The first issue of the Hulk magazine published by Arédit-Artima (the French magazine) is dated December 1976. A detail that puzzles buyers: the title recorded in the catalogue for its contents is not "Hulk" but "Hercule". Another difficulty: a second French magazine titled Hulk, launched in April 1992 by Semic, also starts at number 1 and stops at the same rank. No issue separates the two series, so only the publication date decides.
You come across a listing titled "Hulk no. 1". The photo is blurred, the seller talks about a first issue, and you hesitate. The instinct would be to check the contents page to confirm that it is the right issue. On this particular title, that instinct works against you: the announced contents point to another character, and the number printed on the cover does not say which Hulk magazine it belongs to. This sheet details the two traps, then gives the criterion that resolves them.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact. The analysis is ours, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
The issue: a December 1976 date and a misleading title
The record for this issue is short and unambiguous on one point: the date given is December 1976. That is the marker to hold on to before anything else, because it is the only element that identifies this issue with certainty. The magazine's title does not do it, and the rank on the cover does even less.
Then comes the surprise. The title recorded for the contents of this first issue is "Hercule". Not a variation on the star character, not a subtitle: another name, pointing to another figure. A buyer who judges on that title alone believes he holds an issue off-topic, or wonders whether the seller has mixed up the lot.
This entry has to be read for what it is. Magazines of this format gathered several episodes per booklet, and the catalogue keeps only one title per issue, the one recorded first. That title therefore describes part of the booklet, not all of it. It tells you that a Hercules story is inside, but nothing about the rest of the contents, which must be checked on the copy itself, page by page.
Two Hulk magazines, two number 1s, and a complete overlap
The second trap is more serious, because it cannot be solved by opening the issue. Another French magazine carries exactly the same title, launched sixteen years later by a different publisher, with a first issue dated April 1992. It is numbered from 1, just like the 1976 one.
The overlap is not partial, it is total. The two series stop at the same rank, twenty-nine issues each. There is therefore no issue, not a single one, that belongs to one series and not the other. A "Hulk no. 14" is ambiguous, a "Hulk no. 29" just as much, and the last issue of each run carries the same number. Price lists sorted by rank mean nothing for this title unless the series is specified.
The criterion that settles it is the publication date, and only that. Any issue dated between late 1976 and the early 1980s belongs to the first magazine; any issue dated 1992 or later belongs to the second. If the seller does not give the date, ask for it, or ask for a sharp photo of the bottom of the cover and of the colophon. Failing a date, two secondary clues help: the publisher's name, and the graphic style of the cover, since the look of the seventies has nothing in common with that of the early nineties.
The creators credited on this issue
On the writing side, three names are recorded for this number: Roy Thomas, Stan Lee and A. Garcia. On the art side, Herb Trimpe, Sal Buscema and Jack Kirby. This multiple list is not a gap in the catalogue; it reflects the nature of the issue: several stories of different origins bound into one booklet, and therefore several creative teams under a single cover.
The name to remember for what follows is Herb Trimpe, because he returns issue after issue across almost the whole first series. A buyer looking for the visual consistency of this magazine is really looking for his pages. Sal Buscema takes over on several issues in the middle of the run, which gives the reader a second useful reference when the cover is damaged and only an inside page is photographed.
What sets this issue apart from the next ones
The publication rhythm is the most telling marker. The next issue is dated January 1977, one month later, but the third jumps to April 1977. In other words, the launch happens over two closely spaced issues, then the pace clearly loosens. For a collector, this means the first two numbers circulated almost together, and they are often found paired in original lots.
The other difference lies in what happens later in the series. Issue fifteen is dated December 1978, issue sixteen June 1981: two and a half years of interruption in the middle of the run. This break splits the series into two blocks that did not have the same commercial life, and the first issue belongs to the older block, the one that was kept least.
A detail that is amusing and telling: it is the restart issue, not the launch issue, that finally carries the title "Hulk!". The first issue announced Hercules, the sixteenth announces the star character. The contents title therefore does not follow the numbering order at all, and using it to date an issue leads to error.
Recognising a genuine first issue in a listing
Work by elimination, in this order, because each step rules out a different category of error.
First the date, which settles the question of the series. December 1976 identifies the issue you are looking for; April 1992 identifies the other first issue. Without a legible date, nothing else can proceed, and no other element of the listing replaces this check. Next the printed rank, which must be visible on the cover and not reconstructed by the seller from the contents: the catalogue shows precisely that the title "Hercule" comes back on two other issues of the series, one from late 1977, the other from late 1981. A seller who deduces "issue 1" from a contents page mentioning Hercules has about a one-in-three chance of being right.
Finally the object itself. Ask for a photo of the spine and one of the bottom of the last page. That is where the printing details are read, and where re-stapled or repaired booklets show up, a common practice on magazines of this format once the staples have given way.
What to check on the copy before buying
These booklets have a structural weak point: the spine. Stapled binding on yellowed paper eventually gives way at the fold, and a copy that opens flat without forcing is often a copy whose staples are already working loose. Hold the issue by the spine, let it hang for a few seconds, and see whether the inner block slides.
Then check completeness page by page, not just the announced page count. In a magazine that gathers several stories, a missing page in the middle of an episode goes unnoticed when flicking through, because the reader moves straight into another story without feeling the cut. Count the stories and check that each one runs to its last panel.
Finally watch for the wear typical of the period: corners dog-eared from being stored upright, water rings at the foot of the cover, a child's name written in ballpoint on the cover banner at the top. None of these marks is disqualifying on its own, but together on a seventies issue they explain most of the value gap between two copies described as equivalent.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
Why it is relatively scarce
A first issue is rarely rare because few were printed. It becomes rare because few were kept. At launch, nobody knows whether the magazine will last, and the issue is bought out of curiosity, read, lent, then thrown out with the newspapers. It is the middle-of-series issues, bought by readers already loyal, that come through the years in better condition.
The effect of the series' interruption adds to this. The first fifteen issues form an older set, separated from the rest by two and a half years of silence, and their original buyers were not necessarily there for the restart. Complete collections of this first stretch therefore break up less often as a single block, which is felt when buying piece by piece.
A last factor, less intuitive: the confusion with the 1992 namesake creates constant background noise on the market. Many "first issue" listings are in fact about the second magazine, much more recent and much more common. A collector who knows how to read the date sees that noise fade, and finds that the real supply of the 1976 first issue is narrower than the volume of listings suggests.
Frequent pitfalls on this specific issue
The series trap, already covered, is the most costly. The second is the listing that describes a contents page and deduces a rank from it, when that title actually comes back later in the run. The third is the lot presented as "from the start of the series" whose photo shows only the first copy on the pile: ask for a spread-out view where each cover shows its number.
Be wary too of matches with American publications stated as certainties. The contents of these booklets are an assembly, and the record we hold gives only one title per issue. It allows neither affirming which American issue this number corresponds to, nor saying that a story appears in French for the first time here. A seller who asserts it without showing the inside goes further than what can be verified, and it is up to you to ask for the pages.
Neighbouring issues, and why to take them together
The second issue, dated January 1977, is the purchase that goes most naturally with this one: one month apart, often the same source, and comparable condition. Its recorded title, "Mogol", confirms in passing that the magazine named its booklets after the story it featured rather than after its title character.
The third, from April 1977, marks the move to a more spaced rhythm and opens the magazine's first real year. Taking it with the first two gives a coherent starter set, and above all a point of comparison: three issues from the same printing run look alike, and a difference in paper tone between them often means that one of the three comes from elsewhere.
Condition and tracking your collection
Record the date of the issue in your inventory, not only its rank. That is the only way not to mix the two Hulk magazines in one table, and it is also what will let you later spot a duplicate without opening the box. Add a line on the condition of the spine, since that is the point that changes most over time with this format.
For storage, tight upright shelving is the enemy of these flexible booklets: it marks the corners and eventually bends the block. Prefer a low flat stack, or sleeves with a rigid backing. If you keep your tracking in a collection organised by character, separate the two homonymous series explicitly at data entry, otherwise sorting by number will produce ghost duplicates.
What to remember
This first issue is recognised by its December 1976 date, and by nothing else. Its title announces Hercules, which disorients the hurried buyer while saying only part of the booklet. Its rank does not identify it, since a 1992 magazine of the same name covers exactly the same range of numbers.
The rest is classic observation work: check the binding, count the stories to their last panel, compare the paper with that of the neighbouring issues. Our other collector guides detail the series themselves; this sheet was meant above all to give you the reflex that avoids the most common error on this title.
Frequently asked questions
Because the magazine gathered several stories per booklet, and the record we hold keeps only one title per issue, the one put forward. For this December 1976 issue, it is "Hercule". That indicates a Hercules story is inside, without saying anything about the rest of the contents, which is checked on the copy itself.
By the publication date, and by that alone. This one is dated December 1976, the other April 1992. Since both series are numbered from 1 to 29, no rank is distinctive. Without a legible date, the publisher named and the style of the cover give an indication, never a certainty.
No, and this is a frequent source of error on this title. The title "Hercule" comes back on two other issues of the series, one from late 1977 and one from late 1981. Deducing the rank from the contents therefore leaves a one-in-three chance of being right. Ask for a photo of the number printed on the cover.
On writing, Roy Thomas, Stan Lee and A. Garcia. On art, Herb Trimpe, Sal Buscema and Jack Kirby. This plurality of names reflects the assembly of several stories under one cover. Herb Trimpe is the most useful reference, his pages recurring throughout the first series.
Harder than the volume of listings suggests. Many offers for "Hulk number 1" in fact concern the 1992 magazine, which is much more common. Add to that the fact that a launch issue is poorly kept, and that the series' interruption between late 1978 and summer 1981 separated this first block from the rest.