Two issues of Hulk carry the number 16 in the catalogue. The one from the 1976 series is dated June 1981 and follows a no. 15 dated December 1978: thirty months separate the two covers. The one from the 1992 series is dated October 1994 and has only one writer. The cover date, the publisher named and the number of credited writers are enough to tell them apart when you see a listing.
A lot of Hulk advertised as "no. 16" is not an identified lot. The same number designates here two objects separated by more than thirteen years, and a want list that only notes "Hulk 16" exposes you to buying the wrong one.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact. The analysis is ours, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
The 1976 series: what the catalogue says about its no. 16
In the series launched in 1976 by Arédit-Artima, no. 16 carries the cover date June 1981. Its story title is "Hulk!", and it is the only title in the record reduced to the simple name of the series: all the others name something other than the series ("Submariner", "Cosmos", "Conan", "Thor").
Credits are given at the level of the issue: three writers (Len Wein, Roy Thomas, Tony Isabella) and three artists (Keith Giffen, Gil Kane, Sal Buscema). The record does not say who wrote or drew what, since it logs only one story title per issue. Three names opposite "writing" therefore describe the object, not an episode.
The break: thirty months between two covers
No. 15 is dated December 1978, no. 16 June 1981. No issue in the record carries a cover dated between January 1979 and May 1981, that is twenty-nine months without a number. The numbering, for its part, does not waver: 15 is followed by 16, with no gap in the counter.
The break is all the more stark since the earlier rhythm was tight. From no. 10 (July 1978) to no. 15, six issues follow one another each month. The first fifteen numbers fit, moreover, into twenty-four months of covers, fewer than the single pause that follows. After the restart the rhythm is no longer the same: three months between no. 16 and no. 17 (September 1981), then twelve intervals of two months, from no. 17 of September 1981 to no. 29 of September 1983.
Why this pause? The record does not say, and we do not explain it. It only establishes that what follows carries a date, a rhythm and, as we shall see, a team different from what came before. For a collector, that is enough: no. 16 opens a second phase of the series, and it does not belong to the same era as its fifteen predecessors.
Credits that change with the date
The break shows in the names. Len Wein, absent from the first fifteen issues, is credited from no. 16 to no. 24, nine issues in a row, then no longer appears in the record at all. Herb Trimpe, for his part, is credited as penciller from no. 1 to no. 15 inclusive, without interruption; no. 16 is the first to go without him, and one must wait for no. 22 to find him again, after six issues without him.
The renewal is wide. The first fifteen issues draw on twelve artists, the next fourteen on twenty, of whom only five were already present before the break: Don Heck, Gil Kane, Herb Trimpe, Sal Buscema and Steve Ditko. Among writers, three names spelled identically cross the break: Roy Thomas, Stan Lee and Larry Lieber. No. 16 is the only issue after the pause that carries Roy Thomas, and Tony Isabella appears nowhere else in the record.
A reading precaution: count by person, not by character string. The word "Buscema" comes back twenty times in the art credits, but it covers Sal Buscema (eighteen issues) and John Buscema (two, nos. 17 and 22). These are two artists, not one.
The 1992 series: one issue without a break
In the series launched in 1992 by Semic S.A., no. 16 is dated October 1994 and is titled "Fournaise". The script is by Peter David, the art by Gary Frank and Paul Pelletier. Nothing in this issue marks it as a border: it falls in the middle of a period of continuity.
The 1992 record is almost monotonously regular: twenty-eight intervals of two months between April 1992 and December 1996, from start to finish of the record. Peter David is credited on all twenty-nine issues and alone as writer on twenty-eight of them, no. 19 adding Barry Dutter. Gary Frank draws thirteen consecutive numbers, from no. 11 to no. 23, and no. 16 is the sixth of them; Paul Pelletier accompanies him only from no. 14 to no. 17, four numbers.
These are two objects of opposite nature: one is the first issue after a pause, which largely renews the team; the other an ordinary issue in a long sequence by a single writer. The only thing they share is the number, and the word Hulk.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
Telling them apart in a listing
Four checks, from most to least reliable. First the cover date: June 1981 for the 1976 series, October 1994 for the 1992 one. A listing that files the 1976 no. 16 under "the seventies" is wrong, since the pause pushed it to 1981. Next the publisher's name: Arédit-Artima on one side, Semic S.A. on the other. Third, the credits: three writers or just one. Finally the story title from the catalogue, "Hulk!" or "Fournaise".
Ask for a photo of the cover, one of the credits page and, if possible, the contents page. A listing that shows only the spine of the issue proves nothing about the series. A seller who answers "1981" or "1994" to the date question is in fact answering the question of which series it is.
What the record cannot tell
For these two numbers, the catalogue gives neither a full contents page, nor a verified first French appearance of a character, nor a match with an American issue. It does not give prices either: we write none. Credits are those of the issue, not of the episode, and the story title is only one title among several.
It must also be recalled that a record is not the whole series. Each of the two records counts twenty-nine issues, nos. 1 to 29 for the 1976 series as for the 1992 one, and we write "in the record" each time a sentence concerns an absence: what the catalogue does not show may exist on a copy. The contents of your issue remain to be checked on the object.
Noting these two numbers on a want list
The remedy fits on one line: write the series with its launch year, the publisher and the cover date. "Hulk (1976), no. 16, June 1981" and "Hulk (1992), no. 16, October 1994" do not get confused, and sorting by date then places each in its right position in your run.
Look at the neighbours too. In the 1976 series, around no. 16, no. 15 ("Thor", December 1978) belongs to the period before the pause and no. 17 ("Télé Junior", September 1981) to the period after. In the 1992 series, around no. 16, no. 15 ("Premier sang") and no. 17 ("L'héritier") continue the same team two months apart. If you are completing the 1976 series, treat no. 16 as the hinge: no. 15 and no. 16 did not follow each other in time. The guides on the Hulk page help you place what follows.
Frequently asked questions
Yes, in the catalogue: a no. 16 from the 1976 series, dated June 1981, and a no. 16 from the 1992 series, dated October 1994. Both share the same series title and number, but not the same publisher or team.
Because no issue in the record carries a date between those two covers: twenty-nine months without a number. The catalogue records the pause but does not give the reason, and we do not reconstruct it.
On writing, Peter David alone. On art, Gary Frank and Paul Pelletier. Peter David is credited on all twenty-nine issues of the 1992 record; the story title of no. 16 is "Fournaise".
The catalogue does not allow us to say so. It gives a single story title, "Hulk!", and credits at the level of the issue. The full contents and the first French appearance of a character are checked on the copy, not in the record.
Require the cover date and the publisher's name before any purchase: June 1981 and Arédit-Artima for 1976, October 1994 and Semic S.A. for 1992. The number of credited writers (three or one) then settles it, from a photo of the credits page.