The X-Men #4, cover-dated March 1964, written by Stan Lee, drawn by Jack Kirby and inked by Paul Reinman, contains the first appearances of Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver, along with that of the villain group Magneto gathers around him, the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, with Toad and Mastermind. Both characters act as antagonists there. This is the issue collectors have been chasing since television put them back in the spotlight.
A collector building a set of sixties key issues always ends up stumbling on this particular case: an issue with two first appearances, where neither of the characters concerned is on the right side. For a long time, the March 1964 #4 traded mainly as a Brotherhood issue, behind the #1 and far ahead of nothing. It has changed category. The useful question is no longer whether to buy it, but in what condition, in which edition, and with which checks before paying.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
The issue: March 1964, Lee, Kirby, Reinman
The cover carries the date March 1964 and a price of twelve cents, like the whole of Marvel's output that season. Writing is by Stan Lee; pencils by Jack Kirby; inks by Paul Reinman, whose heavy line marks these first four issues strongly and explains part of their raw look, quite far from the smoother Kirby of the following years.
The episode brings five figures onto the page at once, or more precisely four new ones around a former one. Magneto, already introduced in issue #1, stops being a lone adversary: he surrounds himself. Two of the recruits, Toad and Mastermind, also make their first appearance here. The other two are a young woman capable of inflicting bad luck on whatever she points at, and a runner whose speed is at first used to flee, and who is presented as her brother.
The plot takes them to a small nation Magneto intends to seize, Santo Marco, invented for the occasion. The narrative stake is less the conquest than the debt that binds the brother and sister to their recruiter: they obey without agreeing. This mechanism, set up in 1964 in a few panels, has held for sixty years.
What the series was publishing then
In March 1964, the title has only four issues to its name and a bimonthly schedule. It still runs on a simple pattern: one new antagonist per episode, introduced, confronted, dispatched. The three previous issues followed exactly this mechanism, with the Vanisher and then the Blob. Issue #4 breaks with it, not by changing the formula, but by keeping its newcomers: the Brotherhood comes back, and the two recruits will return elsewhere.
This difference has a very concrete consequence for the collector. In the three issues before, the first appearance is also, more or less, the last major appearance of the character concerned. In #4, it opens two long careers. This is what durably separates its value from that of its immediate neighbors.
It should also be remembered that the title was not a success at the time. The 1964 print runs for this series were modest compared with what the publisher's headline series were selling, and surviving copies in high grade are rare for that reason as much as for the reading habits of the day.
Why this issue became a key
Three movements added up. The first is internal to the stories: as early as 1965, the brother and sister leave Magneto's camp to join the reconstituted Avengers in Avengers #16, turning two supporting figures into regular characters. The second is the long career of Scarlet Witch, which took her to roles of a very different scale than that of a reluctant recruit, notably through her relationship with Vision.
The third is recent, and it is the one that shifted the value: two television series of the 2020s put the two characters, and Wanda in particular, back at the center. WandaVision in 2021, then Agatha All Along in 2024, produced on this issue the classic effect of a successful adaptation, with one notable difference: there is no cheaper alternative here. For a character's first appearance, a buyer can often fall back on a secondary appearance, a period reprint or an issue from the same year. Here, #4 is the only entry point, and it carries two characters at once.
Add to that the fact that the same issue is the key to the Brotherhood, and therefore an issue sought by Magneto enthusiasts who have no interest at all in Wanda, and you get three distinct audiences for a single 1964 print run.
What moves the price
On an issue of this age, the grade controls almost everything. Between a complete but heavily read copy and the same issue in near-mint condition, the ratio is not counted in percentages but in multiples, and each grade step at the top of the scale weighs more than the previous one. A single grade gained can double the value, and beyond a certain level of preservation the progression becomes steep, because the number of known copies at that level is counted in the dozens.
Three specific defects cost more here than elsewhere. The first is cover centering, often approximate on this output. The second is the whiteness of the interior pages: 1964 paper yellows, and a copy that has stayed light cream sells for clearly more than a brown one. The third is the staple, whose rust migrates into the paper and permanently caps the grade.
Finally, provenance counts. A copy from an identified lot, kept flat for decades, sells better than the same grade with no history, because the buyer also pays for the coherence of the file.
Recognizing one edition from another
There is no second printing of this issue in the modern sense: back then, a print run was sold or pulped. Several objects can, however, be mistaken for the original.
Copies destined for the British market carried a price in pence stamped or printed in place of the twelve cents. These are genuine period copies, but their market is distinct and their value follows its own rules; a seller who presents them as identical to the American version is either mistaken or misleading you. Check the price box, not just the date.
In the early 1970s, the series devoted a long run of issues to reprinting its first episodes, starting at #67: the Santo Marco story reappeared there. These reprint issues are recognized by their numbering and their price, and have no value relationship with the original. The same goes for hardcover collections of reprints, black-and-white volumes, and any facsimile editions: if a facsimile of this issue is offered to you, the mention normally appears on the cover or in the indicia, and that is where you should look before discussing the price.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
Traps when buying
The most common trap is not counterfeiting, which remains rare on this title, but mislabeled issue numbers in listings. A listing that promises “the first appearance of Scarlet Witch” while showing a cover with four villains, without checking the number, deserves a request for a photo of the price box and the indicia.
The second trap is undisclosed restoration: a re-glued spine, a small piece of paper added to a corner, a color touch-up on a tear. An honestly disclosed restoration is not a problem, it is a price; undisclosed, it makes you pay for a grade the copy does not have.
The third is the incomplete copy. The 1964 issues included letter pages, advertising and sometimes detachable inserts; a missing page, even an advertising one, changes the category of the object. Ask explicitly whether the copy is complete, page by page, and be wary of photos that show only the two covers.
A last, most mundane point: the copy photographed under a sleeve or film, flat, with raking light that erases the cover creases. Ask for a photo in oblique light.
Neighboring issues that matter too
Issue #1 remains the dominant piece of the series and cannot be compared. Issues #2 and #3, with their single-use antagonists, are secondary keys whose value has moved little in recent years, which sometimes makes them a reasonable entry into the collection for anyone who wants continuity without the bidding war.
For the two characters in question, the true complementary issue is Avengers #16, where they switch sides. Quicksilver fans see there the beginning of the character as it was exploited afterward, and this 1965 issue remains a much more accessible purchase. On the Brotherhood side, the group's return in the following issues of the original series forms a small coherent set, less sought after but easier to complete in good condition.
What grading changes
On a 1964 issue serving three audiences, professional grading does more than reassure: it determines the market on which the copy is sold. A raw copy is negotiated privately, often with a prudence discount that can reach the value of a full grade step; the same copy graded enters auction sales and public comparables.
Two cases deserve thought. If your copy is heavily read, grading often costs more than it returns, and an honest scan is enough. If it is clearly above very fine condition, grading is almost always justified, because the gap between two high grades on this particular issue far exceeds the cost of the service. In between, the decision depends on your horizon: selling within the year, or keeping.
Finally, note that the label of a graded copy mentions recognized first appearances. On this issue, the wording varies across grading eras, and an incomplete mention does not take anything away from the content of the copy.
How to track it in a collection
An issue with three readings has to be filed three times, at least logically. In your inventory, it belongs in the original series, in the list of key issues for Scarlet Witch, and in the Brotherhood list. A well-kept collection lets you find it through each of these entries without duplicating it.
In practical terms, record at purchase the grade or your estimate, the edition, whether a price in pence is present or not, the condition of the staples and the color of the pages, then the source and the acquisition date. These five pieces of information are the ones you will be asked for at resale, and the ones you never recover from memory ten years later. Also track the gap between your price paid and comparable sales, issue by issue: on a key driven by television news, that gap moves quickly in both directions.
Conclusion
The March 1964 #4 occupies an unusual position: it is worth two characters who, within its pages, do nothing heroic, and a villain group it founds. It is an issue you buy once, after checking the edition, the printed price and completeness, and then keep as a reference piece rather than as a rotating asset. Hurried buyers in 2021 paid for scarcity in a rush; a patient buyer looks at the pages first.
Do you have a March 1964 copy in your boxes, or a doubt about the pence price on its cover? Have it appraised before deciding whether to send it for grading.
Estimate my comic
Frequently asked questions
Yes, and that is what makes this key special. Both make their first appearance in The X-Men #4, cover-dated March 1964, as Magneto's recruits. The same episode also introduces Toad and Mastermind, along with the villain group the four of them belong to.
Because they are presented there as bound to Magneto by a debt, not by conviction. The story stresses their obedience without allegiance. They switch sides as early as 1965, in Avengers #16, which makes that issue the logical complement to #4 for anyone following the two characters.
Stan Lee on writing, Jack Kirby on pencils and Paul Reinman on inks. Reinman's heavy line characterizes the early issues of the series and gives this episode a rawer look than Kirby's later work, which buyers used to the seventies notice immediately.
Check the cover number, the printed price and the indicia. The original carries twelve cents and the date March 1964. The episode was reprinted in the long run of reprint issues begun at #67, in the early 1970s, and then in various collections, with no value relationship to the original print run.
No. Period copies destined for the British market carried a price in pence instead of twelve cents. They are authentic, but their market is separate and their value follows its own benchmarks. Check the price box in the photo before negotiating, and have the seller specify this point.