The first issue of Facteur X is dated September 1989 and opens with a story titled "A Day's Power", written by Walter and Louise Simonson, with Walter Simonson and Ciro Tota on art according to the catalogue. It is a recent comic by newsstand-magazine standards, so it is expected in fine condition, and its identification rests on the masthead and the numbering, not on the date, which is rarely legible.
You come across a listing that promises "issue 1 of Facteur X". The question is not whether the magazine mattered, it ran to forty-four releases. The question is whether the copy in the photo is really that one, what condition it is in, and why two copies that look identical do not trade for the same price. This article deals only with that precise object: the 1989 opening issue, the one that is bought, handled and shelved.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of any panel or protected dialogue.
The issue: what the first release actually carries
The catalogue ties the first release of Facteur X to September 1989 and associates it with a story titled "A Day's Power". That is the first thing to remember, because it is the only element that depends neither on the condition of the paper nor on the seller: a story title is an identifier. If a listing shows a contents page, check this entry first. It will tell you more than a photo of the spine, which is always flattering.
The same record credits Walter Simonson and Louise Simonson on writing, and Walter Simonson with Ciro Tota on art. This pairing is instructive. The mutant series of the late eighties were written for the most part by Louise Simonson in the early years of the French magazine, and the joint presence of both signatures on this single release makes it a rather particular starting point, rather than an ordinary early issue.
As for Ciro Tota, his name in the credits of a French newsstand comic does not get confused with any of the signatures that came from across the Atlantic. The catalogue attaches him to this issue without specifying the capacity in which he worked, and he reappears on several later releases. Keep him in mind as a French marker of the magazine, not as proof of the content inside.
What the known contents say, and what they do not
A French magazine of this format did not publish a single story per release. The record we have gives one title, not a contents list: "A Day's Power" is what we know, not what the copy holds. The episodes that complete the issue, the editorial pages, possible letters from readers, none of that appears in a catalogue entry.
This limit has a very concrete consequence. A seller who claims this issue contains a given French first appearance is asserting something that no entry confirms. You do not have to believe or contradict him: simply ask for a photograph of the printed contents, page by page if necessary. On an intact issue that page exists, and it is what settles the matter.
We therefore claim no match between this release and any given American publication. Not out of token caution, but because the information we hold does not support it, and a claim of that kind, copied from one listing to the next, ends up circulating as an established fact when it is only someone's deduction.
What sets it apart from the following releases
The second release is dated November 1989 and the third January 1990: the rhythm is one issue every two months, kept steadily through the first years. The number one therefore does not sit arbitrarily in the stack. It was launched on the newsstands without a readership in place, in a print run sized to a commercial hypothesis, whereas the later issues benefited from an audience already formed.
A second difference, less often noticed: the date. On most early releases, the month appears in the records within square brackets, a sign that it was reconstructed from the publication rhythm rather than read from the object. From the twenty-fifth release onward the month stops being conjectural, and on the very last ones only the year remains. In other words, do not expect to find "September 1989" printed somewhere on your copy, and do not conclude it is a fake if you cannot find it.
A third difference, editorial. The art credits change a great deal over the course of the series, and the reader buying a nineties release today often looks for a specific name. A number one, by contrast, is bought for what it is: the point of entry. The two reasons to buy do not add value in the same way, and that explains part of the price gaps observed between neighboring issues.
Recognizing a genuine first issue in a listing
Start with the number, but do not stop there. The masthead must carry the title of the magazine and an isolated issue number, with no mention of volume, new series or range of numbers. A cover announcing several issues at once is not a single release but a bundle.
Then look at the spine. A newsstand issue of this period is held by two staples and shows a fold, not a squared glued spine. A flat, wide spine with a title printed along its height indicates something else: a publisher's collection, often made of three releases gathered under a clean cover and numbered separately. These collections have their interest, but they are not issue one and cannot be compared to it.
A third reflex, the simplest: require the back cover and the edge in the same set of photos as the front. Many listings show only the front, precisely because it is the best preserved. Two extra shots eliminate most bad surprises before any money changes hands.
Possible confusions, and how to clear them up
The first confusion comes from the publisher itself. The catalogue ties the whole series to Semic, and that period saw several titles devoted to the same mutant teams sitting side by side on the newsstands. A seller acting in good faith who clears out an attic may present as "the mutants number 1" a first release that is not this one. The exact title, read on the cover rather than in the listing, is enough to remove the doubt.
The second confusion is with the neighboring title. The same characters appeared in other magazines of the time, sometimes in episodes very close in chronology, and their contents overlapped. A reader looking for a specific story may find it somewhere other than where he thought, and the reverse is true too: "A Day's Power" is tied to this release, not to another.
The third confusion is with reprints. A release that came out later, or a foreign version of the same title, does not carry the same legal notices. Look for the printing notice, the joint commission number where one exists, and the price printed on the cover. Not for its value, which does not concern us here, but because an unexpected currency or wording immediately gives away a different edition.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
What to look at on the copy before buying
Three points decide almost everything on a stapled issue. The staples first: check whether they are still in place, whether they have rusted, and whether the paper around them has torn under the weight of the pages. A rusted staple stains its neighbors irreversibly, and it is the defect least often photographed.
Next, the fold of the spine. An issue that has been read and folded keeps a white mark along the spine edge, visible in raking light. Ask for a photo of the spine at a slight angle: you will see at a glance whether it was opened flat or rolled. Finally, the flatness of the cover, since a copy stored horizontally under a pile stays straight, whereas a copy standing upright in a box that is too wide cockles along the bottom.
Last, check completeness, point by point. A newsstand issue sometimes included detachable advertising pages, and it is not rare for a reader to have removed a central page. Count the pages if they are printed, and if they are not, simply ask whether the central booklet is still there.
The condition to expect from a 1989 issue
This is where this issue differs most clearly from older magazines. A September 1989 issue has not crossed decades: it was bought by readers who, for many of them, were already collecting consciously and knew how to store things. Copies in very fine condition are therefore not rare finds to hunt for years; they exist, and you can afford to wait.
The consequence for negotiation is direct. On a sixties magazine, a corner defect is tolerated because the alternative is never finding a better copy. Here, the alternative exists. A creased, color-faded or unstapled copy is not an acceptable placeholder, it is a reading copy, and it should be presented as such. Refusing a poor condition is not greed on a title from this period.
Be careful, however, with the paper itself. Newsstand paper from the late eighties yellows along the edge faster than one would think, especially if it was exposed to light or kept near a heat source. A perfectly flat copy can show a markedly browned edge: check the top edge in the photo, it is the most revealing.
What gives it its relative scarcity
This issue is not rare in the sense that postwar magazine hunters use the word. It is the first of a run of forty-four regularly distributed releases, and it circulates. Its relative difficulty rests on three mechanisms that need to be told apart, because they do not evolve in the same way.
The first mechanism is dispersal. Collections of this period were often sold in lots, and a lot missing its first issue resells poorly. Sellers therefore readily keep the number one aside, which makes it visible as a single item but rarely sold cheap. The second mechanism is concentration of demand. A buyer who wants to start the series wants this specific release, not the second, whereas the fortieth interests mainly the collector who is completing a run.
The third mechanism, the only one that really plays at the top of the market, is the quality of preservation. Since fine copies exist in numbers, the price gap between a correct condition and a very fine one widens rather than narrowing, because the demanding buyer has no reason to compromise. So reason in ratios between conditions, not in absolute amounts: it is the ratio that carries over from one marketplace to another.
Tracking this issue in a collection
A number one deserves its own record in your inventory, separate from the "complete series" line. Note three things: whether the central booklet is present, the condition of the staples, and the color of the top edge. These are the three parameters that will change over time if your storage is imperfect, and the only ones on which you can observe deterioration when you reread your record in five years.
Also note what you have checked in the contents, and what you have not. If you have read the printed contents page, record the stories it announces beyond "A Day's Power". That information is worth more than an estimate, because it does not go out of date and it is missing from almost every record available. A written log above all spares you from rebuying a copy you already own, a common accident when the covers look alike.
Conclusion
This September 1989 issue is identified by its story title and its masthead, judged by its staples and its edge, and bought knowing that fine copies still circulate. Do not attribute to it properties the records do not confirm, ask for the printed contents rather than trusting a description, and let a worn copy pass: on a magazine from this period, a better one will come along.
Frequently asked questions
The records tie it to September 1989, but that month appears there as a reconstruction, deduced from the magazine's bimonthly rhythm. Do not expect to find it printed on your copy. The next release is dated November of the same year, which confirms the two-month interval.
The catalogue credits Walter Simonson and Louise Simonson on writing, and Walter Simonson with Ciro Tota on art. The releases that immediately follow return overwhelmingly to Louise Simonson on writing, which makes this joint credit a singular starting point rather than an ordinary early issue of the series.
We do not claim so. The available records give one story title per release, "A Day's Power" for this one, whereas a magazine of this format published several. Any claim of a first appearance requires the printed contents page, which you can ask the seller for before buying.
By the spine. The single issue is held by two staples and has a simple fold. A publisher's collection has a squared spine, often with a title printed along its height, and carries its own numbering because it gathers several releases. A cover announcing a range of numbers also signals a bundle, not issue one.
Rarely, for a title launched in 1989. Many buyers at the time already stored their magazines carefully, and fresh copies still circulate. A stapled-off, cockled or browned-edge issue is a reading copy: keep it to read, and keep searching for the collection.