The best western comics: the tier list — article illustration

The best western comics are, at the top,Jonah Hex , East of West by Jonathan Hickman, Blueberry by Charlier and Giraud, and Preacher by Garth Ennis. This tier list classifies Western stories in comics according to their quality and influence, from classic western to hybrid western. Facts (authors, publishers, dates) checked, no invented ratings.

The western has nourished comics from its beginnings, before reinventing itself in modern, fantastic or apocalyptic versions. This tier list brings together the stories that best convey the spirit of the West – atmosphere, characters, tension – from the most classic to the most daring. Criterion: the success of the western story, whatever its form.

Editorial Ranks, Facts verified. Each entry refers to a site file when it exists.

Tier list — western comics
S
Jonah HexDC, 1972 East of WestHickman & Dragotta, 2013 BlueberryCharlier & Giraud, 1963 PreacherEnnis & Dillon, 1995
A
LovelessAzzarello & Frusin, 2005 The Sixth GunBunn & Hurtt, 2010 Pretty DeadlyDeConnick & Rios, 2013 ScalpedAaron & Guéra, 2007
B
All-Star WesternDC, 1970 Manifest DestinyDingess & Roberts, 2013 Django UnchainedVertigo, 2012 Two-Gun KidMarvel, 1948
C
Rawhide KidMarvel, 1955 Bat LashDC, 1968 Weird Western TalesDC, 1972 CopperheadFaerber & Godlewski, 2014
D
Kid ColtMarvel, 1948 TexasBonelli, 1948 GunhawksMarvel, 1972

Tier S: the Western peaks

Jonah Hex(1972) is the disfigured bounty hunter, a major DC western figure.East of Westreinvents the genre into a wildly ambitious apocalyptic SF western.Blueberry, by Charlier and Giraud (Moebius), is the pinnacle of the European western. AndPreacherhybrid western, road movie and theology with rare force.

Tier A: the great modern stories

Loveless by Brian Azzarello explores post-Civil War America.The Sixth Gun mixes western and supernatural,Pretty Deadly in fact a mythological tale, and Scalped transposes the codes of the western into a contemporary Indian reserve.

Tier B: gender values

All-Star Western , Manifest Destiny(Lewis and Clark Against the Fantastic), the adaptation of Django Unchained and the Two-Gun Kid from Marvel offer solid westerns, between classicism and rereading.

Tier C: the classics of the kiosk

Rawhide Kid , Bat Lash , Weird Western Tales and Copperhead(space western) complete the selection: good westerns, a notch below the peaks.

Tier D: the curiosities

Kid Colt , THE Texas of Bonelli (monument of the western in Italy) and Gunhawks close this selection: historical or foreign series, real but less known to the French-speaking public.

To remember

Frequently asked questions

Jonah Hex is the classic American western in comics. For a modern rereading,East of West (western SF) and Preacher(western hybrid) are the most striking.

Yes, in renewed forms: The Sixth Gun, Pretty Deadly or Manifest Destiny mix the West with fantasy, proving the vitality of the genre among independent publishers.

By East of West(modern and spectacular) or Blueberry(European classic). Both exist in accessible collections.

Do you own any old western comics (Jonah Hex, All-Star Western, etc.)?Estimate their value for freewith our tool based on real eBay sales.