Detective Comics #475 (1978): The Laughing Fish and Why It Sells High, article illustration

Detective Comics #475, cover-dated February 1978, opens "The Laughing Fish", a story written by Steve Englehart, drawn by Marshall Rogers and inked by Terry Austin, under the editorial direction of Julius Schwartz. The Joker poisons fish that bear his grin, then demands to register their commercial ownership. No first appearance here: the issue is sought for its cover and for the reference status this story has since acquired.

This is one of the rare issues that sellers present without ever uttering the word "first", and which still trades above its immediate neighbours. For a collector used to indexing his purchases on inaugural appearances, this #475 is a useful textbook case: it forces you to name the other drivers of value, the cover, the critical standing of a story, the relative scarcity of a late-1970s print run. Knowing why it rises means recognising the next issues of this type before they are labelled as such.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

Profile of Detective Comics #475: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

What the February 1978 issue contains, exactly

Detective Comics #475 carries the cover date February 1978, which places its newsstand release in autumn or late 1977 depending on the distribution circuit. The main story is titled "The Laughing Fish". Steve Englehart writes it, Marshall Rogers pencils it, Terry Austin inks it. Julius Schwartz is the editor in charge. This combination of names is the first thing to check when the issue is offered to you: it appears in the indicia and in the catalogue, and it immediately distinguishes this issue from later reprints, where the pagination and advertisements differ.

The plot runs on a simple mechanism, and that is what makes it memorable. The Joker contaminates an ordinary food item, fish sold at the market stalls, so that every piece carries his expression. Then, instead of demanding a ransom, he demands a right: he wants these fish registered as his creation and to collect on every sale. The engine is not theft but administration, and it is this mismatch that commentators have remembered.

The story does not conclude in this issue. It continues in Detective Comics #476, "Sign of the Joker!", by the same creative team. A collector who buys #475 alone owns the first half of a diptych, which has a direct consequence for resale: the two issues together sell more easily than each one separately.

The series at this precise point in its history

In the mid-1970s, Detective Comics goes through a period when page count, cover price and the space given to backup stories often change. The issues of this sequence alternate lead story and backup features, and several carry a mention of an expanded format. Check the page count and the printed price on your copy rather than assuming a uniform format across the whole series.

Englehart writes the series only over a short run of issues, around #470, and this brevity counts in the way the market treats it. A short, tight run becomes identifiable, people talk about it as a block, and each issue of the block inherits part of the reputation of the whole. The run introduces Silver St. Cloud, who first appears in Detective Comics #470, and brings back antagonists such as Hugo Strange and city councilman Rupert Thorne, in a local political plot that runs across several issues.

Marshall Rogers arrives on the series during this run, and his line is instantly recognisable: very elongated silhouettes, urban architecture treated as a character, a cape that fills the composition. Combined with Terry Austin's inking, this style fixed for a long time a particular graphic image of the character. #475 is one of the issues where this partnership reads most clearly.

Why an issue with no first appearance ends up costing a lot

Three drivers combine here, and none of them is an inaugural appearance.

The first is the cover. That of #475 puts the Joker and the fish motif forward, an image identified in a second even from a distance, even in a badly sorted box. Covers that read immediately sell better than narrative covers, because they work framed, as a thumbnail in a listing, as a miniature in a list of results. This is a value of use, not a value of plot.

The second is the reference status of the story. "The Laughing Fish" was adapted for television in an episode of the animated series of the early 1990s that takes its title, and later writers working on the Joker regularly cite this story among their touchstones. Each revival points readers back to the original issue. An adaptation does not create scarcity, but it creates demand, and on an older print run demand is enough.

The third is the place of the story within the Englehart and Rogers run. When a short stretch becomes canonical, collectors look for the complete stretch, and the most sought-after issues of that stretch act as a locomotive for the rest. #475 occupies this position.

A practical consequence to keep in mind: on this type of issue, the value rests on a reputation kept alive by adaptations and citations. It is a more mobile foundation than a first appearance, which remains true even if nobody talks about it for ten years. We detail this reasoning on the Joker hub, where this issue sits alongside other entries whose value does not depend on an inauguration.

What moves the value from one copy to another

On a 1978 comic, the gap between two copies of the same issue comes first from condition. Paper from this period yellows unevenly depending on storage, and the difference between cream pages and clearly browned ones is visible to the naked eye before you even look at the folds.

The defects that weigh most on this format are well known: spine sagging at the staple, micro-creases along the right edge of the cover caused by handling at the newsstand, and above all the vertical reading fold that runs across the Joker's face. On a cover whose value rests on the image, a defect located within the image costs more than an equivalent defect in the margin. Two copies graded at the same overall level can sell at noticeably different prices if one has its defect in the border and the other across the full figure.

Consider the geographic dimension as well. North American, British and Australian copies of this period do not circulate in the same markets and are not valued against the same references. A copy bought outside its home market often resells more slowly, not because it is worth less, but because the expected buyer is not on the spot.

Telling the original from a reprint or a facsimile

The content of this issue has been made available several times, which multiplies the chances of confusion. Englehart and Rogers' run has been collected in a volume, and the story also appears in anthologies devoted to the Joker. A collection does not get confused with the issue, but a collection cover reusing the fish image can mislead on a poorly framed photo.

The more serious trap is that of facsimile editions. The publisher has issued them for various older issues, and they deliberately reproduce the original cover. The mark that distinguishes them is printed, usually on the cover and always in the indicia, with a recent publication date and a current production barcode. Do not rely on the look of the cover: open the issue and read the legal notice page. If the listing does not show this page, ask for it before paying.

Three checks are enough in the vast majority of cases. The printed cover price must match the pricing of the period, not a contemporary price. The interior advertisements must be period ones: a facsimile keeps them, but a collection removes them. And the paper of a 1978 print run has neither the whiteness nor the feel of recent paper, even on a very well-preserved copy.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Detective Comics #475 (1978): the sections of this guide, in reading order

Pitfalls at the point of purchase on this specific issue

The first pitfall is vocabulary. Since this issue has no first appearance to put forward, some listings compensate with vague phrases such as "first modern Joker story" or "start of the classic era". These phrases have no stable definition and appear in no catalogue. Ask exactly what is being claimed, and pay only for what can be verified: the date, the creative team, the story title.

The second pitfall is splitting the diptych. Since the story ends in #476, a seller who owns both has every reason to sell them together. A #475 offered alone at a price that assumes the lot costs you twice: once at purchase, and again when you look for #476 at the going rate.

The third pitfall concerns graded copies whose label carries no qualitative mention about the colour of the paper or about a restoration. On a series from 1978, the absence of information is not information. Ask for flat photos, front and back, under raking light that reveals the folds, plus a shot of the edge.

The neighbouring issues that deserve the same attention

#476 is the necessary complement, since it closes "The Laughing Fish". Treat the two as a single line in your buying list.

Earlier, #470 deserves to be known for the arrival of Silver St. Cloud, and the issues that follow it carry the storyline involving Hugo Strange and Rupert Thorne. These issues are less sought after than #475, often available in good condition for a fraction of its value, and they fill out the sequence. For a collector building a coherent set rather than a pile of isolated issues, this is the best value in this corner of the series.

In this late-1970s stretch, issues whose cover is instantly identifiable rise, and the others stay quiet. If you are wondering where to put your budget, look at the covers first, not the contents.

What grading changes, and when it changes nothing

Having a copy graded fixes its condition and makes it comparable, which matters in a period when paper varies a great deal. On this issue, grading has a particular effect: since the value rests on the cover image, a case that protects that cover from a future fold literally protects the value.

But grading has a cost, and that cost is roughly constant whatever the issue. It is therefore justified on a high-end copy, where one grade step can move the value by a multiple, and not on an average read and folded copy, where the cost of the operation may exceed the gain. The practical rule: estimate first, grade afterwards, never the reverse.

If your copy carries a restoration, even a light one, say so before sending it. A cover cleaning or a spine consolidation will show up on examination, and a declared restoration resells better than a discovered one.

Following it in a collection

An issue like this one requires slightly different tracking from a first appearance. Of course, record the series, the number and the year, but add two fields: whether the copy is an original printing or a facsimile, and whether or not #476 is in your collection. This second field will stop you forgetting that you are missing half of the story.

Also note the nature of the main defect, not just its severity. "Vertical fold across the face on the cover" and "vertical fold on the right edge" do not weigh the same at resale, and in two years you will no longer remember which was which. A photo attached to the file settles the question for good.

Finally, watch for announcements of animated adaptations or productions revisiting this story. On an issue whose demand is kept alive by its revivals, the announcement comes several weeks before the price rise. Our collecting guides describe this monitoring method, and character hubs such as that of Harley Quinn show the same mechanism applied to other entries.

What to keep in mind before buying

Detective Comics #475 demonstrates that an issue can trade high without containing any inaugural appearance. Its cover is recognised instantly, its story has served as a reference since the 1990s, and it belongs to a short, identified stretch of the series. These are three real assets, but they are reputation assets, so they are to be monitored rather than taken for granted.

In practical terms: require the legal notice page to rule out a facsimile, aim for #475 and #476 together, look at where the defect sits before looking at its grade, and have the copy valued before having it graded. If you already own the copy, the only remaining question is where it stands today against its real condition.

Do you hold a Detective Comics #475 and are you torn between having it graded and keeping it as it is? Have it placed first.

Estimate my comic
Detective Comics #475 (1978): the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

No, and that is what makes it an interesting case. The February 1978 issue introduces no new character. Its value rests on its cover by Marshall Rogers, on the reputation of the story "The Laughing Fish" and on its place in the short run written by Steve Englehart. Listings claiming a first appearance are either mistaken or bending the facts.

Yes, if you are buying to read or to resell. "The Laughing Fish" concludes in Detective Comics #476, "Sign of the Joker!", by the same creative team. The two issues sell more easily as a lot than separately, and a #476 bought later on its own will cost you the going rate rather than a price negotiated on the pair.

Open it and read the indicia. A facsimile carries a recent publication date, a current production barcode and often an explicit mention on the cover. The printed price must match the 1978 pricing. Paper from a period print run never has the whiteness of recent paper, even on a remarkably well-preserved copy.

The episode of the animated series of the early 1990s that takes the title sent a generation of viewers back to the original story, and each later citation by the authors keeps that demand alive. An adaptation does not reduce the number of copies available, but on a 1978 print run the increase in demand is enough to move the value.

It depends on the condition. On a high-end copy, the case protects the cover that carries all the value, and one grade step weighs heavily. On a read copy, with a fold running across the illustration, the cost of the operation may exceed the expected gain. Estimate first, then decide.