Few cases in comics market history match New Mutants #98's meteoric rise. Published in March 1991 in near-total indifference — the market's attention was then on variant covers and "special" issues — this comic nonetheless contained something exceptional: the very first appearance of Deadpool, the character created by Rob…
For informational purposes only: This information is provided for educational purposes only. My Comics Collection is not an investment advisor. Values vary with condition, scarcity and market trends.
Few cases in comics market history match New Mutants #98's meteoric rise. Published in March 1991 in near-total indifference — the market's attention was then on variant covers and "special" issues — this comic nonetheless contained something exceptional: the very first appearance of Deadpool, the character created by Rob Liefeld and Fabian Nicieza who would become one of the most popular Marvel superheroes of his generation.
In 2026, after two monster-hit films with Ryan Reynolds and a third installment (Deadpool & Wolverine) that broke global box office records, New Mutants #98 has become a must-have key issue, and its value directly reflects that enthusiasm. This complete guide explains what this copy is worth, how to avoid the traps (and there are many on this title), and what the outlook is for the months ahead.
The story of New Mutants #98: the birth of a cult anti-hero
In 1991, The New Mutants is a second-tier series at Marvel. Created in 1982 as an extension of the X-Men franchise, it focuses on the new generation of mutants at Professor Xavier's school. By 1991, the series is near the end of its life — it will end at issue 100 to make way for X-Force, the more aggressive new team imagined by Rob Liefeld.
In that transition context, New Mutants #98 is published. Liefeld, then one of Marvel's most visible artists despite his controversial style, introduces two new characters: Deadpool, a masked mercenary in red and black with swords and pistols, and Domino, a sharpshooter with the power to manipulate luck. A third character, Gideon, also makes his first appearance in this issue.
At the time of its release, this comic was essentially worthless. Mint copies bought at $1.75 on newsstands would have cost less than $5 at collector sales in the following years. It took until the 2010s and especially the 2016 Deadpool film announcement for collectors to start realizing what they had — or what they had thrown out.
Triple key issue: New Mutants #98 (March 1991) contains the 1st appearance of Deadpool, the 1st appearance of Domino and the 1st appearance of Gideon. That density of first appearances makes it one of the richest key issues of the 1990s.
Current New Mutants #98 CGC values in 2026
New Mutants #98 has a different valuation structure from Golden Age and Silver Age comics: copies were printed in very large quantities (several hundred thousand), but demand for maximum CGC grades (9.8 and 9.6) remains extraordinarily strong, which keeps prices high at those levels.
| CGC grade | Condition | Estimated 2026 value |
|---|---|---|
| CGC 10.0 (Gem Mint) | Absolute perfection | $25,000 – $50,000+ |
| CGC 9.8 (NM/MT) | Near perfect | $4,000 – $8,000 |
| CGC 9.6 (NM+) | Excellent | $800 – $1,500 |
| CGC 9.4 (NM) | Very Good+ | $250 – $500 |
| CGC 9.2 (NM-) | Good+ | $100 – $200 |
| CGC 9.0 (VF/NM) | Very Fine | $60 – $120 |
| Raw (ungraded) | Variable | $30 – $150 |
The NM #98 price structure is characteristic of high-print-run Modern Age keys: 9.8 and above grades concentrate most of the value, with a spectacular gap between a 9.8 ($4,000-8,000) and a 9.6 ($800-1,500). This value concentration on maximum grades reflects collector demand for the best possible copy of a comic that exists in thousands of lesser-condition copies.
How Deadpool made NM #98's value explode
New Mutants #98's value rise is directly correlated to Deadpool's cinematic trajectory. It's one of the most documented correlations in the modern comics market:
- 2009: X-Men Origins: Wolverine, Deadpool appears controversially. Low impact on values.
- 2014-2015: Solo Deadpool film announcement with Ryan Reynolds. First significant rise — CGC 9.8s go from ~$200 to $500-800.
- 2016: Deadpool release, record for an R-rated film. CGC 9.8s explode to $1,000-2,000.
- 2018: Deadpool 2, new rise. 9.8s reach $2,000-3,500.
- 2024: Deadpool & Wolverine, all-time R-rated box office record. 9.8s hit $5,000-8,000.
The lesson of this trajectory is clear: major Deadpool film releases have systematically pushed prices higher. And with Deadpool now integrated into the MCU, new projects are inevitable, which maintains structural buying pressure on this issue.
Track your New Mutants #98's value
My Comics Collection aggregates sales data in real time for your Deadpool key issues. Get an alert the moment a reference sale lands for your CGC grade.
Start freeFree trial, no credit card required
Pitfalls to avoid on New Mutants #98
New Mutants #98 is one of the most counterfeited, overrated and misrepresented comics on the market. Its popularity with unwary buyers makes it a prime target for unscrupulous sellers. Here are the most common traps:
The overrated-condition trap
Copies presented as "NM" or "Near Mint" in open eBay sales can actually be CGC 8.0 or 8.5 once seriously examined. Spine stress, small color loss and cover micro-damage are often minimized by non-professional sellers.
The cover "cleaning" trap
Some sellers chemically clean covers to make them brighter and appear in better condition. This practice is undetectable to the naked eye but is caught by CGC and results in a "Conserved Applied" designation or downgrade. Ideally buy copies already graded by CGC.
The "guaranteed CGC 9.8" trap
Some sellers claim their copy "would grade a 9.8" without having graded it. Nothing guarantees a CGC grade before official examination. A copy that looks perfect can receive a 9.4 for a reason imperceptible to a lay visual examination. Never pay a 9.8 price for an ungraded copy.
The reprint trap
Reprints and trade paperbacks reproduce NM #98's content. Always check the copyright date and the indicia (the small-print legal notices at the bottom of the page) to confirm you have the original March 1991 edition, not a later reprint.
The outlook for New Mutants #98 in 2026
With Deadpool & Wolverine confirming Deadpool's integration into the MCU, the outlook for NM #98 remains very positive. Marvel Studios has clearly indicated Wade Wilson will be a recurring Phase 6 character, which means regular announcements that could fuel fresh demand spikes.
The most rational strategy for a collector on this title in 2026 depends on the goal:
- To collect: A raw (ungraded) copy in good visual condition lets you own this key issue for $50 to $150. Inspect the condition carefully before buying.
- To appreciate a copy already owned: If you have a copy that looks in excellent condition, having it graded by CGC can multiply its value 10 or 20x if the result is a 9.8.
- To invest: CGC 9.8s remain the most liquid asset class on this title. MCU announcements create opportunity windows both on buying (before the peaks) and selling (during post-announcement peaks).
Key facts about New Mutants #98 (1991)
- 1st appearance of Deadpool, Domino and Gideon, by Rob Liefeld and Fabian Nicieza
- Published March 1991, Modern Age, high print run
- CGC 9.8: estimated value $4,000 – $8,000 in 2026
- Spectacular rise since 2014, tied to Deadpool films
- Many pitfalls: overrated condition, chemical cleaning, reprints
- Further upside potential from future Deadpool MCU projects
FAQ: New Mutants #98, your most common questions
Value alerts on your Deadpool key issues
Set up your custom alerts on My Comics Collection and be the first notified when major sales set the reference for your New Mutants #98 CGC grade.
Try freeOver 15,000 collectors trust My Comics Collection