Thor, Semic 1989: the complete collector's guide to issues 3 to 31, article illustration

The catalogue lists the Semic magazine Thor from #3 to #31, with no break in the numbering across that whole range. The cover dates show a regular bimonthly rhythm, from the late 1980s to the very start of the following decade. Tom DeFalco and Ron Frenz fill almost the entire credits. The tricky point is the start of the series: the issues before the checklist are missing, and that absence says nothing about whether they really existed.

When you pull a stack of Thor magazines out of a box, the first question is not about the content but about the count: is the stack complete, or just continuous? With this title, the answer gets complicated at the very first step, because the available checklist does not start where a reader would expect. That gap governs the whole collecting method.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of artwork or protected dialogue.

The key dated facts given in this article about Thor, Semic 1989

What this magazine published

The title takes the god of thunder's name, but the French format does not work like a monthly American comic book: a newsstand magazine fills its pages with several episodes, and the catalogue keeps only one story title per issue. What you read in a checklist is therefore a shop window, not a table of contents, and this distinction must come before any conclusion about the contents of an issue.

The proof is in the checklist itself. The title chosen for the tenth issue of the run is "La Femme-Sable" ("The Sand Woman"), which obviously does not belong to the Asgardian pantheon. Standing alone in a series devoted to Thor, a title like that signals that the magazine carried stories from elsewhere, and that the episode put forward was not necessarily the one filling the most pages. For a buyer, this means something very concrete: the table of contents is checked on the copy, never on a listing.

Where the checklist starts, and what that does not prove

Here is the known fact about this title, and it deserves stating plainly: the checklist starts at number 3. The two issues that should logically come before it are absent. On checking, this is not a misreading on our part: the documented range does start at that rank, and nothing comes before it.

What can be concluded from this is limited. We can say that the printed numbering reaches at least that rank, so the series existed before the first documented issue. We can also say that the uncertainty is concentrated at the very beginning, and nowhere else. These two statements are solid.

What cannot be concluded matters more. The absence of the first ranks from the checklist does not show that they never appeared, nor that they would be rare, nor that the numbering started at an unusual figure. A lack of documentation is not the absence of an object: it is a hole in the register, not on the newsstand. Someone who sells you a lower-numbered issue is therefore not necessarily telling you a story, and the catalogue gives you no argument to contradict them. The right stance is to treat these issues as probable, their contents as unknown, and to handle them as pieces to document if you come across them.

A very regular rhythm, readable in the dates

The rest of the series is remarkably orderly. Sorting the cover dates by calendar year gives six issues for each full year in the checklist. This regularity leaves no doubt about the publishing pattern: it is a bimonthly magazine, which kept its pace without any visible accident throughout its run.

A pair of entries confirms this reading independently. The checklist carries a month only on two consecutive issues, dated October then December, which is exactly the expected gap. It is the corroboration one always hopes for and rarely gets, and here it falls into place.

This changes how you hunt. On a bimonthly magazine that never skipped an issue, no middle number is structurally harder to find than another: no distribution break, no phantom rank. The difficulty of completing the set is concentrated at the ends.

The last year, and what it tells us

Only one year in the checklist has fewer issues than the others: the last one, which stops after five issues instead of six. The magazine therefore did not complete its calendar year and stopped partway through.

A stop partway through the year explains how the market behaves at the end of the series. The final issues of a magazine that ends without notice were generally printed in the same runs as the earlier ones, but they circulated for less time, were restocked less often by distributors, and were kept less by readers who no longer had a reason to follow the title. In practice, it is the tail of the series that is hard to find, not its middle. Start your search, then, with the last ranks and with the uncertain zone at the beginning.

The creators and their limits

The credits show a very clear handover. Walt Simonson, whose name appears under two spellings in the credits, is credited as writer on the first four documented issues, then disappears. Tom DeFalco takes over and does not let go: he is credited on twenty-seven of the twenty-nine checklist issues, that is, the entire rest of the series without exception.

On the art side, the continuity is even more striking. Ron Frenz appears in the art credits from #5, the third issue on the checklist, and holds on to the end without a single absence. He is also credited as writer on a large half of the series, alongside DeFalco. For a collector, this means the title is not a patchwork: it is a magazine with a steady hand, where the visual signature stays stable from one end to the other.

The limits delimit usable zones. Sal Buscema is credited on the first four issues of the checklist and nowhere else, which makes that opening stretch an overlap between two artistic regimes. At the other end, Patrick Olliffe appears on the last three: the series changes hands once more just before it stops. Between the two, Gary Hartle signs a continuous block in the heart of the title, and Tony DeZuniga a consecutive pair. These blocks, rather than isolated numbers, are the coherent sets to look for together.

French names in the credits

Here is the most interesting feature of this checklist for a French-speaking reader: French artists appear in the art credits, mixed in with American names. Ciro Tota returns on five issues spread across almost the whole run of the title. Jean-Yves Mitton and Manchu also appear, more occasionally.

Let us be precise about what this allows us to claim. The catalogue credits names at the level of the issue, not at the level of the page or the cover. It therefore indicates that these artists worked on these numbers, without saying on what: from this source alone, we do not know what share of the object is theirs, and any further detail would be invention.

The collecting angle remains remarkable: an issue whose credits pair a French artist of that generation with a series about the god of thunder is an object with a double affiliation. If you hold these numbers, note exactly what you see signed.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Thor, Semic 1989: the sections of this guide, in reading order

The issues that matter, read through their titles

The story titles chosen by the catalogue trace a very readable thematic line. One thread runs from one end of the checklist to the other, that of the hammer: "The Song of Mjolnir" opens the documented series, "Me, This Hammer" arrives in the middle, and "Whoever Wields This Hammer!" comes back in the last part. The weapon is not an accessory in this title; it is a character.

A second, darker thread runs over the first. Three titles explicitly invoke death, from "In the Realm of Death" to "If Death Is My Destiny!", and the last documented issue is titled "The Trial of Beta Ray Bill!". That the series closes on a trial and on the name of a rival hammer-bearer is not a coincidence of layout: it is the end of a cycle, and it can be read in the checklist without having to open the issue.

Recognising the right edition

A first precaution, purely nominal: another French magazine with the same title was published by Arédit from 1977, and it is not the series dealt with here. Comparing the two titles is the subject of a separate guide.

To decide on a copy, rely on three markers, in this order. The publisher printed on the cover or in the imprint is the decisive criterion. The cover year comes next, since the range documented here covers the late 1980s and the start of the following decade. The numbering rank, finally, places the copy in the series but does not by itself distinguish it from a namesake: a low rank can exist with either publisher, and that is precisely the trap. Always note these markers together in your inventory, or you risk buying the same object twice.

Condition of a copy, and buying pitfalls

A newsstand magazine from this period is not graded like a stapled American comic. The spine is often glued, the inside paper is matte and heavy, and the two degrade differently. Look at the spine fold first, because a magazine read flat tends to loosen its glue and release its central signatures: a copy whose middle pages move will always lose value, even under an immaculate cover.

Next, check the top edge and the corners, which pick up moisture from cellars. These magazines travelled a lot in stacks, and the copies on top often show a sun-fading of the red cover that cannot be repaired. Even yellowing of the paper is normal for their age; a halo or a smell is not.

The pitfall specific to this title lies in its very format. Because these magazines contain several stories, a seller may describe a copy by the only episode they know, the one the catalogue highlights. Ask for a photograph of the printed contents page rather than a description, and check that no signature is missing: on a multi-story object, a torn-out signature is much less noticeable than elsewhere, and it is the mistake that costs the most in lots.

Completing the series and tracking its value

With a continuous range and a steady pace, completing this title is a matter of organisation more than luck. Work in blocks of one calendar year: six consecutive issues form a natural purchase unit, and lots offered on the second-hand market often follow that split, because it is how readers filed their magazines.

For value, reason in ratios, not in absolute figures. For a series of this profile, the gap between a very fresh copy and a read copy is of a much larger order of magnitude than the gap between two different numbers in the middle of the series. Condition therefore weighs more than rank, except at the ends: the shortened final year and the uncertain zone at the start escape this rule and are negotiated separately.

Keep your tracking on the object, not on a theoretical list: for each issue, note the rank, the publisher, the cover year as read, the condition observed and the contents present. That is what will tell you, the day you sell or insure, what you actually hold.

What to take away

This magazine is a rare case of a French series that is at once short, continuous and graphically steady: a range without holes, a bimonthly rhythm that never falters, and a duo of creators who fill almost the whole credits. It can be completed without acrobatics once you accept searching by annual blocks.

The two zones of caution are clearly identified. At the start, the issues before the checklist probably exist but are not documented, and one must refrain from deducing anything from them, in either direction. At the close, the stop partway through the year makes the last ranks harder to find than their place in the series would suggest. In between, you have a healthy series, where the condition of the copies will make all the difference. The other collecting guides and the character hub will help you place this title in a wider context.

Thor, Semic 1989: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

Because the issues before rank 3 are not listed in the catalogue consulted. It is a gap in documentation, not proof that these numbers never appeared. If you come across one, treat it as a piece to document: record its publisher, its cover year and its printed contents, none of which the sources consulted here will give you.

The cover dates give six issues per full calendar year, a bimonthly pattern. Two consecutive checklist entries carry a month, October then December, and confirm that gap. The pace shows no break across the documented range, which means no issue in the middle of the series is structurally rarer.

Walt Simonson writes the first documented issues. Tom DeFalco succeeds him and stays credited on almost all of the rest. Ron Frenz holds the art without interruption from his arrival to the last checklist issue, and co-writes a large share of the stories. Sal Buscema opens the range, Patrick Olliffe closes it.

No. The catalogue keeps only one title per issue, whereas these magazines published several stories. The checklist does contain a title whose main character does not belong to the Asgardian universe, which proves the point. The full contents can only be checked on the copy, by photographing the printed contents page.

Read the publisher printed on the cover or in the imprint: it is the only decisive criterion. A namesake was published by Arédit from 1977. The cover year completes the sorting, and the numbering rank is never enough on its own, since a low rank can exist with both publishers.