Strange Tales #110 (1963): Doctor Strange's First Appearance, article illustration

Doctor Strange debuts in Strange Tales #110, cover-dated July 1963, in a short story written by Stan Lee and drawn by Steve Ditko. The sorcerer is already settled in his Greenwich Village townhouse and steps into the nightmare of a man who can no longer sleep. The same issue introduces Nightmare, his adversary in the dream realm. This is the issue collectors look for, and it sells for more than any other in the series.

Strange Tales #110 has one feature that makes life harder for the buyer: it is not a Doctor Strange issue. It is an anthology in which the sorcerer takes a handful of pages at the back, behind a lead feature that has nothing to do with him. Anyone hunting for the first appearance therefore has to buy a comic whose cover does not necessarily mention him in an obvious way, and whose condition is judged across the whole book, not just the eight pages that matter.

As always in this guide, only verified details (creators, issue numbers, dates) are stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

Profile of Strange Tales #110: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

The issue: date, creators, and what happens in the pages of Strange

Strange Tales #110 carries a cover date of July 1963. As with all American comics of that era, this date is the newsstand removal date, not the on-sale date: the issue was available several weeks earlier, in April or May depending on the distribution channel. A dealer who lists it as April 1963 is not necessarily wrong.

The sorcerer's story is credited to Stan Lee for the script and Steve Ditko for the art. The exact share of each man in creating the character has been the subject of conflicting accounts over the decades, since the recollections of the two men do not fully agree on this point; the printed credit, however, has never changed. If you describe the issue in an inventory or a listing, cite both names without settling the attribution debate.

In the story, Doctor Strange has no origin. He is presented as an established practitioner of the occult arts, consulted by a man terrorized by his dreams, and his intervention draws him into a confrontation with Nightmare on Nightmare's own ground. This absence of an origin story is the detail that surprises modern readers the most: the character's first appearance does not explain how he became who he is. That story comes later in the series, a few issues on, and it has its own market value.

The editorial context: a shared anthology, and a lead feature that is not him

Strange Tales existed well before 1963. The title had started in the late 1950s as a collection of fantasy and monster stories, the dominant format at the publisher at the time. From the early 1960s, the company gradually converted its anthologies into showcases for superheroes, and Strange Tales was given the Human Torch, that is Johnny Storm, a member of the Fantastic Four who was spun off for solo adventures, as its headliner.

When issue 110 was published, it was the Torch's series that held the main slot, the cover and the largest number of pages. Doctor Strange arrived as the second feature, in a short backup story. For a collector, this has an immediate consequence: the cover of #110 is not a Doctor Strange cover, and the imagery that sells the great first appearances, the hero in action in the foreground, does not exist here in the expected form.

This kind of sharing was not unusual at the publisher: some heroes were even moved from a title of their own into an anthology slot, as happened with the Hulk after his first series ended. Strange Tales, for its part, would eventually switch entirely to the sorcerer.

Why this issue became a key, and what its second first appearance is worth

The price of a 1963 issue owes nothing to its original print run: it is built decades later, when the character it contains becomes indispensable. Doctor Strange has endured, and above all he has gained a status that few creations of 1963 have reached: that of a visual reference. The impossible geometries and settings Ditko developed in the series established the sorcerer as a part of the graphic history of the medium, not only of its publishing history.

There is also an effect of structural scarcity. The 1963 print runs were not built to last: acidic paper, simple stapling, newsstand distribution, reading by children. The population of surviving copies in good condition is small, and the anthology format did not help, since nobody in 1963 had a reason to set aside an issue for its backup feature. The copies that survived did so because of the Torch, or by chance.

Nightmare, the entity that rules the realm of dreams, makes his first appearance in this same story. This is worth knowing, because it is systematically mentioned in listings and it is one more reason to hunt for the original comic rather than a reprint. On an issue whose value already rests on the lead character, a second first appearance does not add a second premium: it strengthens demand and widens the circle of interested buyers.

The issue also contains the first panels of characters from the sorcerer's inner circle, including his servant and his master, but the exact status of these appearances is debated depending on whether one counts the first image, the first mention of the name, or the first explicit identification in the story. Sources disagree, and the catalogs themselves do not always rule the same way from one checklist to another. If a seller bases a price on these secondary appearances, ask which definition they are relying on, and do not pay a premium for a disputed point.

What moves the price: condition, paper, completeness

On a 1963 comic, condition matters more than anything else. The gap between a read copy and a well-preserved one is not measured in percentages but in multiples, and moving up one grade in the upper part of the scale can be enough to double the value of a copy.

Three flaws matter especially on this issue. Color and spine wear, because anthology covers from this period handle center folds poorly. Paper browning, which is very common and which caps a grade even when the book looks clean. And above all completeness: the order form page and the cut-out interior pages are a classic problem with 1963 comics, and a missing page pushes the copy into a category of its own, whatever the apparent freshness of the rest.

Telling this issue apart from other editions: printing, reprint, facsimile

As far as we know, issue 110 had only one original printing, and there is no alternate price or cover variant of the kind found on modern series. The question is therefore not "which variant" but "is this really the 1963 comic". Three families of objects get confused with it in listings.

First, collections and reprints. The first-appearance story has been reprinted many times, in paperback collections, hardcover anthologies and newsstand reprint series. These volumes contain the same text and the same panels, they have no market connection to the original, and they are perfectly legitimate for someone who wants to read rather than own. Check the copyright date and the page count: an object with more than a hundred pages is not a 1963 comic.

Second, facsimiles and commemorative editions. The publisher has reissued several of its first appearances as reproductions close to the original, sometimes with the original cover and a modern indicia. The control point is always the same: the indicia, that is the legal notice in small print on the first or last interior page. It carries the real date and issue number of the object you are holding, and it will not lie, whereas a cover scanned in a listing can mislead.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Strange Tales #110 (1963): the sections of this guide, in reading order

Pitfalls when buying this specific issue

The first pitfall is confusing issue numbers. In a stack or in a photo of the spine, 110 and 115 look alike, and both numbers are key issues in the series for different reasons. Ask for a photo of the indicia, not just the cover, and read the issue number yourself.

The second is undisclosed restoration. Comics of this value have often been reinforced: spine strengthened, corner glued back, color touched up, staples replaced. These interventions are not illegitimate, but they must be disclosed, because they change the category of the object. A cover that looks too fresh for browned interiors deserves a written question to the seller.

Neighboring issues that also matter in the series

The timeline of the sorcerer's beginnings in Strange Tales is not continuous: after issue 110, the character does not come back in every issue, the anthology's backup feature having alternated with other stories for several months. This irregularity means the first episodes are spread over a wider range of issue numbers than one might expect, which makes building a starter collection more technical than a simple "110 through 120".

Two markers are worth tracking alongside 110 if you are building a collection of the character. The origin story, which recounts the accident, the journey and the training of the character, published a few issues later, and which is the most sought-after secondary key of the series. And the title change after issue 168, when Strange Tales became Doctor Strange while keeping its numbering: the first issues carrying the character's name are inexpensive objects but structurally important for a coherent collection.

What grading changes for a 1963 issue

Above a certain value level, professional grading with encapsulation becomes the transaction standard rather than an option. On a 1963 comic it provides three things: a grade that is comparable from one seller to another, an explicit statement of restorations and completeness defects, and an end to debates about the authenticity of the edition, since the grading service identifies the issue.

It also has effects you have to accept. The case prevents reading and tactile examination of the paper. The cost only makes sense if the expected value justifies it, which rules out copies at the bottom of the scale. And the grade assigned can be disappointing, because the criteria applied to older comics take into account defects that an untrained eye does not see, especially paper flatness and color.

How to track this issue in a collection

Also make sure to clearly separate, in your inventory, the original issue from any reprints of the same story you may own elsewhere. This is the kind of confusion that bothers no one for ten years, then costs a sale or skews a lot estimate. In My Comics Collection, the two objects are separate catalog entries, and tracking them separately keeps you from believing you own a key you do not own.

Finally, follow the value over time rather than at the moment of purchase. Old keys tied to film releases go through spikes and corrections, and the right selling decision is almost never the one you make in the weeks following a listing. The other guides in our key issues series follow the same method.

Conclusion

Strange Tales #110 is a 1963 key that behaves like a key, with one nuance not to lose sight of: you are buying an anthology whose headliner is not the character you care about. That does not change its value, but it changes how you examine it, since condition is judged across the whole book and the cover will not tell you what you are buying. Check the indicia, check completeness, and be wary of premiums asked for disputed secondary appearances.

The rest is a matter of patience. The supply of copies in good condition is narrow and will not widen, but it does renew itself, and demand breathes with the rhythm of adaptations. An informed buyer waits for a quiet window; a rushed buyer pays the peak.

If you have a Strange Tales from the 1963 period in your boxes and you do not know whether it is the 110, a reprint of the story, or a neighboring issue: have it examined before you insure it or sell it.

Estimate my comic
Strange Tales #110 (1963): the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

No. Issue 110 presents the sorcerer as an established practitioner, without explaining his background. The origin story was published a few issues later in the same series, and it is a separate secondary key, sought after in its own right. This is one of the reasons a coherent starter collection does not stop at issue 110 alone.

Because Strange Tales was then an anthology whose lead feature was the Human Torch, spun off from the Fantastic Four for solo adventures. The sorcerer only had a short backup story at the back of the comic. This editorial hierarchy also explains why so few copies were set aside at the time.

Nightmare, the entity that rules the realm of dreams and remains the adversary most closely associated with the character, makes his first appearance in this same story. Other figures from the sorcerer's inner circle also appear, but the exact status of those appearances is debated depending on the definition used, and it does not justify a quantified premium.

By the indicia, the legal notice printed in small type inside the book. It carries the real date and issue number of the object, whereas a cover may have been reproduced identically in a facsimile. The pagination also helps: a thick, hardcover or paperback volume is never the original July 1963 comic.

It depends on the likely grade. In the upper half of the scale, grading resolves doubts about the edition, restorations and completeness, and it moves the resale price well beyond its cost. At the bottom of the scale, the market accepts a raw copy described honestly very well, and the expense is not justified.