Superman et Batman et Robin 71-72: The Last Double Issue, article illustration

In the checklist for Superman et Batman et Robin, the "71 - 72" is a single entry dated December 1974, with the title "Incredulity". It is the second and last double issue in the checklist: three ordinary issues follow it, from 73 to 75. It is recorded as a single line, never as two gaps, and its credits remain at the level of the issue.

When a list of gaps carries two numbers joined by a hyphen, the temptation is to look for two magazines. Here there is only one, and the line you noted may already be covered by a copy you own without knowing it.

As always in this guide, only verified details (creators, issue numbers, dates) are stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

The key dated facts given in this article about Superman et Batman et Robin 71-72

What the checklist says about the "71 - 72"

The entry is brief: number "71 - 72", cover date December 1974, a single story title, "Incredulity". The credits are three writers (Frank Robbins, Cary Bates, Denny O'Neil) and three artists (Nick Cardy, Dick Giordano, Curt Swan). Nothing indicates which name corresponds to which episode, or even how many episodes the comic brings together.

What the entry does not say matters as much as what it does. The checklist gives no contents list: the title "Incredulity" belongs to one story, not necessarily the one that opens the comic, and nothing proves that it holds the place of honor. For the actual contents, the copy in hand settles the question.

The last double issue in the checklist

The checklist counts 74 comics, from number 1 of January 1969 to number 75 of March 1975, and only two carry a double number: the "65 - 66" of May 1974 and the "71 - 72" of December 1974. The second is therefore the last double in the checklist, the one that closes the series of two-number comics.

Behind it come three ordinary comics, issues 73, 74 and 75. Issue 75 is the last in the checklist; since a checklist is not the series, we will say "in the checklist" and stop there, without asserting anything about what might have followed or why it ended.

What the date allows us to measure

The immediate neighbors read as follows: issue 70 is dated October 1974, the "71 - 72" December 1974, and issue 73 January 1975. The gap before the double is two months, the gap after it is one month. The last three comics then follow a monthly rhythm: January, February, March 1975.

More telling still: of the 71 single-number entries in the checklist, 70 carry a date whose month matches their rank, counting number 1 as January 1969. The exception is issue 69, dated July 1974 instead of September. Applied to the "71 - 72", this calculation rule (ours, not the publisher's) gives November for the 71 and December for the 72. The date of the double therefore corresponds to its second number. The "65 - 66" of May 1974, for its part, corresponds to its first. Two doubles, two conventions: the date of one double cannot be deduced from the other.

Nine comics for eleven numbers

Counting from the "65 - 66" inclusive, the nine comics (up to 75) cover eleven numbers, from May 1974 to March 1975, that is eleven calendar months. The double issue is what keeps the numbering aligned with the calendar: the "71 - 72" alone occupies the place of two numbers, hence November and December 1974 under our calculation rule.

This reading remains arithmetical: it describes what the figures show, not a decision by the publisher, of which we have no trace in the data. For the collector, the practical consequence is this: no separate "71" or "72" comic appears in the checklist, and it is the double that holds both places.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Superman et Batman et Robin 71-72: the sections of this guide, in reading order

Credits compared with the neighbors

Three writers and three artists is the norm for the checklist: 57 of the 74 comics carry three names on writing, and 66 of 74 on art. A double therefore does not display more credits than an ordinary comic. That is precisely what rules out splitting the credits between "the 71" and "the 72".

Compared with the comics beside it, the "71 - 72" has hardly any signature of its own that sets it apart: issue 73 shares with it Cary Bates, Frank Robbins and Curt Swan; issue 74 shares Cary Bates, Nick Cardy and Curt Swan; issue 75 shares Cary Bates, Frank Robbins and Nick Cardy. Each of the three neighbors that follow therefore has three names out of six in common with the double; issue 70 as well, with Denny O'Neil, Nick Cardy and Curt Swan.

Two details nonetheless stand out. Dick Giordano appears in the checklist only on this comic. And the "71 - 72" is the last line where the name "Denny O'Neil" appears: he is credited on 18 comics in the checklist, the previous one being issue 70. Mind the spelling: the checklist writes "Dennis O'Neil" only once, on issue 37, and a search on the exact string would miss that one.

Nick Cardy, present almost everywhere at the end of the checklist

Nick Cardy is credited on nine comics in the checklist overall. Eight of them fall among the last nine, from the "65 - 66" to 75; the only one missing from that stretch is issue 73. The "71 - 72" therefore sits in the middle of a period where Cardy is nearly constant, rather than at a boundary between creators.

Do not overread this: it applies to the credits of the comic, not to each page. Knowing whether Cardy drew the first, the last or all of the stories in the double requires the copy in hand. For the characters who give their names to the series, see the Batman and Superman hubs.

Recognizing and filing the copy

What to check on the object: the printed number, which must show both numbers and not just one; the cover date, which must read "December 1974"; and the title "Incredulity" somewhere in the contents. The checklist writes "71 - 72" with spaces around the hyphen, but that is catalog notation, not necessarily what appears on the cover.

For the list of gaps, a single line, "71-72", is enough. Do not note 71 and 72 separately: you would be searching for a comic that does not appear in the checklist. Nor should you mark the range 70 to 73 as complete without having seen the double itself, since the 71 and the 72 cannot be deduced from their neighbors.

Condition and tracking

The checklist gives no page count: do not assume this comic is thicker, and compare it with issue 70 or 73 if you have them. Check the spine, the corners and the cover's hold, as you would on any copy.

Superman et Batman et Robin 71-72: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

In the checklist, yes: it contains only two double-number comics, the "65 - 66" and the "71 - 72". The second is therefore the last. After it come issues 73, 74 and 75, each carrying a single number.

The checklist contains no separate 71 or 72 line: both numbers are held by the "71 - 72" comic. Note a single line in your list of gaps, and check the cover of the copy before concluding that one is absent.

The checklist gives December 1974. Issue 70 is dated October 1974 and issue 73 January 1975: the gap is two months before the double and one month after. The day of release is not recorded.

The checklist credits the comic, not the story: Frank Robbins, Cary Bates and Denny O'Neil on writing, Nick Cardy, Dick Giordano and Curt Swan on art. It is impossible to assign a name to "Incredulity" alone without opening the copy.

No. The data gives numbers, dates and credits, not reasons. What the checklist shows is that issue 75, dated March 1975, is its last entry; the cause of the stop is not recorded there.