Superman et Batman et Robin 69: The Date That Runs Out of Order, article illustration

In the checklist for Superman et Batman et Robin (Sage, 1969), issue 69 is dated "July 1974", while issue 68 is dated "August 1974": this is the only month inversion in the whole list. Issue 69 therefore shares its date with issue 67. The data does not say which of the two dates is correct; it only shows that the order by number and the order by date no longer match here.

You have a list of gaps with an issue 69 to tick, and a cover date that seems to lag behind that of the previous issue: enough to hesitate over where the comic belongs in a stack arranged by month.

As always in this guide, only verified details (creators, issue numbers, dates) are stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

The key dated facts given in this article about Superman et Batman et Robin 69

What the checklist states about issue 69

The entry for issue 69 gives a cover date, "July 1974", a story title, "Peace on Earth", and credits at the level of the issue: Leo Dorfman, Frank Robbins and Elliot S! Maggin on writing, Nick Cardy, Curt Swan and Irv Novick on art. The publisher is listed as "Sage - Sagédition", for a series whose launch year is 1969.

What the entry does not give matters just as much: no complete contents, no correspondence with an American comic, no indication of the actual newsstand release. The single title designates only one story among those in the comic, and the cover date is not the on-sale date. Everything that follows therefore concerns printed dates, not a distribution calendar.

The four dates around issue 69

Issue 67 is dated July, issue 68 August, issue 69 July and issue 70 October, all in 1974. Read in the order of the numbers, the sequence is therefore July, August, July, October: a step back of one month between 68 and 69, then a jump of three months to 70, the longest gap in the checklist.

The credits show no break. Nick Cardy appears on six consecutive entries of the checklist, from the double 65-66 to the double 71-72, and Leo Dorfman returns on issue 69 after issue 67 without appearing on issue 68. Nothing in the names suggests an issue that arrived from elsewhere: issue 69 fits into the same workshop as its neighbors, which makes the anomaly sharper, not more understandable.

Order by date, order by number

Sorted by number, the four issues give 67, 68, 69, 70. Sorted by date, they give 67 and 69 tied in July 1974, then 68 in August, then 70 in October. Issue 69 therefore moves ahead of issue 68 as soon as you sort by date, and is distinguished from issue 67 only by its number.

For a collection kept by hand, this hardly matters: the number printed on the cover remains the most reliable marker, because it is the only one that never repeats. For a collection entered in a spreadsheet or an app, however, it is a trap: sorting by date places issue 69 next to issue 67, and issue 68 ends up separated from both neighbors. Keep the number column as the sort key, and the date as simple information.

How the double issues change the count

The area is crossed by two double entries: "65 - 66" (May 1974) and "71 - 72" (December 1974). Each carries a single story title and a single date for two numbers.

Between issue 64 and issue 75 inclusive, there are twelve numbers but only ten entries. Across the whole checklist, seventy-five numbers plus a "50bis" are spread over seventy-four entries.

The effect is subtle but real for anyone counting their gaps: a list of numbers from 1 to 75 does not line up with a list of comics. The "50bis" adds one entry and the double 65-66 removes one: between the two, the rank of the entry runs one ahead of the number, and the entry for issue 69 happens to be the sixty-ninth in the checklist through simple compensation. After the double 71-72, the rank falls back below the number: issue 73 is the seventy-second entry. If you count your copies, count entries, not numbers, and note that each double is worth two slots in the list.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Superman et Batman et Robin 69: the sections of this guide, in reading order

One possible reading: the date of issue 69 is missing September

What follows is a hypothesis, not a fact from the checklist. From issue 1 (January 1969) to issue 64 (April 1974), the checklist skips no month and no number, and numbers and months advance in step: issue 61 is January 1974, 62 February, 63 March, 64 April.

After the double 65-66, dated May, issue 67 is July and issue 68 August, which extends the same rule if the double absorbed the month of June. Issue 70 falls in October, and the double 71-72 in December, again compatible with an absorbed month, November.

In this sequence from April 1974 to March 1975, a single month is covered neither by an issue nor by a double that would absorb it: September 1974, exactly where issue 69 would have fallen. The date "July" then looks like a copy of the one for issue 67, rather than a release that really came before issue 68. This is an economical reading, because it explains the three missing months with a single anomaly, but the checklist cannot prove it: the issue in hand would be needed, and probably a document dated from the period, to settle it.

Why this issue matters to a collector

An issue with an inverted date is not rare by nature: it is ambiguous. If your copy does carry "July 1974", you hold printed proof of the anomaly, and it becomes the issue to photograph and describe precisely when you offer it for sale. If, on the contrary, it carries another date, the catalog entry needs correcting, and your copy documents the error. In both cases, what you bring is not a price: it is a verification that the checklist cannot carry out on its own.

What makes an individual copy interesting therefore depends less on its title, "Peace on Earth", than on the clarity of the date notice on the cover, the condition of the spine, and whether the copy is complete. For market value, no price guide replaces a comparison of sold listings in comparable condition.

Recognizing the copy and avoiding confusion

Three checks can be done on the cover and the first page. First, the printed number, which must read "69" alone: the two doubles in the checklist carry two numbers, and a "65 - 66" or a "71 - 72" does not fit the slot of a single number. Next, the date notice as it is written, month and year, without correcting it from memory. Finally, the credits on the title page, to be compared with Dorfman, Robbins and Maggin for the writing, and Cardy, Swan and Novick for the art.

A confusion also lurks in listings: a seller who sorts by date may describe issue 69 as the "July 1974 issue" and mix it up with issue 67, from the same month. Ask for a photo of the cover with the number legible, never a description alone. Issue 67, for its part, has its own title, "Supergirl's Great Ordeal", which lifts the doubt without opening the comic.

Entering issue 69 in a list of gaps

To avoid mistakes, tick by number, never by date, and add a "printed month" column to record what each copy carries. With your 67, 68, 69 and 70 in hand, the column should read July, August, July, October, which is exactly what the checklist announces. A gap from that sequence is information to keep, not a data-entry error to erase.

On condition, a comic from this period is judged on the same points as its neighbors: spine, corners, detached pages, water stains. Photograph the date notice closely, because it is that, not the spine, that gives this issue its documentary interest.

Superman et Batman et Robin 69: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

The checklist only gives cover dates: "July 1974" for 69, "August 1974" for 68. It gives no on-sale date. A release inversion is possible, but a wrongly copied date is too. Only the copy itself can settle the question.

No. File it by number, between 68 and 70: that is the order of the entries in the checklist. The date is there to note a peculiarity, not to move the comic. A sort by date would place it next to issue 67, which muddles the list.

Each is a single entry in the checklist, with one title and one date, but it covers two numbers of the list. For a count of objects, count one item. For ticking off a list from 1 to 75, it is worth two boxes.

At the level of the month, the checklist contains only one: that of issue 69. It does however show three gaps of two months or more, all located between the double 65-66 and the double 71-72, one of which is three months between 69 and 70.

Nothing in the checklist allows us to say, and no price guide applies. The value depends on condition, completeness and how legible the date notice is. Compare actual sold listings in comparable condition rather than an asking price.