5 January 1970, and ran until issue 228. So within the same editorial catalogue you have two items that could be advertised as "Strange n° 1", five and a half years apart. A hurried seller, or an heir clearing out a cellar, confuses the two without ill intent.
The second confusion is the reverse of the one often feared. When Semic took over the title in 1989, the numbering was not reset to zero: the series picks up at number 60 and runs on to number 115. In other words, there is no second issue number one for Spécial Strange, and a listing offering an issue number one from the Semic period is in fact describing something else. This is good news for you: for this particular title, issue number one is unambiguous.
Two families of objects remain to be set aside. First, the special issues and one-off specials, whose numbering is independent and sometimes restarts at one. Second, the compilations and reprints, which bring old content back in a new presentation. In both cases, the publisher's name and the date remain your best judges, and an object whose date is not 10 July 1975 cannot be the original edition, whatever the resemblance of the cover.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
What to examine on the object before buying
Start with the two staples. On a paperback-bound issue of this period, they are the weak point: rust, an enlarged hole, a staple missing or replaced. A replaced staple is not a disaster, but it must be disclosed, because it leaves a visible trace on the back and changes the way the booklet closes.
Next, look at the spine, folded and refolded by successive readings, and then at the four corners, which tell the story of how the copy was stored. A copy left upright in a stack wears along the bottom edge; a copy folded into a pocket picks up a central vertical crease that no flattening will ever remove. Finally, check that the booklet is complete by counting the pagination on either side of the central fold, where pages come away first.
Two details specific to newsstand magazines deserve a last look. Odours and damp halos, which do not show in a flash photograph, and spine discolouration from light, common on copies that spent years in a shop window. On an issue number one, these two defects weigh more than elsewhere, because it is the copy you will keep on display.
What makes it relatively scarce
The scarcity comes from a mechanical phenomenon, not from a particularly low print run. The first issue of a magazine is bought by an audience that does not yet know whether it will follow the title, so often without any intention of keeping it, whereas later issues enter an already-started collection and are stored with care. The issue number one is the one that was read the most and protected the least.
The second factor is time. Between 10 July 1975 and today, a copy has had time to pass through several hands, several moves and several attics. The late issues of the series, published in the 1980s, have had ten years less to deteriorate, which is why a late issue in good condition is easier to find than an issue number one that is merely decent.
These two effects combine at the top of the condition curve: average copies exist in quantity, truly clean copies are rare, and the value gap between the two is far more pronounced on issue number one than on an issue from the middle of the series. That is where most of a buying decision is actually made, far more than in identification, which only requires a photo of the date.
The neighbouring issues, and what they change
If your goal is to build a coherent start to the series, issue number two, dated 10 December 1975, and issue number three, dated 15 March 1976, form with the first a set that is sometimes sold together. Buying the three together saves you two postage fees and gives you an immediate point of comparison on the print quality of the first releases.
Beware, however, of a lot trap: a seller offering "the first issues" will happily put issue number one in the photo and leave the rest in the shadows. Ask for the list of issues included, and above all the condition of each, because a lot is almost always pulled down by its worst item, and that is rarely the one shown in the listing thumbnail.
Tracking this issue in your collection
Record three pieces of information at the moment of acquisition, not just the number: the cover date, the condition of the staples, and whether the additional pages are present or not. These three data points are the ones you will have forgotten in two years, and they are exactly what a buyer or an insurer will ask you for. Logging them in your inventory while you hold the object takes less than a minute.
Also photograph your copy as soon as you receive it, flat and without flash, front and back. That photo serves as proof of condition if the object travels, and as a reference when you compare a future opportunity with what you already own. A collection record is only worth something if it records condition, not just the list of issues held.
In short
Only one issue can carry the title Spécial Strange and the number one: the one dated 10 July 1975, published by Éditions Lug, to which the catalogue links "Le Penseur Fou" and six credited creators with no division of roles. Identification is therefore easy, provided you insist on a photo of the date rather than a description.
The real work lies elsewhere: setting aside the magazine with the neighbouring title launched in 1970, setting aside the special issues and the reprints, and above all judging the condition of an object that is fifty years old and has almost always been read. On this issue, condition makes up most of the price gap, and the rest of the contents can only be checked on the copy itself, never on the listing. To go further on the characters who fill the magazines of this period, the Fantastic Four and X-Men hubs are useful companions to this sheet.
Frequently asked questions
The cover date is 10 July 1975, for a publication by Éditions Lug. It is the simplest criterion for validating a listing: if the date legible on the object differs, it is not the original issue number one, even if the cover resembles the one you are looking for.
The catalogue associates this issue with a story titled "Le Penseur Fou". It gives only one title per issue, however, whereas these magazines contained several: the full contents are therefore not documented. Ask for a photo of the contents page, or of the first pages of each story, before buying.
The texts are credited to Gerry Conway, Len Wein and Steve Gerber, the art to Jean Frisano, John Buscema and Ross Andru. These six names apply to the issue as a whole, with no split specified between cover and interior pages, which is usual for a magazine built by assembling episodes.
No. The numbering was not reset: the series picks up at number 60 and runs on to number 115. There is therefore only one issue number one for this title, the one from 1975. A listing offering an issue number one attributed to that second period necessarily describes something else.
Because a first issue is bought without any intention of keeping it, and so is read without care, and because it has had more years to deteriorate than the issues of the 1980s. Decent copies circulate, truly clean copies are rare, and that is where the gap widens.