Number : Watchmen #1 (DC Comics)
Publication date: September 1986
Creators: Alan Moore (screenplay), Dave Gibbons (drawing), John Higgins (colors)
Current value CGC 9.8:~$4,500-$6,000
Watchmen #1 marks the beginning of what is unanimously considered one of the greatest works of Western comics. Published in September 1986 by DC Comics, this first issue introduced a deconstructed superhero universe that redefined the narrative possibilities of the medium. For the collector, it is an essential piece of the Modern Age era.
The 12-issue miniseries received the Hugo Award in 1988: a first for a comic book. The influence of Watchmen on the industry is such that we often speak of a "before" and an "after" of this publication. The first issue, with its iconic bloody smiley face cover, remains the most requested of the series.
Publication context
1986 was a pivotal year for DC Comics: Frank Miller delivered The Dark Knight Returns while Alan Moore launched Watchmen. The two works inaugurate the "grim and gritty" era of American comics. Moore, already famous for Swamp Thing, gets carte blanche to revisit superhero archetypes from the Charlton Comics characters recently acquired by DC. The initial print run is substantial: DC is betting big on the project.
The creators
Alan Moore deploys a narrative structure of unprecedented complexity in comics: non-linear narration, recurring visual symbolism, additional texts at the end of the chapter. Dave Gibbons adopts a strict waffle iron of 9 squares per page which becomes the visual signature of the work. John Higgins brings a deliberately artificial color palette which reinforces the oppressive atmosphere.
The cover
Dave Gibbons' design is strikingly simple: a blood-stained yellow smiley face on a black background, with a clock in the background reading five minutes to midnight. This image has become one of the most recognizable symbols in pop culture. The absence of any character on the cover was a bold marketing move for the time.
CGC census and distribution by grade
The CGC census has approximately 3,800 certified copies. The large circulation at the time and immediate popularity meant that many examples were preserved in good condition. Around 650 copies are graded 9.8. The newsstand edition, more fragile than the direct edition, is slightly more valued in the high grades.
Live vs. Newsstand
The direct edition (DC logo in a diamond) represents the majority of copies in circulation. The newsstand edition (visible barcode) commands a 20-30% premium in grades 9.6+ due to its relative rarity in mint condition.
Value by grade
- CGC 9.8: 4,500-6,000 USD
- GCC 9.6: 1,200-1,800 USD
- GCC 9.4: 600-900 USD
- GCC 9.2: 350-500 USD
- CGC 9.0: 200-350 USD
Price history
The rating of Watchmen #1 has experienced several waves of appreciation: a first during the release of Zack Snyder's film in 2009, then a second with the HBO series in 2019. The market then consolidated around current values. Unlike other media outlets, the literary collector base maintains a solid floor regardless of adaptations.
Shopping Tips
The optimal quality-price ratio is at grade 9.4, accessible under 1,000 USD. For a 9.8 copy, carefully check the whiteness of the black background on the cover: the micro-scratches are very visible and may justify a downgrade. Favor copies with bright white pages. The complete series in 12 issues, all CGC certified, constitutes a particularly elegant collector's set. Discover our guide to grading CGC to optimize your purchases.
Manage your Watchmen collection and track the rating of each issue using our number by number tracking tool. Don't miss any purchasing opportunities again.
Timeline and checkpoints before buying Watchmen #1
Watchmen #1 has an editorial history that helps explain why it behaves differently from other key issues. Here are the markers to keep in mind, then what to examine on the copy itself.
A short timeline
- September 1986: the first issue is published by DC Comics, the same year as Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns.
- 1988: the 12-issue mini-series wins the Hugo Award, a first for a comic book.
- 2009: Zack Snyder's film is released, the first wave of interest in the issue.
- 2019: the television series brings a second wave before the market settles.
This rhythm explains the issue's stability: demand comes first from readers and collectors attached to the literary work, with adaptations only adding peaks.
Identifying the right edition
Look at the logo at the top of the cover and at the barcode corner. The direct edition shows the DC logo in a diamond and accounts for most of the copies in circulation. The newsstand edition shows a visible barcode and is met less often in very high condition, which is why buyers of top grades value it slightly more.
What the eye should check
- The black cover background. The blood-stained smiley stands out against a dark flat colour where micro-scratches leap out. Tilt the copy in the light before approving a high grade.
- The clock. It reads five minutes to midnight on the cover: a design detail, but also a good marker for making sure you hold the right issue in a series where the covers look alike.
- The interior pages. The 9-panel grid per page and the supplementary texts at the end of each chapter must be complete: check that no page has been cut or replaced.
- The page whiteness. Bright white pages are a deciding factor at equal grade.
Thinking as a set
The census counts about 3,800 certified copies, a small share of them at 9.8: the large print run of 1986 left many well-preserved copies. If you plan to gather all 12 issues, choose a consistent grade across the series rather than aiming for an isolated 9.8 on #1 with badly worn issues around it.
Frequently asked questions
It is the first issue of a work unanimously regarded as one of the greatest in Western comics, and it introduces the series' characters. The mini-series also won the Hugo Award in 1988, a first for a comic book.
Alan Moore wrote the series and Dave Gibbons drew it, with John Higgins on colours. Published in September 1986 by DC Comics, the first issue draws on characters from Charlton Comics, recently acquired by DC.
The direct edition carries the DC logo in a diamond, and the newsstand edition a visible barcode. The direct edition is the more common, while the more fragile newsstand edition is valued slightly more in high grades.
The CGC census counts about 3,800 certified copies, of which about 650 are graded 9.8. The large print run of the time and the immediate popularity explain why many copies were kept in good condition.
They triggered waves of appreciation, first with Zack Snyder's film in 2009, then with the television series in 2019. The market then consolidated, and the base of literary collectors maintains a solid floor.