Flash versus comics: the invention of the multiverse

How a 1961 editor's tinkering became the bedrock of a decade of television. Decryption source by source, without disclosing the outcomes.

As in each article in this series, only verified information (creators, distribution, dates, publishers) is stated; the comparative analysis is ours, without reproducing dialogue or protected images.

1956: the number that relaunched a genre

Showcase #4(1956) not only contains the first appearance of Barry Allen. This is the number which, according to general opinion,opens the silver age comics.

The context explains it. After the war, the superhero had collapsed commercially; publishers lived on romance, war, westerns and horror. DC is trying a cautious experiment: taking the name of a 1940s hero, Flash, but with an entirely new character — Barry Allen, police scientist — in a test title intended to gauge demand.

It was a clear success, and it triggered the wave of reconstructions that produced the modern catalog. Without this issue, neither Hal Jordan's Green Lantern, nor the Justice League, nor the competition's response a few years later.

The story itself is modest: a laboratory accident, a man running fast, a suit in a ring. What matters is not what he says but what he made possible.

1961: an editor problem becomes the multiverse

Five years later appears The Flash #123, under the title “Flash of Two Worlds”. It is, in its way, an even more important number.

The problem this story solves is purely practical. DC released a Flash in the 1940s, then another in 1956, unrelated to each other. The oldest readers asked what had happened to the first one. The editor had two options: decree that the old one had never existed, or explain it.

The response was multiverse: the two Flashes exist, on two parallel Earths, and the speed allows them to go from one to the other. Nothing is canceled, everything is preserved, and inconsistency becomes a decoration.

We must measure what happened there. An editorial DIY solution, invented so as not to annoy a few loyal readers, has become the dominant narrative structure of popular fiction sixty years later. This corpus encountered many unforeseen consequences; this is the most extensive.

2014: reintroduce what Arrow had banned

The 2014 series derives from a series that explicitly refused fantasy. Its function, overall, is to open this door.

She does it straightforwardly: a collective accident produces numerous individuals endowed with powers, which suddenly provides a hero, a gallery of adversaries and a common explanation. It's a departure from the comics, where the Rogues have scattered origins — but it's a format convenience, and it's honest.

The real contribution lies in your. Where the parent series cultivated mourning and night, this one finds the clarity of the Silver Age: bright colors, a team that jokes, a hero who loves what he does.

This corpus formulated this observation aboutThe Alliance of Heroes: adaptations that assume the Silver Age are rare, and they reopen a fund that decades of darkness had made unusable. Flash belongs to this family — and its success has helped make this register defensible again on television.

The multiverse as a production solution

There is an irony that the series illustrates perfectly, and which deserves to be developed.

The multiverse, in 1961, was used to solve a continuity problem. In the series, it serves exactly the same purpose - but for production reasons: to make series with an incompatible tone coexist, to justify that an actor returns in another role, to integrate previous versions of the character from other eras and other channels.

In other words, a trick invented to manage the archives of a publisher in 1961 turns out, sixty years later, to be the ideal tool for managing the archives of a audiovisual catalog. The problem has changed in nature, the solution has remained the same.

There is a warning here that comic book readers know well. The multiverse resolves everything, and this is precisely its danger: when everything is possible and any error can be attributed to another Earth, nothing has any consequences. Comics experienced this saturation point — this is what led to the 1985 event that this body of work examines elsewhere.

The characters, from paper to screen

• Barry Allen— Scientific policeman, as in 1956.
• The Rogues— The almost complete gallery, with shared origins.
• The team— Created for the series, with no equivalent on paper.
• The other Flashes— Present thanks to the 1961 multiverse.
• The murder of the mother— Borrowed from Flashpoint (2011).

Flashpoint, or the cost of time travel

The series borrows from Flashpoint(2011) his strongest point: Barry Allen goes back in time to prevent the murder of his mother, and discovers that the modification has consequences far beyond what he intended.

It's a powerful idea, and for a moral rather than a spectacular reason. Time travel, in most fiction, is a tool for resolution: we go back, we correct, we come back. Here it becomes a tool of guilt. The hero does not face an adversary but the consequences of his own action - and an action that the spectator approves, since it involves saving his mother.

The series uses this device repeatedly, perhaps too much, and it wears out. But it provides a character with power without clear limits the one thing he might lack: a mistake.

It is also a good illustration of what this body of work has found elsewhere — excessive power is not corrected by reducing it, but by putting a price on it.

Les Rogues, a gallery that works differently

A word about the adversaries, as they are one of the best-designed galleries in the catalog and the series was right to stick with them.

The Rogues don't look like Batman or Spider-Man's enemies. They are neither madmen, nor monsters, nor ideologues: they are professionals. Robbers equipped with special equipment, who know each other, organize themselves, respect the rules between them, and consider Flash as a risk of the job rather than as an obsession.

This configuration produces a unique report of its kind. The hero and his adversaries treat each other with a form of working courtesy. No one seeks to destroy the other; everyone does their job.

This is also what makes them adaptable to a weekly format. An obsessive adversary cannot return indefinitely without becoming absurd; a robber, yes — he simply has a new job to do. Comics understood this in the 1960s, and that's why this gallery has survived the decades without wearing out.

For the reader, this is an often neglected reading avenue. The stories centered around the Rogues are among the most enjoyable in the DC catalog, precisely because they escape the register of the struggle of good against evil — they follow people doing difficult work.

Collection side: which numbers to aim for after the series

Showcase #4(1956) is one of the major keys to the Silver Age, often cited among the five most sought-after post-war comics. His rating is very high and has never weakened - this corpus devoted adetailed analysis.

The important point for the buyer is elsewhere.The Flash #123(1961) contains the invention of the multiverse, that is to say the idea which structures a considerable part of popular fiction today. Its rating is significantly lower than that of Showcase #4, although its influence is undoubtedly greater.

This is a gap that this corpus encounters regularly, and which deserves to be understood. The market values first appearances much more than the ideas. An issue that introduces a character sells, an issue that introduces a concept sells less — even when the concept produced more.

For a collector who thinks in the long term, this gap constitutes an avenue. Concept numbers are rarer in high grade — no one has put them aside — and their importance has not yet been fully integrated by the market.

Finally,Flashpoint #1(2011) is a common modern comic, very cheap, and it is the direct source of the common thread of the series. As always, condition and gradation determine value; relying on real recent sales is strongly recommended.

Where to start reading

The Flash #123(1961) can be read alone in a few minutes, and we witness the invention of an idea that has become omnipresent. For the common thread of the series,Flashpoint(2011) is a direct, comprehensive and accessible reading.

Timeline to know

• 1956— Showcase #4: Barry Allen opens the Silver Age.
• 1961— The Flash #123 invents the multiverse to resolve an inconsistency.
• 1985— The multiverse saturates and causes a rethinking.
• 2011— Flashpoint puts a price on time travel.
• 2014— The series reintroduces fantasy into the Arrowverse.

Its place in the saga and for the collector

This series will remain as the one which reopened the register of the silver age on television, and above all as the demonstration that a 1961 editorial DIY solution— the multiverse, invented so as not to annoy a few readers — could become the management tool for an entire audiovisual catalog. It also shows that unlimited power cannot be corrected by reducing it but by giving it a price. For the collector, it indicates an exploitable market gap: The Flash #123 is worth much less than Showcase #4 even though its influence is greater.

The verdict: the silver age preserved, the origins shared

• Loyalty: Barry Allen police scientist, the multiverse of 1961, the almost complete Rogues' gallery, the clear tone of the Silver Age and the cost of time travel from 2011.
• Freedoms: a collective origin instead of an isolated accident, an invented support team, the murder of the mother borrowed from Flashpoint, Rogues with common origins and a tightened chronology.
• Collectible numbers: Showcase #4 (1956), The Flash #123 (1961), Flashpoint #1 (2011).

An editor in 1961 was looking to explain why two characters had the same name. His response structures much of cinema and television today — and no one at the time thought it was anything other than a mending.

Frequently asked questions