Swamp Thing (2019) versus Alan Moore's comics

The most brutal cancellation of the corpus, and the most foreign to the work. Decryption source by source, without disclosing the outcomes.

As in each article in this series, only verified information (creators, distribution, dates, publishers) is stated; the comparative analysis is ours, without reproducing dialogue or protected images.

1971: one swamp monster among others

Swamp Thing appears in House of Secrets #92 (1971), created by Len Wein and Bernie Wrightson. It's a short story, in a horror anthology title, and its plot is classic: a man dies in a swamp and comes back transformed.

The story made enough of an impact for the character to get his series. Its premise is then firmly established: a scientist, Alec Holland, whose body has merged with vegetation, and who seeks to become human again.

It's a good premise for a horror series, and it held up for about ten years. However, it contains a limit: the quest for a return to humanity imposes a status quo. The character must fail indefinitely or the series ends.

1984: the revelation that changes everything

This is where one of the most commented upon gestures in the history of the medium takes place.

Alan Moore takes up the title and publishes, in Saga of the Swamp Thing #21(1984), an episode entitled "The Anatomy Lesson". He reverses the premise: the creature is not transformed Alec Holland. It's a plant who absorbed the consciousness of a dead man and believed herself to be human.

The difference seems subtle; it is total. The character ceases to be a man trying to become himself again, and becomes a being who has never been human and must admit it. The impossible quest turns into a question of identity — and the status quo that blocked the series disappears.

This issue is also a textbook case of what an author can do when taking over an existing series. Moore did not contradict anything: all the facts published since 1971 remain true. He only proposed another reading. It is the most elegant form of recovery, and the rarest.

2019: adapt the reveal, not the premise

The 2019 series makes a structuring choice: it integrates the 1984 revelation early, instead of replaying thirteen years of waiting to get there.

This is the right choice, and it sheds light on a general problem with adaptations. A revelation that shocked readers in 1984 cannot produce the same effect on a viewer in 2019 – first because it is known, then because it only has force in relation to the premise that it overturns, a premise that the viewer has never taken for granted.

Rather than artificially reconstituting a dead expectation, the series treats the revelation as a starting point. She therefore adapts the state of the character after Moore, without adapting Moore's gesture.

This corpus encountered the same difficulty with regard toWatchmen, resolved differently — by a sequel. The two series, in the same year, from the same publisher, hit the same wall: what to do with a work whose effect was based on a surprise that no one has anymore?

The characters, from paper to screen

• Swamp Thing— Treated according to the 1984 revelation, not according to 1971.
• Abby Arcane— Health investigator, expanded role for the screen.
• Doctor Woodrue— The scientist from the “anatomy lesson.”
• The Green— The plant network, central concept of the Moore era.
• The swamp— Setting and character at the same time, as on paper.

A cancellation of a new kind

This corpus keeps a list of reasons for interruption, and this case adds the strangest one.

The precedents were rights, toy sales, regulation, branding, programming, the financial situation of a publisher, and once an editorial choice of the series itself. None were narrative.

Here, the series is canceled after the broadcast of the first episode, while ten had already been shot. The decision could therefore not be based either on the audience – non-existent – ​​or on the reception – unknown. It was due to the economy of the platform which distributed it, in a context of industrial reorganization.

This is the purest case of the demonstration that this corpus has constructed batch after batch:what decides the fate of an adaptation almost never concerns it. Here, the link is even formally impossible — the decision is prior to any reception.

A practical consequence arises from this for the spectator. The ten episodes exist and form a whole that holds together, because they were designed as a complete season. This is not a series interrupted while writing: it is a completed season which has not been followed up. The nuance changes everything for those who hesitate to look at it.

Horror, a register that adaptations avoid

A word about genre, because it constitutes the other singularity of the series.

Swamp Thing belongs to the horror, not the superhero. This has been true since 1971, and Moore has only accentuated this belonging by adding an ecological and metaphysical dimension.

But horror is almost absent from comic book adaptations. The reasons are commercial: the target audience is narrower, classifications limit distribution, and the genre does not support the family format. This corpus examined a few exceptions —Constantine,Doom Patrol— but they remain rare.

The 2019 series assumes this register, with practical rather than digital effects — a coherent choice, because horror relies on material and texture, two things that synthesis hardly renders.

For the reader, this is an invitation to explore a little-known part of the catalog. DC's horror titles from the 1970s and 1980s - including those from the Vertigo line that emerged from it - are among the best in the medium and remain significantly less expensive than superhero titles from the same era, due to lack of adaptation.

Collection side: which numbers to aim for after the series

House of Secrets #92(1971) contains the first appearance of Swamp Thing. This is an important Bronze Age key, carried by Bernie Wrightson's cover, considered one of the finest of the decade. Its rating is high for an anthology title, precisely because of this cover.

Saga of the Swamp Thing #21(1984) is the number to aim for first, and it's an excellent deal. It contains “The Anatomy Lesson” – one of the most commented episodes of the medium – and yet is at a modest price: print run from the 1980s, therefore abundant, on a title which was not monitored by speculators.

This is a profile that this corpus constantly recommends: a number historically major but common. Its value will never rise suddenly, but it will not collapse either, and it can be read without breaking the bank. For a collector looking for pieces to tell stories rather than resell, this is the best segment of the market.

Also note:Saga of the Swamp Thing #37(1985) contains the first appearance of John Constantine, a character born in this title before having his own. This key is monitored, and its rating has followed the adaptations of the character - it is significantly more expensive than #21, which clearly illustrates the difference between historical importance and media exposure.

As always, condition and gradation determine value; relying on real recent sales is strongly recommended.

What Moore did, and which few buyers dare

A final development on the 1984 gesture, because it constitutes a rare model and it is of interest to any reader of long series.

Taking an existing title presents the author with three options. He can continue— respect the premise and add episodes, which the vast majority of buyers do. He can to erase— declare that the above did not take place, a convenient solution and always poorly received, because it deprives the faithful reader of what he has read. Or he can reinterpret.

The third way is the most difficult, and it is that of the “anatomy lesson”. Nothing that has been published since 1971 is canceled: the facts remain, the episodes remain valid. Only their meaning changes. The reader who rereads the old issues after 1984 finds something other than what he saw there — without a single box having been contradicted.

This is an operation that serial comics allow better than any other form, because its continuity is long, public and shared. On the other hand, it requires that the author has read the above carefully, which is rarer than one might imagine.

For the reader who is looking for quality benchmarks in a cover, this is a useful and simple criterion to apply: an author who erases himself avoids work; an author who reinterprets must have provided this work before writing. The latter almost always produces better stories — and the story of this title demonstrates that.

Where to start reading

Saga of the Swamp Thing #21(1984) can be read alone and is one of the best entry points into the entire medium. It does not require any knowledge: the episode itself explains what it reverses, and the effect works even for those who have never read the series before.

Timeline to know

• 1971— House of Secrets #92: first appearance, cover by Wrightson.
• 1984— Saga of the Swamp Thing #21: Moore turns the premise on its head.
• 1985— Saga of the Swamp Thing #37: First appearance of Constantine.
• 2019— The series starts from the revelation instead of leading up to it.
• 2019— Canceled after a single episode broadcast, for external reasons.

Its place in the saga and for the collector

This series will remain as the most foreign cancellation to the work of this entire corpus: the decision is prior to any receipt, which makes the link with quality formally impossible. It also provides a solution different from that of Watchmen to the same problem - what to do with a revelation that no one knows anymore - by treating it as a starting point. For the collector, it leads to Saga of the Swamp Thing #21, a historically major and yet common issue: the best segment of the market for those who collect story pieces.

The verdict: the revelation kept, the order reversed

• Loyalty: the Louisiana swamp, the 1984 revelation on the nature of the character, the Green, horror as a register and the characters of Abby Arcane and Doctor Woodrue.
• Freedoms: a reveal placed early instead of being a climax, Abby's role expanded, storylines written for the series, a narrowed scope, and an ending forced by cancellation.
• Collectible numbers: House of Secrets #92 (1971), Saga of the Swamp Thing #21 (1984), #37 (1985).

Ten episodes filmed, only one broadcast before the decision. This is the clearest demonstration of what this corpus has established for forty batches – the fate of an adaptation is played out elsewhere than on the screen.

Frequently asked questions