In the catalogue listing, Spécial Strange No. 14 and No. 18 carry the same cover date, 10 December 1978, although three issues sit between them. The dates of Nos. 12 to 20 rise steadily, except at No. 18, the only step backwards among the 59 entries. No. 18 is therefore probably the misdated one, most likely with a wrong year. This is a calendar hypothesis, not proof: only the copy settles it.
You file your Spécial Strange by cover date, and two issues compete for the same December 1978 slot. One is No. 14, the other No. 18, separated by three issues. This page explains where the collision comes from and how to avoid reproducing it in your own filing.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact. The analysis is our own, with no reproduction of any panel or protected dialogue.
What the listing states for No. 14 and No. 18
No. 14 of Spécial Strange is dated 10 December 1978 in the listing, under the story title "Une source d'énergie : le Soleil" (A source of energy: the Sun).
No. 18 carries exactly the same date, 10 December 1978, under the title "Navette spatiale" (Space shuttle). These are not neighbouring months: the day, the month and the year coincide, whereas Nos. 15, 16 and 17 fall between the two entries by their rank.
The credits, given at the level of the issue, do not look like those of a single issue entered twice. On No. 14, the credited writers are Chris Claremont, Len Wein and Scott Edelman, and the art is credited to Jean Frisano, Dave Cockrum and Gil Kane.
On No. 18, we read Yves Chantereau, Chris Claremont and Gerry Conway for the text, and Patricia Chantereau, Jean Frisano and Dave Cockrum for the art. Only one person is common on the writing side: Claremont. These are indeed two issues, not a data-entry duplicate.
The calendar of Nos. 12 to 20
To judge a date, you have to place it in sequence. Here is what the listing gives, issue by issue.
- No. 12: 10 June 1978
- No. 13: 10 August 1978
- No. 14: 10 December 1978
- No. 15: 10 April 1979
- No. 16: 10 June 1979
- No. 17: 10 August 1979
- No. 18: 10 December 1978
- No. 19: 10 March 1980
- No. 20: 10 June 1980
The gaps between consecutive issues run from two to four months up to No. 17. Then the sequence breaks: from 17 to 18 the date moves back eight months; from 18 to 19 it jumps forward fifteen months.
Without No. 18, the gap from 17 to 19 is seven months, roughly two of the usual three-month steps for a single issue inserted between them: that looks far less aberrant, and it is what points to No. 18 as the line to examine.
What the rhythm reveals: the magazine appears in cycles of four, with gaps of three, two, four then three months (March, June, August, December, with April in place of March in 1979). A step back of eight months belongs to none of these gaps.
Which of the two is probably misdated
No. 14 slots in cleanly: August 1978 before it, April 1979 after it, and a December that completes the 1978 cycle. No. 18, on the other hand, is the only issue in the listing, out of 59 entries, whose date is earlier than that of the line preceding it. It is therefore the suspect, not No. 14.
A count by year supports this reading. From 1976 to 1985, the listing has four issues per calendar year in every case except two.
The year 1978 lists five, including No. 18; the year 1979 has only three. With No. 18 moved one year later, each of the two years would fall back to four issues, and the gaps towards No. 17 and then towards No. 19 would be four months then three, those of the ordinary cycle.
A hypothesis, then, and named as such: a year error on this issue, which would be 1979. The listing contains no other trace that could prove it.
Listing fact, hypothesis, and what nobody proves here
What is a listing fact: the two entries carry the same date, and a single line out of 59 steps backwards. What is a calendar deduction: the cycle of four issues a year, which the listing lets us measure. What is a hypothesis: that the year given for No. 18 is wrong and that the right one is 1979.
The listing does not say where the error lies. Three readings remain open: the copy itself carries a wrong year, the catalogue entry misreads a correct date, or the issue really came out in December 1978, which remains unlikely since Nos. 15, 16 and 17 are dated after it. Saying otherwise would be inventing.
A weak clue, not to be overloaded: in the window of Nos. 12 to 20, Gerry Conway is credited on Nos. 15, 16, 17 and 18, and on none of the other nine issues. The credits of No. 18 therefore sit alongside those of the 1979 issues, not those of No. 14. The credits are attached to the issue and follow its rank; they prove nothing about the date.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
The immediate neighbours: 16, 17 and 19
No. 16 (10 June 1979) is titled "Les jeux de l'Araignée" (The Spider's games); No. 17 (10 August 1979), "Les mots croisés... de la Chose..." (Crosswords... of the Thing...).
These are the two lines that precede No. 18 by rank, and it is towards their date that No. 18 would have to move. No. 19 (10 March 1980), titled "Ces drôles de machines volantes" (Those funny flying machines), comes after the break.
A reader's remark: some titles, for example those of Nos. 12, 14, 15, 18 and 19 (the planet Mars, the Sun, geothermal energy, the space shuttle, flying machines), read like subject headings. The listing does not say what they cover, and a single title per issue does not allow the contents to be described. For the collector, they offer one thing: a marker to identify the issue, nothing more.
Checking the copy and the date on the object
The issue number printed on the cover is the most reliable datum: it is what identifies No. 18, whatever date is attached to it. Then check whether the copy carries a date or year mention, and compare it with the 10 December 1978 of the listing. Note what you actually read, not what you expect to read.
If the copy says 1979, the error is in the catalogue. If the copy does say 1978, the calendar hypothesis falls, and No. 18 deserves checking against other copies. In both cases, do not correct a record on the logic of the cycle alone: the deduction points the way, the object decides.
Entering No. 18 in a list of gaps
If you sort by date, No. 18 slots in between No. 14 and No. 15, and the list appears complete even though a December may be missing from the 1979 calendar. If you sort by number, the trap disappears: the run from 14 to 19 reads without any visible gap.
The simple rule: number first, date second, and note the disputed date of No. 18 in the margin rather than settling it. For a condition assessment or an estimate, the date collision does not change what you hold: a copy precisely identified by its number.
Frequently asked questions
No. The story titles differ ("Une source d'énergie : le Soleil" and "Navette spatiale"), the credits differ too, and three issues sit between the two by rank. Only the cover date in the listing coincides.
Probably No. 18, the only line in the listing whose date moves backwards. Nos. 15, 16 and 17 are dated 1979, which places No. 18 later. This is a calendar hypothesis, which only the copy can confirm.
The one your copy carries. Failing that, keep the 10 December 1978 of the listing and mention the doubt, rather than replacing it with a deduced date that nothing proves.
Nothing suggests it: the numbers run from 14 to 19 without a gap. Only the date of No. 18 is in question. If the year were 1979, the calendar would on the contrary be complete.
It can be estimated, to within a few months, because the magazine follows a cycle of four issues a year. But that is a deduction; the actual date is read on the object, not calculated.