In September 2011, DC Comics launched the New 52 initiative: 52 new series simultaneously relaunched with fresh #1s, aiming to modernize the DC universe and attract new readers. Among all those series, one stood out so sharply that fifteen years later it has become an absolute reference in Batman comics history: Batman by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo.
In September 2011, DC Comics launched the New 52 initiative: 52 new series simultaneously relaunched with fresh #1s, aiming to modernize the DC universe and pull in new readers. Among all those series, one stood out so sharply it has become, fifteen years later, an absolute reference in Batman comics history: Batman by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo. Their run, spanning September 2011 to June 2016 across 52 issues (plus annuals and tie-ins), is universally recognized as the best Batman run since Frank Miller and one of the best superhero runs ever published.
At the heart of that run sit two major arcs: Court of Owls (Batman #1-11, 2011-2012) and Death of the Family (Batman #13-17, 2012-2013). This guide walks through the essential key issues from both arcs, the issues to acquire first, the most valuable variants and current 2026 market values.
Why the Snyder/Capullo run became canonical
To understand why these issues deserve to be collected, you have to first grasp what Snyder and Capullo accomplished. In 2011, Batman is a character weighed down by decades of tangled continuity. Scott Snyder makes a bold choice: invent an entirely new mythology for Gotham City, anchored in the city's history, one that could have always existed but had never been explored. The Court of Owls — a secret society that has controlled Gotham for centuries and that Batman has never suspected — is that invention.
Greg Capullo, for his part, brings a visual style of rare precision and expressiveness. His Batmen are dynamic, his urban compositions striking, his narrative paneling flawless. The Snyder/Capullo pairing produces a series where every issue is both a satisfying episode and an indispensable brick in a larger narrative structure. That's rare in modern superhero comics.
The run also hit exceptional sales levels for its era: Batman New 52 #1 sold over 200,000 copies on release, a staggering number for 2011. That high print run slightly tempers raw-copy scarcity, but ongoing demand continues to support prices on the key issues.
Court of Owls, Batman #1-11: key issues arc by arc
Batman New 52 #1 (2011), the foundational issue
Batman #1 of the New 52 (September 2011, Scott Snyder / Greg Capullo) is the defining issue of the run. This opening chapter sets up everything: Bruce Wayne is confident, master of Gotham, and absolutely certain the Court of Owls doesn't exist. That certainty is going to be systematically dismantled issue after issue. The first installment reintroduces Gotham's rogues gallery and ends on a shocking revelation about Dick Grayson.
In 2026, Batman New 52 #1 raw Near Mint trades between $45 and $135. In CGC 9.8 the range is $340 to $680. There are several cover variants (notably a Greg Capullo sketch variant) that committed collectors chase, and which can reach higher prices.
Watch the print run: Batman #1 of the New 52 was the best-selling DC comic in decades at release. Its high print run (over 200,000 copies) means it's easier to find in good shape than truly scarce issues. That doesn't diminish its collecting value, but it does temper scarcity expectations — it's not a hard-to-find NM book, which slightly caps its rarity upside.
Batman New 52 #2 (2011), first named appearance of the Talon
Batman #2 is a frequently overlooked but important key issue: it's the issue where the term "Talon" (the Court of Owls' assassin title) is used for the first time and where the first Talon is fully developed as a character. Batman discovers traces of an assassin who has killed a mayoral candidate and traces the path back to the Owls. The issue sets up the run's central threat in earnest.
In 2026, Batman #2 trades between $18 and $45 raw. Undervalued relative to its narrative importance.
Batman New 52 #5 (2012), the labyrinth arc
Batman #5 is unanimously cited as the best issue of the run and one of the best Batman issues ever published. Scott Snyder uses a brilliant narrative device: the pages rotate progressively to 90 degrees, then 180 degrees, symbolizing Bruce Wayne's disorientation as he's trapped in the Court of Owls' underground labyrinth. That formal innovation, carried by Capullo's layouts, makes it a unique editorial object.
This issue is more sought-after than #1 among connoisseurs. In 2026 it trades between $35 and $90 raw, and a CGC 9.8 can reach $225 to $450. The issue to grade if you only grade one.
Batman New 52 #8 (2012), start of "Night of the Owls"
Batman #8 launches the "Night of the Owls" crossover spanning the New 52's entire Batman line (Detective Comics, Batgirl, Nightwing, etc.). In this issue, the Court of Owls simultaneously releases dozens of Talons across Gotham to assassinate their enemies. A pure-action, epic-scale issue. The #8.1 ("Talon #0") is also sought-after by certain collectors.
Batman #8 trades between $14 and $40 raw in 2026. The first issue of the Night of the Owls crossover in the main title.
Batman New 52 #11 (2012), the Court of Owls finale
Batman #11 closes the Court of Owls arc with a major revelation about the true identity of the Court's leader. Without spoiling it, the conclusion calls into question Bruce Wayne's family history in a radical way. An emotionally powerful closing issue and a great entry point if you want to start with the end of the first arc before re-reading everything.
In 2026, Batman #11 trades between $12 and $35 raw — still very accessible for an issue of this quality.
Your Court of Owls checklist
Build your tracking list for the Snyder/Capullo Batman run, identify your missing issues and monitor their values in real time.
Start 14-day free trial, no commitmentDeath of the Family, Batman #13-17: the key issues
The Snyder/Capullo run's second major arc is "Death of the Family," published from October 2012 to February 2013. It marks the Joker's return after a year's absence (since Batman #1 of the New 52, where his face was cut off) and develops a threat against the entire Bat-Family. The most intense and psychologically disturbing Joker arc of the modern era.
Batman New 52 #13 (2012), the Joker's return
Batman #13 is one of the most important DC issues of the 2010s. It marks the Joker's return with his face reattached by a cord (an element introduced in Batgirl #1 of the New 52 where a cop hands his severed face back to him). The issue's opening — the Joker, in disguise, joining a radio show to murder everyone live — is one of the most memorable opening scenes in modern comics.
Batman #13 is the most sought-after issue of Death of the Family. In 2026 it trades between $28 and $80 raw, and a CGC 9.8 between $220 and $560. It's also the issue where Snyder manages to make the Joker genuinely terrifying — not comedic, not baroque, but viscerally frightening.
Batman New 52 #14-16 (2012-2013), the escalation
Issues #14, #15 and #16 develop the Joker's plan against the Bat-Family. Each issue calibrates the tension higher. Issue #15 contains a revelation about what the Joker claims to know regarding Batman's secret identity — a deliberately ambiguous reveal that has kept fans arguing since publication.
These issues trade between $9 and $28 raw each in 2026. Best acquired as a lot with #13 for the complete arc.
Batman New 52 #17 (2013), the conclusion
Batman #17 closes Death of the Family with a deliberately ambiguous ending: has the Joker really killed certain members of the Bat-Family? The answer is never shown directly, leaving the reader in uncertainty. The issue was divisive at release but is now considered a masterpiece of narrative manipulation.
Batman #17 trades between $12 and $35 raw in 2026. Often sold as a lot with the other issues in the arc.
Night of the Owls tie-ins worth collecting
The "Night of the Owls" crossover (April-May 2012) spans several Batman New 52 series. If you want to collect the complete event, here are the most important tie-ins:
- Detective Comics #9: Nightwing vs. Talon in Gotham's waters. One of the best tie-ins.
- Batman & Robin #9: Damian Wayne facing Mr. Freeze. A confrontation that enriches both characters.
- Batwing #9: African perspective on the Talon attack. An original tie-in but optional.
- All-Star Western #9: A flashback to the Court's origins in 19th-century Gotham. Excellent for DC history fans.
- Batman Annual #1 (2012): Snyder's reinterpretation of Mr. Freeze. Regularly cited as one of the best DC annuals of the decade.
Annual #1 is the most sought-after and valuable tie-in of the Night of the Owls event. In 2026, it trades between $18 and $55 raw. Snyder's Mr. Freeze reinterpretation is masterful and redefined the character for a generation.
Current prices and 2026 value summary
2026 price ranges, Snyder/Capullo Batman run (raw NM)
- Batman New 52 #1: $45 to $135
- Batman New 52 #2 (1st named Talon): $18 to $45
- Batman New 52 #5 (labyrinth arc): $35 to $90
- Batman New 52 #8 (start of Night of the Owls): $14 to $40
- Batman New 52 #11 (Court of Owls finale): $12 to $35
- Batman New 52 #13 (Joker's return): $28 to $80
- Batman Annual #1 (Mr. Freeze): $18 to $55
- Batman New 52 #17 (Death of the Family finale): $12 to $35
The Snyder/Capullo run has the advantage of being recent (published between 2011 and 2016) while already having achieved absolute classic status. Current prices are still accessible compared to other "modern classic" Marvel runs (Morrison's New X-Men, Bendis Avengers), but the trend is clearly upward, driven by growing critical recognition and the run's impact on DC adaptations.
How to collect the Snyder/Capullo run intelligently
Start with Batman #1, #5 and #13
These three issues are the run's pillars. Batman #1 for the opening, #5 for the best issue of Court of Owls, #13 for the launch of Death of the Family. Acquire them first, ideally in Near Mint or graded.
Complete the full arcs
Court of Owls (#1-11) and Death of the Family (#13-17) are two perfectly defined arcs. Each can be completed as a lot for a reasonable budget — look for "complete run" lots at conventions or on eBay.
Add Batman Annual #1
Batman Annual #1 (2012) is often left off checklists but is essential. Snyder's Mr. Freeze story is considered one of the best Batman stories ever published in annual format.
Grade Batman #5 first
If you only grade one issue of the run, pick Batman #5. Its formal innovation makes it a unique object, and its demand on the grading market is high. A CGC 9.8 is an excellent long-term investment.
FAQ, Court of Owls & Snyder/Capullo run
Manage your Snyder/Capullo Batman run
Track every issue of your Batman collection, identify your missing copies and monitor values in real time with My Comics Collection.
Start 14-day free trial, no commitment