James Tynion IV: Where to Start Reading, Step by Step

The name James Tynion IV covers two careers that rarely cross: that of a Batman writer, who came up through Scott Snyder's teams before signing original arcs, and that of an author of horror and thrillers of original creation, at BOOM!, Image and DC Black Label. A reader who knows one of the two faces often ignores the other, and sometimes picks a first collected edition at random. This path proposes an order, so that the first read makes you want the second.

As always in this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of protected pages or dialogue.

The ranking criterion is the number of readings you need behind you. Something Is Killing the Children opens on a Wisconsin town and expects nothing of the reader. Batman and Joker War call for familiarity with Gotham, and Batman Eternal, with its dozens of narrative threads, only makes sense to someone who already knows the Batman family well. The six steps below follow that progression.

Step 1: Something Is Killing the Children (2019), the front door

The series was born at BOOM! Studios in 2019 with Werther Dell'Edera on art, Miquel Muerto on colors and AndWorld Design on lettering. The first issue, dated October 2019, takes us to Archer's Peak, a small Wisconsin town where children are disappearing, and brings in Erica Slaughter, a bandana-wearing monster hunter. Our file on the first issue details the object and its print run.

Why start there? Because the series works in arcs, with no prior continuity whatsoever. You read the first collected edition, you see the tone, the brutality, the way Tynion and Dell'Edera dose explanation and silence. If horror puts you off, you will know within a few pages, without having invested anything.

An extension exists: the spin-off House of Slaughter, launched in 2021 at the same publisher, widens the universe. It can wait until you are attached to the characters. For fans of the genre, the history of BOOM! Studios places the publisher in the independent landscape.

Step 2: Detective Comics (2016), Tynion on Batman

When DC relaunched its universe under the Rebirth label, Tynion took over Detective Comics from issue 934, in 2016, with Eddy Barrows on art for the launch. Instead of a solitary Batman, the series features a team: Batwoman, Red Robin, Spoiler, Orphan and, a little later, Clayface. The first arc, Rise of the Batmen, lays out the idea that sustains the whole run: a Gotham too vast for one man.

Why in this spot? Because the success of this step rests on the cast, not on the puzzle. A reader who knows Batman by name can follow, and discovers supporting characters treated with rare care. It is an excellent way to grasp Tynion's ensemble writing before the big events.

On the collecting side, the landmarks are the opening issues of the run. The ranking of Detective Comics runs places this period among the title's great eras, with a numbering that overlaps that of previous decades: beware of identical numbers from different eras.

Step 3: The Nice House on the Lake (2021), the closed thriller

DC's adult label welcomed The Nice House on the Lake in 2021, twelve issues drawn by Álvaro Martínez Bueno and colored by Jordie Bellaire. The starting point is a closed-door setup: friends invited by a host to an idyllic house, and an unease that sets in from the opening. We reveal nothing of the ending, which is the heart of the effect.

Why step 3? Because the story is closed: twelve issues, a beginning, a resolution, no DC knowledge required despite the publisher. It is the best example of what Tynion does when in control of the entire form. It simply demands a bit of patience, since the reading rewards attention to detail from the first issue.

Our entry on the first issue separates what belongs to the paper from what belongs to reputation. The reader can choose the complete collected edition without regret: the story was conceived as a whole.

Step 4: Batman (2020) and Joker War, the mainstream at large scale

In 2020, Tynion succeeds Tom King on Batman starting with issue 86. The run becomes an open construction site: the Joker War arc occupies issues 97 to 100, prepared from issues 95 and 96, with Jorge Jiménez on art, and sets up new characters, including Punchline, cited by most sources as appearing as early as Batman #89, and Ghost-Maker. Dates and exact issue numbers of the appearances diverge depending on the source: check them on the issue itself before buying.

Why late in the path? Because this run assumes familiarity with the Joker, Tom King's Batman and the extended Batman family. Nothing forbids reading it cold, but the pleasure grows when you know the terrain. To fix these landmarks, our Batman reading guide puts the earlier periods back in order, and the Joker hub gathers the related articles.

The artist also has a hub: Jorge Jiménez, useful for gauging the share of the art in Joker War's reputation. To compare this run with the other great periods, see the ranking of modern Batman runs.

Step 5: The Department of Truth (2020), conceptual demands

The series began at Image in late September 2020, with Martin Simmonds on art, fully painted, and Aditya Bidikar on lettering. The hero, Cole Turner, is a federal agent recruited by an agency tasked with containing conspiracy narratives that end up altering reality. Our analysis of the first issue shows that it is a creator-driven series launch more than a first appearance.

Why so far into the path? Because the series is the most abstract: it plays on references to the history of popular beliefs, and its construction requires accepting a fragmented narration. A reader who already enjoyed the suspense of The Nice House on the Lake finds a natural extension here, but a denser one.

Martin Simmonds's painting is a reading argument in its own right. Open the first collected edition in a bookstore before buying it: if the texture of the image suits you, the rest will follow; if not, better to know before committing to an entire series. For fans of the publisher, the history of Image Comics sheds light on this landscape.

Step 6: Batman Eternal (2014) and The Woods, going back to the sources

The last tier, for those who want to measure the distance traveled. Batman Eternal appeared in 2014 in 52 weekly issues, written by a team led by Scott Snyder and Tynion, with Jason Fabok on art for a large part of the series. The whole is one of the most ambitious collective projects of the period, but reading it takes time and a good knowledge of the Batman family.

The same year, at BOOM!, The Woods places a high school and its students in the middle of an unknown forest, with Michael Dialynas on art. It is an early work that already announces the writer's taste for groups bound together by a threat. It reads with no prerequisites, but we place it here because it makes full sense after step 1.

These two series are the oldest on the path and the easiest to regret if read too early. Take them as archives: you see ideas in germ, before their definitive form in the later works.

How to read: single issues or collected editions

For reading, favor the collected editions. Tynion's series advance in arcs, and the volumes gather them cleanly. Closed works, such as The Nice House on the Lake, exist in an omnibus edition, which saves chasing twelve single issues. For Batman Eternal, a boxed set or several volumes are indispensable: 52 weekly issues read poorly one at a time.

One detail matters when shelving these collected editions: at BOOM! Studios as at Image, volume numbering follows the arcs, not the year of publication. Something Is Killing the Children, drawn by Werther Dell'Edera, and The Department of Truth, painted by Martin Simmonds, are therefore shelved volume by volume, with no gap between two arcs, if you want your shelf to reflect the reading order.

For collecting, recent issues, published between 2019 and 2021, do not yet have an established market value. Between 2019 and 2021, the value of a single issue depends on the longevity of its series, its reprints and the attention paid to Tynion. No adaptation should be considered a given until it is confirmed by the publisher, and we announce none.

We suggest keeping only the #1 of each series, checking the print run printed on the issue, then comparing closed sales for the same issue in the same condition. We quote no amount, because it changes too fast. A record of your purchases spares you duplicates between single issues and collected editions. As for language, French availability of each title remains to be checked with French-language publishers.

Recap: the recommended order

Here is the complete order, from the most open to the most demanding: Something Is Killing the Children (2019), Detective Comics (2016), The Nice House on the Lake (2021), Batman and Joker War (2020), The Department of Truth (2020), then Batman Eternal (2014) and The Woods (2014).

If you read only one, take the first collected edition of Something Is Killing the Children. If you read two, add The Nice House on the Lake, which shows the writer's closed-form work. Batman readers can swap steps 1 and 2 without harm. The author hub brings together all of our files on Tynion, buying guides and rankings included.

Frequently asked questions