Michonne enters The Walking Dead at the very end of issue 19, published by Image Comics with an April 2005 cover date, written by Robert Kirkman, drawn by Charlie Adlard and toned in grey by Cliff Rathburn. She appears outside the prison fence, sword at her side, flanked by two chained corpses that serve as her camouflage. Collectors look for this issue because it also opens the series' fourth collected volume.
With this issue, the difficulty is not finding a copy: plenty are in circulation. The difficulty is knowing which one you are looking at. The Walking Dead is one of the most reprinted series of the 2000s, and issue 19 went back to press several times, sometimes with a cover identical to the 2005 one. Add to that a market price that rose, then left, the curve of the TV series, and you get an issue where two buyers can pay wildly different sums for what looks like the same object.
As always in this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact. The analysis is ours, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
The issue: date, creators, what happens
Issue 19 carries an April 2005 cover date. Robert Kirkman wrote the script, Charlie Adlard handled the art, and Cliff Rathburn the grey tones that give the interior its particular black and white look, neither clear line nor wash. The series was then published by Image Comics, without the label that would later accompany the franchise.
Narratively, this issue closes one cycle and opens another: it follows the battle for control of the prison and is the first chapter of the series' fourth collected volume. Most of the booklet is devoted to restoring order to Rick Grimes' group in a place they finally believe is secure. The last page is the one that matters to the collector: a hooded figure appears on the other side of the fence, accompanied by two reanimated corpses held on chains. This is Michonne, whose name is not yet given to the reader at that point.
This construction has a practical consequence. The appearance is brief, at the end of the issue, and it is not advertised on the cover. A seller who does not know the series may list an issue 19 without knowing what they are selling, and that is nearly the only good news in this market for a patient buyer.
Editorial context: what the series was publishing then
In spring 2005, The Walking Dead is a little over a year and a half old: the first issue came out in October 2003. Tony Moore drew the first six issues before Charlie Adlard took over from issue 7, and he would carry the series through to the end. The series is not yet a phenomenon. It is a black and white horror title, published monthly, in a catalogue where the collected-edition format is only starting to build a readership in bookstores.
This has a direct effect on print runs. Orders from specialist shops for issues of this period sit well below those of competing superhero titles. Image then met the nascent demand not with new printings of issue 19 alone, but with the collected editions, and later with reprint programs. In other words, the scarcity of a 2005 first printing is real, and the number of copies on the market does not reflect it.
Why this issue became a key
Over two hundred issues, Michonne became one of the three or four characters the series could no longer do without. She is not a supporting figure introduced for a single arc: she goes through the prison, the confrontation with the Governor, the rebuilding, and she remains present very late in the publication. In a story that built its reputation on the mortality of its cast, a character's longevity is in itself a collecting argument.
The other driver lies outside the paper. The television adaptation began in late 2010. Michonne appeared briefly at the turn of the second season, then as a regular character from the third, in 2012. Each casting announcement, each broadcast and each spin-off set off waves of buying for her first appearance. It is the classic mechanism for first appearances adapted on screen, and it explains why issue 19 separated itself from the rest of the 2005 issues.
What moves the price: condition, edition, print run
Three variables, and they do not weigh the same. The edition comes first: a first printing and a reprint of the same issue are not in the same category, and the gap between them is the widest of all those you will meet on this booklet. Condition comes next: on a 2005 comic, a high grade is expected, and it is the absence of defects that is paid for, not their presence. The country of sale comes last, because demand for early 2000s Image series remains very concentrated in the English-speaking market.
One point specific to this issue deserves a mention: the covers of this period of the series carry wide dark areas, which ruthlessly reveal light scuffs, staple creases and whitened edges. At equal real condition, an issue 19 therefore looks worse than a contemporary issue with a light cover. This is also why copies judged flawless are proportionally fewer than one would expect for a comic of this age.
On the downturn, let's be frank: the end of the TV series removed from issue 19 the fuel that had carried it. Speculative demand moved elsewhere, offers multiplied, and the hierarchy between grades tightened from below. A buyer who compares today's offer with a memory of the big-season period will use the wrong reference. Take recent comparison points, from completed sales, and only for copies whose print run is established.
Telling one edition from another
This is the central question for this issue, and it is settled at the foot of the legal text, not by eye. Print run details normally appear in the indicia, the legal notice printed on the first pages: a later print run is in principle identified as such there. Get into the habit of requiring a clear photograph of this block of text before any remote purchase, just as you would for cover photos.
Two families of reprints circulate widely. The first is the classic later print runs, put back to press to meet demand, with the same cover illustration. The second belongs to republication programs: the weekly series launched by the publisher in 2011, which reprinted the first issues one by one with its own logo treatment, and the anniversary reprints with a redrawn cover released later. The latter are easy to rule out since the image changes. The weekly series is recognized by its logo. Later print runs with an identical image are the only ones that require reading the indicia.
If a seller cannot or will not provide this photograph, treat the copy as an undetermined print run and negotiate on that basis. There is no reliable shortcut, and no barcode detail is universally accepted as allowing you to conclude without this check. The claims to the contrary that you read on forums deserve at least a check against the copy itself.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
The pitfalls at purchase
The first pitfall is the listing that reads "first appearance of Michonne" without specifying the print run. The statement is true of the content; it says nothing about the object. The second is the confusion between the booklet and the collection: the fourth bound volume contains the scene, but it does not have comparable collector value, and some listings keep the confusion alive by photographing a collected-edition cover.
The third is more insidious: lots. Issues from this period are often sold in sequences, and a "13 to 24" lot can perfectly well combine later print runs with a few first printings, with no intent to deceive. Ask for the details issue by issue, or buy the lot at the price of the lowest print run.
Last point, specific to high-volume reading series: pressure on the staples. Image booklets of this era have fairly fragile spines, and a copy that has been read several times shows a page offset at the staples that heavily penalizes the grade without being visible in a face-on photograph.
The neighboring issues that also matter
Issue 1, published in October 2003, remains the absolute summit of the series and a class of object of its own, with its own print run identification problems. Issue 7 interests art enthusiasts: it marks Charlie Adlard's arrival. Issue 27 carries the first appearance of the Governor, the antagonist who structures the long prison sequence and for whom issue 19 indirectly paves the way. Much further on, issue 100 combines a major first appearance with the most discussed episode of the whole publication, in an editorial context unrelated to 2005. Issue 193, published in July 2019, closes the series deliberately abruptly.
If your goal is the coherence of a set rather than the isolated piece, the sequence of issues 19 to 24 forms a complete narrative block and can still be acquired without difficulty. The hub devoted to the series details this structure.
What grading changes
On a 2005 booklet of which many copies survive, grading serves less to certify condition than to certify the print run. This is the reverse of its usual use. An encapsulated copy whose label explicitly mentions the first print run and the character's appearance spares you the indicia check and the risk of dispute. An encapsulated copy whose label stays silent on the print run spares you nothing at all, and you then have to read what is visible through the holder.
For a raw issue, the reasoning is one of relative cost: grading only makes sense if the price gap between the expected grade and the grade immediately below clearly exceeds the cost of the operation and shipping. On issue 19 in average condition, that condition is practically never met. On a copy you judge impeccable after examining the edges and the staples, it can be.
How to track it in a collection
This issue is the typical example of an entry that should carry more information than "series, issue, condition". Record the print run, the source of that certainty, the acquisition date and, if the copy is graded, the exact wording on the label. In My Comics Collection, these elements fit into the copy's fields, and the catalogue provides the bibliographic framework on which you hang them.
The benefit shows when you sell or insure: in one search you find the copies whose print run is documented and those that remain uncertain, instead of reopening boxes. For a series reprinted this much, that is the difference between an inventory and a list. Creator-owned series from the same publisher, from Spawn to Saga, also raise similar edition questions.
Conclusion
Issue 19 of The Walking Dead is a reasonable purchase on two conditions, and both are within your control. The first is to buy only an established print run, with the indicia as evidence, while accepting that you will let pass the opaque offers, which are numerous. The second is to calibrate your price on recent sales rather than on the period when the TV series set the market. On those terms, you acquire the first appearance of a central character from a completed series, in an issue whose scarcity as a first printing is very real.
Do you have a 2005 issue 19 in your boxes and don't know whether it is a first printing or a reprint?
Estimate my comic
Frequently asked questions
Yes, but only in the last pages of the booklet, behind the prison fence, with her two chained corpses. Her name and role are only developed from the following issues. This brevity is normal for a first appearance and takes nothing away from the status of issue 19, which remains the sought-after reference.
Read the indicia, the legal notice block printed on the first pages: a reprint is in principle flagged there as a later print run. Anniversary reprints carry a different illustration, and the 2011 weekly series is recognized by its logo. If you have doubts about a remote purchase, require a clear photograph of this block.
No. The collection does contain the scene, since issue 19 is its first chapter, but it was printed in very large quantities and reprinted for years. It keeps its reading and library interest, not its collector value. Beware of listings that illustrate a booklet with a collected-edition cover.
The demand that formed during the most-watched seasons has indeed withdrawn, and offers have become plentiful again. The gaps between mid-range grades have tightened, while those at the top hold up better. To set a price, rely on recently completed sales, not on the levels of the great adaptation period.
Only if the copy is flawless after examining the dark edges and the staples, because that is where this booklet degrades. On this issue, the label mainly serves to attest the print run. In average condition, the cost of the operation almost always exceeds the expected price gain, and a raw copy that is well photographed sells without difficulty.