The best betrayals in comics: the tier list — article illustration

The best betrayals in the history of comics are, at the top, that of Earth (The Judas Contract), Emma Frost , of Norman Osborn (Dark Reign) and the plan Ozymandias(Watchmen). This tier list ranks character betrayals according to their dramatic impact. Facts (stories, dates) verified, no invented odds; each entry refers to a record when it exists.

Betrayal is one of the most painful elements of comics: an ally who turns out to be an enemy, a broken trust. This tier list classifies betrayals according to their dramatic impact and their shock wave. Some have redefined entire teams.

Editorial Ranks, Facts verified. Each entry refers to a site file when it exists.

Tier list — the great betrayals
S
Terra (Judas Contract)DC, 1984 Emma FrostMarvel, 1980 Norman Osborn (Dark Reign)Marvel, 2008 OzymandiasWatchmen, 1987
A
Iron Man (Civil War)Marvel, 2006 Hank Pym (Ultron)Marvel, 1968 SabretoothMarvel, 1977 Bishop (hunting for Hope)Marvel, 2008
B
Doctor Octopus (Superior)Marvel, 2013 MysticalMarvel, 1978 Moira MacTaggertMarvel, 1975 MaestroMarvel, 1992
C
LokiMarvel, 1962 Namor (AvX)Marvel, 2012 Moonstone (Thunderbolts)Marvel, 1997 Cassandra NovaMarvel, 2001
D
Guy GardnerDC, 1968 HushDC, 2002 PrometheusDC, 1998

Tier S: legendary betrayals

The betrayal of Earth in “The Judas Contract” (1984) is the most famous: a young heroine undercover to destroy the Teen Titans.Emma Frost, long an enemy before joining the X-Men, embodies ambiguity. The takeover ofNorman Osborn(Dark Reign) and the planOzymandiasappear at the top.

Tier A: the gone become enemies

The position ofIron Manin Civil War, felt as a betrayal by many heroes;Hank Pym creating Ultron;Sabretoothet Bishop(tracking the child Hope) mark this tier.

Tier B: camp reversals

Doctor Octopus stealing Spider-Man's body (Superior Spider-Man),Mystical(permanent manipulator),Moira MacTaggert and Maestro(the Hulk of the future) complete the selection.

Tier C: notable traitors

Loki(god of betrayal),Namor (AvX), Moonstone (Thunderbolts) and Cassandra Nova are among the notable traitors.

Tier D: memorable betrayals

Guy Gardner , Hush(Bruce Wayne's childhood friend) and Prometheus close this tier list: more punctual but very real betrayals.

To remember

Frequently asked questions

The betrayal of Earth in “The Judas Contract” (Teen Titans, 1984) is the most famous, an undercover heroine revealed as a traitor at the worst moment.

A betrayal is a character act (an ally changing sides); a plot twist is a broader narrative revelation. The two sometimes overlap, as with Terra.

Yes: Emma Frost, former enemy of the X-Men, has become one of their major members. The redemption of a traitor is a frequent and appreciated narrative spring.

Do you have a Grand Betrayal key number (Tales of the Teen Titans…)?Estimate its value for freewith our tool based on real eBay sales.