The Walking Dead #100 (2012): Negan's first appearance, cover by cover, article illustration

Negan first appears in The Walking Dead #100, published in July 2012, written by Robert Kirkman and drawn by Charlie Adlard. The issue closes the "Something to Fear" arc and introduces the leader of the Saviors along with his barbed-wire-wrapped bat. Its collecting peculiarity: it came out in an unusual series of different covers, each of which has since developed its own market.

Buying this issue does not mean finding "the" number 100, but deciding which one you want. In a list of sales, you will see the same issue offered at price gaps ranging from simple to very high, with no condition explaining the difference: it is the cover letter at work. This guide helps you choose that letter with full knowledge, and avoid the most common mistake, which is taking the most talked-about cover thinking it is the hardest to find.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

Profile of The Walking Dead #100: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

The issue: July 2012, Kirkman and Adlard, and a character entry

The Walking Dead #100 was published in July 2012. Robert Kirkman writes the script, Charlie Adlard handles the art, and the issue ends the cycle titled "Something to Fear". Negan enters late in the pages, framed by an armed group that takes control of the scene. The issue introduces an antagonist who talks, negotiates and imposes a tribute.

From a collecting standpoint, three elements matter and only three: the issue is indeed 100, Negan's first appearance is on its interior pages, and the physical object exists in several cover versions distributed at the same time. Everything else is a matter of personal judgement. The barbed-wire-wrapped bat, named Lucille in the series, became the character's visual signature and explains part of the later demand for this specific issue.

The release context matters: this hundredth issue was presented as an editorial milestone, retailers ordered it in volume, and the sales figures recorded at the time place it in the range of several hundred thousand copies, a level few titles reached then. We are therefore not talking about a confidential issue: scarcity plays out within the range of covers.

Why one issue came out in so many covers

The alternate cover practice had existed for a long time, but this hundredth issue pushed it to a degree rarely seen for a non-superhero title: the publisher lined up a regular cover signed by Adlard and a series of covers commissioned from guest artists, several of them very recognisable names in the American market. The copies are distinguished by a letter, from the regular cover to the last ones in the set, including a version printed on metallic stock.

This structure has a direct consequence: there is not one price for number 100, there are as many prices as there are letters, and those prices do not move together. A cover can gain value because its artist has become sought-after again, while its neighbour stagnates. Sales listings sometimes use floating names, and a seller who simply writes "#100 variant" leaves the identification work to you.

The first appearance is identical in every version

A point often misunderstood: Negan's appearance is an interior element. The pages are the same from one letter to the next, the plot is the same, the pagination is the same. No cover contains "more" first appearance than another, and none confers a special status in the catalogue, which records the issue and its cover variants under a single content entry.

This has a useful practical implication if your goal is character completeness rather than chasing covers: the least valued version in the range gives you exactly the same narrative event as the most valued one. For a collector ticking off first appearances, buying the most affordable letter in fine condition is a perfectly rational decision, and often the best spending per unit of satisfaction.

Conversely, if your goal is the object, then the cover becomes the subject and the interior content is no longer the criterion. Both approaches are defensible, but they do not cost the same, and they do not resell to the same buyers. Decide before you search, not in front of a listing.

What sets the price of one cover over another

Four forces are at work. The first is the quantity printed per letter, which the market does not know exactly but guesses from how often it appears for sale. The second is the guest artist's reputation, which attracts demand from collections other than that of the title. The third is image legibility: a cover where the introduced character is recognisable sells better than a mood composition, even when signed by a more highly rated name.

The fourth force is the most deceptive: the hierarchy of covers has been fixed by habits of speech. Certain letters have been nicknamed, cited and sought out by their nickname, and that nickname has created its own demand. A cover everyone talks about is easy to sell, so it is often put up for sale, so it is visible, so it is perceived as the reference, and the price follows that visibility more than real scarcity.

To orient yourself, watch the volume of offers per letter over several weeks rather than the displayed price. A letter that rarely appears for sale and trades modestly is the real signal of an imbalance worth exploiting. A letter that is everywhere and expensive only tells you the market is liquid, which is comfortable at resale but is not a source of value.

Why the most expensive cover is not necessarily the rarest

Price measures the meeting of supply and demand, not a print run. On this issue, the most demanded covers are also those that sold the most at release, precisely because retailers anticipated demand and ordered accordingly. The result is counterintuitive: the expensive copies are often numerous, and within the range there are more discreet letters of which very few certified copies come through.

Three indicators help separate scarcity from prestige. The gap between two public sales of the same letter in a comparable condition, first: a few days indicates abundance, several months indicates something else. The number of graded copies recorded next, public information whose reading letter by letter is far more instructive than a global reading of the issue. And finally the price gap between two neighbouring grades, which widens when the population is thin.

The practical conclusion is not to systematically buy the rare letter: scarcity without demand resells poorly. It is to know what you are paying for. If you pay for a famous cover, you are buying liquidity; if you pay for a rarely seen cover, you are buying a bet on future attention. Both positions are tenable; confusing the two is not.

Reprints, later editions and special formats

This issue saw printings after its release, identifiable by a mention in the small legal text on the credits page or by a modified cover treatment. A copy from a later printing contains the same story but is not the same object for the market, and its price sits at a level unrelated to that of first-printing copies.

The metallic-stock version deserves a separate mention, because it introduces a condition trap: these surfaces show marks at the slightest rub, and a defect invisible on ordinary paper becomes a very visible white trace. A copy of this type described as "perfect" without a raking-light photograph should be treated as undescribed.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
The Walking Dead #100 (2012): the sections of this guide, in reading order

The traps when buying this issue

The first trap is the silent listing about the letter, sometimes accompanied by a photo cropped around the character. Ask for a view of the whole cover and the back. The second is the confusion kept alive between a guest-artist cover and a convention or shop edition: the names vary from one seller to another, and only visual identification, cross-checked against the catalogue record, settles it.

The third trap concerns the spine. On a thick issue that has been heavily handled in shops, reading creases at the staples are common and weigh heavily when grading. The fourth is provenance: this issue circulated widely in lots when the television series popularised the character, and some copies were cleaned or pressed without this being mentioned.

The last trap is your own. The eagerness to own the first appearance pushes you to pay for a well-known cover at the price of a hot market, when the same release date exists under another letter for a fraction of the cost. If the goal is the character, let the headline cover pass and take the finest copy available of a neglected letter.

Neighbouring issues that also matter

The issues immediately after number 100 deserve more attention, because they establish the power dynamic introduced at the end of #100 and contain the character's first developed scenes. They make a sensible fallback position for anyone who does not want to pay the market price of number 100, provided they accept that these are follow-up content rather than a first appearance.

Finally, if your collection is built by character rather than by series, frame the purchase within a coherent set. Landmark first appearances of antagonists follow a common logic, which you will find on other hubs of the site, for example that of Spawn, where the same question of choosing a cover treatment arises across several issues.

What grading changes on a 2012 issue

On a recent issue, grading does not serve to authenticate: nobody doubts that a 2012 copy is of its time. It serves to settle the top of the scale, where the naked eye no longer distinguishes anything. The value gap between a very fine copy and an almost perfect one is decided by cutting and centring details that only a formal assessment makes negotiable.

This mechanism applies unevenly depending on the letter. On an abundant cover, grading an average copy costs more than the gain you hope for. On a letter little represented among graded populations, the same approach can create value, because the buyer has no other way to compare their copy with the rare precedents.

In practice: decide on grading after choosing the letter, never before. And if you inherit an already graded copy, read the cover mention on the label before comparing the grade with past sales, or you risk comparing two different objects. To settle a choice, an estimate of the specific copy is worth more than a series average.

How to track it in a collection

An issue with several covers requires a more precise entry than others. In My Comics Collection, record the letter or the artist's name in the variant field, not in a free-text note: that field is what will later let you find your copies by cover and avoid buying again a letter you already own. The classic mistake is to enter "The Walking Dead 100" three times and no longer know which ones are on the shelf.

Also distinguish the reading copy from the preservation copy if you own two. The first justifies normal handling, the second calls for a sleeve and a rigid backing, especially on glossy stock that scratches. A well-kept collection on this issue means one line per cover, a condition recorded, and the printing mention when it is not the first.

Finally, follow your letters separately over time. The price movements of this issue are not synchronised, and that very gap offers buying windows: the letter nobody talks about this month is the one found at the best price. The The Walking Dead hub brings together useful landmarks for the rest of the series.

Conclusion

The Walking Dead #100 is a textbook case: a single first appearance, that of Negan in July 2012 under Kirkman's pen and Adlard's pencil, and a family of objects that behave like independent titles on the market. Choosing here means answering a simple question: do you want the event or the object?

If you want the event, take the least contested letter in the finest possible condition and keep your record up to date. If you want the object, accept paying for the liquidity of the headline cover, or go looking for rarely seen letters knowing you are betting on future attention. In both cases, identify the cover before looking at the price, and check your choice against the landmarks gathered on the blog.

The value of your copy depends entirely on the cover you hold and on its printing: have it identified before selling or insuring it.

Estimate my comic
The Walking Dead #100 (2012): the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

The range includes the regular cover by Charlie Adlard and a series of covers commissioned from guest artists, identified by letters, including a version on metallic stock. Convention or shop variants also circulate. Check the letter printed on the copy and cross-check it with the catalogue record, since sellers' names for them are inconsistent.

No. The interior pages are identical from one cover to the next, so the first appearance is the same everywhere. Paying more means buying a cover treatment, not extra content. If your goal is to tick off the first appearance, the most affordable letter in fine condition serves exactly the same purpose in the collection.

Look at how often that letter sells publicly over several months, at the number of graded copies recorded for it, and at the price gap between two neighbouring grades. A permanent supply signals abundance, even at a high price. A letter that disappears from sales for weeks is the real sign of scarcity, regardless of its reputation.

The mention appears in the small legal text on the credits page, and the cover treatment is sometimes modified. The story is identical, but the object belongs to a different market and trades far lower. If a listing does not show that page or stays silent on the printing, treat the information as missing and ask for it.

Create one line per cover and record the letter or artist's name in the variant field, not in a free-text note. Add the condition and, where relevant, the printing. This way you find your copies by cover and avoid buying again a letter you already have, a common error on an issue published in so many versions.