Issue number one of the X-Men magazine launched by Semic S.A. (the French magazine) carries a cover date of December 1992. The title recorded for its main story is “Ombre Noire, Ombre Blanche! Chapitre II: L'ombre attaque”, credited for writing to Jim Lee, Chris Claremont and Marv Wolfman, and for art to Jim Lee and John Buscema. This “Chapter II” is the decisive fact: the magazine's first issue does not begin a story, it picks up a thread partway through.
A buyer who spots this issue at a fair or in a listing almost always reasons the same way: first issue, so starting point, so read from here. For this particular magazine, that reasoning is wrong, and it can be checked in black and white in the title of the story recorded in the catalogue. Understanding why avoids two disappointments: that of the reader who expects an opening, and that of the collector who pays for a first issue without knowing what they are holding.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
What the December 1992 issue actually carries
For this issue, the catalogue records a cover date of December 1992 and a single story title: “Ombre Noire, Ombre Blanche! Chapitre II: L'ombre attaque”. The recorded credits bring together two teams that have nothing to do with each other: Jim Lee and Chris Claremont on one side, Marv Wolfman and John Buscema on the other. This mix within a single credit field is not a data-entry oddity; it is the signature of a composite issue, placing side by side material from different origins.
It is worth saying right away what the data does not contain, because that is what misleads most people. Only one story title is recorded per issue, whereas a newsstand magazine of this format usually stacks several episodes under one cover. The recorded title therefore identifies the main story, not the full contents. Any question of the “what else is inside” kind is settled by opening the copy, never by reading a listing, and certainly not by trusting the cover.
Likewise, nothing in what is recorded allows us to say which American comic this issue corresponds to, or which character makes a first appearance in French there. Both claims abound in sales descriptions with nothing verified behind them. It is better to state content checked page by page than an assumed equivalence.
“Chapter II”: the first issue does not open the story
The central point of this entry rests on one word in the title: chapter two. The magazine's inaugural issue does not contain the beginning of the story that serves as its flagship. Someone who buys it to start a storyline is in fact buying its immediate sequel, and will always be missing a piece that no later issue of this same magazine will supply.
This is not an isolated accident: it is the mechanics of the entire magazine. Across the twenty-five issues on record, only two carry a title that announces an opening, and neither of them is number one. The magazine was therefore conceived as a tap opened onto a flow already under way, not as a collection of beginnings. For a collector, this changes how one builds a readable set: a complete run by issue number does not necessarily produce a continuous read.
Something sharper still: the first five issues carry chapters two, four, six, eight and ten of the same arc, in that order, in Roman numerals. In other words, the story's numbering advances twice as fast as the magazine's. Two readings are possible and the available data does not settle them: either each issue contained two chapters and only the second of each pair was recorded, or the odd-numbered chapters came out elsewhere. The first hypothesis is the more economical, but it remains a hypothesis: it is checked by counting the episodes in an actual copy.
What to look for in the contents before paying
This peculiarity leads to a very concrete buying step. Before committing, ask for a photo of the contents page or of the first page of the main story, not just the cover. Two pieces of information can be read there and are decisive: the chapter or part marking, and the number of episodes stacked in the issue. With these two elements, you know where you are entering the story and how much material you are buying.
If the seller cannot provide that view, treat the contents as unknown, not as matching what you imagine. For a widely distributed 1992 magazine, the requirement is reasonable: the market offers enough copies to refuse a listing that is stingy with images and move on to the next.
A third habit, less obvious: note which chapter you already own. When a magazine advances two chapters per issue, reading tracking no longer coincides with collection tracking. Many collections from this period are “complete” in terms of issue numbers and full of gaps in terms of the story, which becomes apparent on the evening you decide to reread everything in order.
How to recognize a genuine first issue in a listing
The most reliable marker is not the printed number but the pairing of date and content. A genuine number one of this magazine carries December 1992 as its cover date, and its main story is the chapter two cited above. If the stated date does not match, or if the story title is a different one, you do not have this issue in front of you, whatever “1” is visible in the photo.
The number one on its own proves nothing. The same publisher launched several titles in the early 1990s, each with its own number one, and the covers of that period share the same graphic codes, sometimes the same artists. A listing illustrated with a catalogue thumbnail rather than the actual object should prompt a request for a photo of the copy being sold, spine and staples included.
Finally, be wary of listings that sell the number one as a historic piece without saying anything about its contents. When the description is limited to superlatives, the seller has often not opened the issue.
What sets this issue apart from the rest of the series
Two recorded credits do not last. Chris Claremont's name as writer appears only on the number one and on the February 1993 issue; from the third issue onward, John Byrne is recorded in his place, then Scott Lobdell, then Fabian Nicieza, who occupies most of the rest of the series. For someone interested in creative signatures rather than issue numbers, the first issue therefore belongs to a very small window of the magazine.
The other credit on its way out is John Buscema on art, present on the first five issues and then no longer at all. Here too, the number one is not isolated; it sits at the start of a short sequence. This offers a useful way to sort a pile: the very first issues belong to an editorial setup that did not last, while the rest belongs to another, clearly more stable one built around Andy Kubert.
One last difference, this one commercial in nature: a first issue circulates through hands that did not buy the following ones, picked up out of curiosity, read once, then shelved or thrown away. This is why number ones abound in average condition and become scarce in fine condition, whereas mid-run issues, bought by regular readers and often kept with care, are easier to find clean.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
Possible confusions at the point of purchase
The first confusion comes from seniority. The adventures of this team had already been appearing in French well before December 1992, in magazines from the same publisher, some of which ran for dozens of issues. An issue bearing a number one in 1992 is therefore not the starting point of the series in French, only of a new container. Listings that present the first issue as the birth certificate of a publication confuse the title with the material it carries.
The second confusion is lateral. Other titles devoted to characters from the same universe were launched by this publisher in those years, and their number ones cross over in the same lots. The full title on the cover and the date are enough to settle it, provided you read both and not just the larger of the two.
A third, more insidious trap: later compilations. The same story can reappear in another container, with different pagination and a different cover. If you are looking for the December 1992 object, it is that object that must be seen in the photo, not the story it contains. For simple reading, the opposite is true. Decide which of the two you are buying before comparing listings.
A 1990s magazine: what that changes for condition
To be frank: this issue is among the most recent we handle in this field, and the indulgence that applies to magazines from the 1950s or 1960s has no place here. Paper from 1992 has no reason to be yellowed, brittle or foxed. When it is, the cause is not age but storage: damp cellar, crushed stack, sun on a shelf. A defect on an object from this period is a defect, not a patina.
The consequence is direct for the standard applied. For an issue of this era, the expected reference condition is very close to new: clean staples, no whitening along the spine, sharp corners, a cover free of reading creases. A worn copy is not a collector's piece, it is a reading copy, and it should be offered as such. Accepting poor condition is justified only if you are buying to read, or to fill a gap while waiting for something better.
The silver lining is pleasant: fine copies exist in quantity. This period was printed widely, and many buyers at the time already stored their magazines upright, out of the way. The standard does not condemn you to searching for years, which is not true of the newsstands of earlier decades.
Where its relative rarity comes from
The series ran four years without a hitch: from the December 1992 issue to the December 1996 issue, the cover dates follow one another every two months, with no gap. This regularity says something important about rarity: there is no interruption or hard-to-find restart number in this run, because publication never wavered. The difficulty does not come from the calendar.
It comes from two other directions. First, demand, supported by the lasting fame of the characters and by the appeal of the signatures of the very first period of the magazine. Second, the rarity of condition described above: it is not the issue that is missing, it is the flawless issue. On a series this recent, the value gap between a crumpled copy and a clean one is the real driver of price, more than the number itself.
One last factor, often overlooked: the way the number one is sold. It rarely goes alone, usually in a lot with the first issues, which blurs the comparison benchmarks.
Keeping this issue in a collection
For this magazine, a useful inventory does not stop at the number and the condition. Add two columns: the chapter or part the issue contains, and the number of episodes you counted in it. This is the only way the reading gaps appear, since they never show up in a run of consecutive issues. A collector who follows the mutant series across several magazines gains even more from this.
Also note the cover date rather than the year alone. With a two-month rhythm, the year is not enough to tell six different issues apart, and inventory confusions almost always start there. December 1992 identifies the first issue without any possible ambiguity, including in a conversation with a seller who does not have the magazine in front of them.
Finally, distinguish what you have checked yourself from what you copied from a listing: in six months you will have forgotten which was which. On the Wolverine stories published in France, many widespread errors come from listings copied without anyone having opened the object.
What to keep in mind
The first issue of this magazine is a precisely dated, well-identified object, easy to find, and yet regularly misrepresented, because people credit it with an opening function it does not have. Its recorded title announces a chapter two: it enters a story begun elsewhere, and the first five issues each advance by two chapters.
Three steps are enough to buy correctly. Require the cover date of December 1992 on the actual object. Ask for an image of the contents and count the episodes. And apply to an issue from the early 1990s the standard of condition that its youth makes legitimate, without granting it the indulgence reserved for much older magazines.
Frequently asked questions
No. The title recorded for its main story announces a chapter two, not an opening. The December 1992 issue therefore picks up a story already under way, and no later issue of this magazine publishes the missing chapter. If you want a continuous read, the first chapter has to be sought outside this run of issues.
For writing, Jim Lee, Chris Claremont and Marv Wolfman. For art, Jim Lee and John Buscema. This double team-up reflects a composite issue, bringing together material of different origins. Claremont's credits disappear from the third issue onward, which makes the number one part of a very short editorial window.
Cross-check two elements on a photo of the actual object: the cover date of December 1992 and the title of the main story, which mentions a chapter two. The number one alone is not enough, since several titles launched by the same publisher in those years each have their own number one, with covers of very similar design.
Only to read, or on a temporary basis. A 1992 issue has no excuse of age: yellowed paper or a whitened spine point to poor storage, not to seniority. Since this period was printed widely, copies close to new remain accessible, and the condition standard is entirely reasonable here.
The magazine ran from December 1992 to December 1996 without interruption, at a two-month rhythm. There is therefore no restart issue made rare by a halt in publication. The difficulty shifts to condition: it is the flawless copy that is hard to find, not the issue.