Strange Spécial Origines 229 hors série: same day as Strange 229, article illustration

The Strange Spécial Origines listing opens, on the Semic side, with an issue labelled "229 hors série", dated January 5, 1989. The monthly Strange no. 229 carries exactly the same date. The two issues therefore share a number and a day, and in the label only the mention "hors série" (special issue) separates them. The listing gives only one story title per issue: it proves the identity of the object, not its contents.

In a list of gaps, the line "229" is ambiguous. It designates the first Strange of the Semic era, and it also designates a second issue, dated the same day, which the listing distinguishes by two words. For anyone completing a collection, the whole task is not to confuse the two.

As always in this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is ours, with no reproduction of artwork or protected dialogue.

The key dated facts given in this article about Strange Spécial Origines 229 hors série

What the listing states about the "229 hors série"

The catalogue entry is brief. The issue is labelled "229 hors série", its cover date is January 5, 1989, and the publisher is Semic. The recorded story title is "Que la lumière soit". The credited writers are Jim Starlin, Mike Friedrich and Jim Shooter, and the artists Léon, Jean-Yves Mitton and Bob Hall.

These credits belong to the issue, not to an episode: three names on writing and three on art signal a contents with several stories, but the listing does not say who wrote which. Taking "Que la lumière soit" as the entire contents would be a misreading, and this page will not do it.

The same day as Strange no. 229

The monthly Strange no. 229 is also dated January 5, 1989. Its story title is "Conflit de dames", its writers are Bill Mantlo, David Michelinie and Bob Layton, and its artists Bob Layton, Terry Shoemaker and Alex Saviuk. Between the two issues, no name overlaps, neither on writing nor on art: these are not two editions of the same contents, they are two distinct objects bearing the same number.

The pairing holds almost everywhere in the series of specials. Of the 24 issues labelled "hors série", 23 fall in the same month as the Strange carrying the same number. Twelve carry a cover date identical word for word; eleven others give only the month while the Strange gives "5"; only one falls outside the pattern, 280, dated April 1993 against a Strange dated March 5, 1993. The 229 belongs to the twelve cases where the full date is identical on both sides.

Context: Semic's first delivery

The monthly Strange of the previous publisher ends with number 228, dated December 5, 1988. The 229 is the first number that the listing attributes to Semic. The special follows the same break: the Lug listing of Strange Spécial Origines, opening with "133 bis", ends at 226, dated October 5, 1988, and the Semic listing resumes at 229.

The 229 hors série is therefore the first issue of the series under the new publisher, dated the very day the monthly changes hands. None of the 32 issues of the previous listing carries the mention "hors série": it appears with the resumption, not before. What is not known is why: the listing notes the mention, it does not give the reason, and the sources differ on this point.

A step of three, from 229 to 304

After 229, the listing continues with 232, then 235, then 238, and keeps going in steps of three. The 24 "hors série" issues thus run from 229 to 298, and each gap is three. The magazine therefore appears every three months, one special for three monthlies. Between 229 and 298, Strange counts 70 numbers for 24 specials: 46 monthly numbers have no twin.

This rhythm is also readable in the dates: 229 on January 5, 232 in April, 235 on July 5, 238 in October. The Strange issues 230, 231, 233 and 234 fall in between and have no counterpart. To complete a series, the step of three is the best tool: up to 304, an expected number that does not fall at 229 plus a multiple of three is not part of this series.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Strange Spécial Origines 229 hors série: the sections of this guide, in reading order

Reading "hors série" as the sole criterion: the trap

If you search for "all issues marked hors série", you stop at 298. But the listing continues at the same step: 301, dated January 1995, then 304, dated April 1995, follow the same cadence of three and the same pairing with Strange, without carrying the mention. That makes 26 issues at this step, from 229 to 304, of which only 24 are labelled "hors série".

The "mention" criterion is therefore too narrow by two issues. A collector who sorts their listings on these words will miss 301 and 304, which no longer have a label to distinguish them from the monthly with the same number. The right criterion is the pair "number" and "step of three", the mention being only a readable clue as long as it exists.

After 304: the number stops being shared

From 305 onward, the listing changes regime. The numbers follow one another one by one, 305, 306 up to 313, and the dates advance two months at a time: June 1995 for 305, August for 306. The same number on the Strange side is then dated May 1995 and then June 1995, and the gap widens to nine months at 313, October 1996 against January 1996.

The pairing that made 229 a simple case, same number and same day, therefore holds only for the start of the whole. Of the 35 issues in the listing, 24 carry the mention, 2 follow without it, and 9 are already in the other regime. Saying "the same day as the monthly" is accurate for 229 and eleven other specials, approximate for eleven where only the month is given, and wrong for 280 and from 305 onward.

Recognising the copy and recording it in a gap list

What the listing allows you to check on the object: the number, the "hors série" mention next to it, the cover date of January 5, 1989, the publisher's name. It does not allow you to check the contents, nor to assert that a character makes its first French appearance in this issue: the title "Que la lumière soit" is only one title among those of the issue. Open the copy and read its printed table of contents.

For the gap list, write the line in full: "Strange Spécial Origines 229 hors série, January 5, 1989". The line "229" alone is ambiguous, and a duplicate bought by mistake is precisely what this ambiguity produces. The advice applies to other paired numbers, for example 232, whose title "Qui est Daredevil ?" is the only content clue the listing provides.

As for condition, these are 1989 issues: watch the corners and the spine. Finally, check that the issue is not the monthly with the same number, since confusion is easy on an advertisement photo taken from a distance.

Strange Spécial Origines 229 hors série: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

No. Both carry the date January 5, 1989, but their story titles and credits differ entirely in the listing. "Que la lumière soit" designates the special, "Conflit de dames" the monthly. They are two objects to be acquired separately.

No. It appears on 24 issues, from 229 to 298, whereas 301 and 304 follow the same step of three without it. From 305 onward, the rhythm changes again. The number and the step of three are better markers than the mention alone.

The listing keeps only one story title, "Que la lumière soit", and credits at issue level. It gives neither a full contents list nor an American correspondence. To know what the copy contains, open it and read its table of contents.

The listing records the step, it does not give its cause. One can only read that a special takes the numbering of the monthly and appears one month in three, from 229 to 304. The sources differ on the editorial reasons, and the page offers none.

Look for the "hors série" mention on the cover or in the description, and ask for a photo of the spine or the contents. Then note the full line, with the date January 5, 1989, in your gap list so you do not confuse it with the monthly.