Batman: The Killing Joke (1988): The Key First Printing Guide, article illustration

Batman: The Killing Joke came out in 1988 from DC Comics, as a hardcover album of about forty pages, written by Alan Moore, drawn by Brian Bolland and colored by John Higgins. The Joker escapes, turns up at Commissioner Gordon's house, shoots his daughter Barbara, then drags the father through a night of staging. The story also offers one possible version of the Joker's past. Collectors look for it for that reason, and for its first printing, which has become the minority.

Few albums have a value that rests entirely on a page nobody looks at. Here, the cover will tell you nothing: it stayed almost unchanged through more than thirty years of reprints, and a copy printed last year looks, in a bin, like a copy from 1988. The difference lies in a few lines of legal text inside. If you buy this title without reading them, you are buying a gamble.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is ours, with no reproduction of any panel or protected dialogue.

Profile of Batman: The Killing Joke #1: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

The book: 1988, three names, about forty pages

The full title is Batman: The Killing Joke. It carries no serial number: it is a standalone volume, published directly as a hardcover and then as a softcover, without going through the monthly newsstand format. The script is by Alan Moore, the art by Brian Bolland, the colors by John Higgins. That split matters for what follows: Bolland would redo the coloring two decades later, and that redo today marks a clear dividing line between two families of copies.

The story takes place over one night. The Joker, escaped, shows up at Commissioner Gordon's home, shoots Barbara Gordon, kidnaps the father and forces him through a course in a derelict amusement park. Alongside, flashback sequences offer an explanation of the Joker's origin, an explanation the character himself downplays within the story. This deliberate ambiguity is one reason the book is still debated: it provides a biography without guaranteeing it.

The page count is short, given how important the title has become. You are holding a thin object with a square spine, and the spine is the first thing to inspect when buying from a seller: it marks, whitens, and fans open when the album has been read lying flat. On a stapled comic, collectors speak of a center fold; here, of spine creases, and they cannot be undone.

The editorial context: the standalone album rather than the series

By the late 1980s, the hardcover album sold outside the monthly circuit had become a common format for stories a publisher wanted to take out of the regular flow. Larger format, thicker paper, square spine, higher price, and distribution handled as much by specialty bookstores as by general retailers. The Killing Joke belongs to this category, and that has two very concrete consequences for a collector.

First consequence: there is no "newsstand" printing and "direct market" printing to tell apart, as there is on monthly issues of the same period, and cover marking variants do not arise in the same way. Second consequence, the heavier one: a backlist album is reprinted as soon as it sells out, and it often sells out. The title has never left the shelves since 1988.

In other words, the object was designed to last in bookstores, not to be rare. That is the reverse of the logic of a monthly issue, whose print run is single and whose surviving copies wear away. Here, the world stock grows every year.

Why this volume became a key issue

Three factors combine. The first comes from the story itself: Barbara Gordon's wound stayed in the editorial continuity for years, which makes this album a turning point for a supporting character, not an episode closed on its last page. The second is the name on the script: titles signed by Alan Moore have lasting demand beyond the usual superhero readership, and that demand comes as much from general readers as from collectors.

The third factor is the animated adaptation released in 2016, which put the title back in the search results of the general public and set off a wave of reprint purchases. That wave did not push up the price of reprints, which are plentiful, but it widened the gap with the first printing.

It is important to be clear about what is rare: the story is not rare, the book is not rare, only the first printing is. Anyone who wants the text buys any copy. Anyone who wants the 1988 object enters a narrow market where the seller knows, or should know, what they are holding.

A key issue for Barbara Gordon

Let us say it plainly: the story permanently maims a supporting character, and that choice was debated from the start, including by Moore himself in later interviews. Barbara Gordon is wounded to produce an effect on her father and on Batman, and the book shows no interest in her beyond that function. That is a weakness of the story, not a collecting detail.

For collecting, the consequence is nonetheless real. The publisher did not cancel that wound, and the character was rebuilt from it in the following publications, under another identity and in another role, that of coordinator and analyst. A collector who follows the thread of Barbara Gordon should therefore own this album, even if they prefer to keep their hardcover albums apart from their monthly issues. The Batgirl page gathers the other landmarks of this thread, including the issues that come before 1988 and those that follow it.

The central problem: almost everything in circulation is a reprint

If you see a dozen copies for sale on the same day, the working assumption is that none of them is from 1988. The title went through printing after printing without interruption, in hardcover and then in softcover, at the American publisher as well as with its foreign partners, and the number of successive print runs is counted in the dozens. A listing that shows "1988 edition" without justification refers, nine times out of ten, to the copyright date printed on a reprint.

This is the structural trap of this title, and it differs from that of a monthly issue. On a reprinted monthly, the publisher almost always adds a visible mark to the cover, or changes the cover, or removes the distribution code. On a backlist album, nothing changes on the outside. Two copies thirty years apart look identical in a bin, and the only way to tell them apart is to open the book.

Recognizing a first printing: the copyright page

The method is always the same, and it has nothing to do with the cover. Open the album to the page that carries the copyright, the credits and the printer's name, usually at the very beginning or the very end depending on the edition. That is where the publisher records the rank of the print run.

What you are looking for: a notice such as "second printing", "third printing", or a list of printing numbers. If it is there, the matter is settled, the rank is written in black and white. Its absence is, for this title as for many albums of this period, a sign of a first printing, but a negative sign: it has to be cross-checked with the rest of the page, dates and the publisher's wording, which has changed presentation over the decades.

Three complementary habits. Compare the page count and the placement of the credits with the catalog, because later editions enriched the front matter. Check the binding: hardcover with dust jacket, hardcover without dust jacket, or softcover, each form corresponds to a distinct phase of publication. And require a clear photograph of this page before buying at a distance; a seller who refuses it has already told you something.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Batman: the sections of this guide, in reading order

Editions derived from the original and the question of color

Two decades after publication, a deluxe edition presented the story with coloring redone by Brian Bolland himself, more subdued and less saturated than John Higgins's original coloring. This edition also adds extra pages. For a collector, this is the easiest distinction to make without opening the book: if the interior panels look dull and contrasty where you expected bright tones, you are holding the recolored version, and therefore a late edition.

Then came the editions tied to the release of the animated film, followed by various reissues in collections and compiled formats. None of these editions is a counterfeit, none should be avoided if you want to read it; none should be presented as a first printing. On the French side, the story was published and republished under several successive covers, in layouts and formats that match no American print run: a French edition, even an old one, is never the first printing of the title.

The pitfalls when buying

The first pitfall is the single cover photograph: it proves nothing here, unlike a monthly issue whose cover carries the date and the distribution marking. Demand the inside.

The second pitfall is the dust jacket. On hardcover copies that had one, its absence changes the perceived condition, and some sellers photograph the album wearing the dust jacket of another edition: check that its spine and the book's spine show the same presentation.

The third pitfall is the spine. An album with a square spine, opened flat, keeps parallel white creases that no flattening removes: ask for a photo of the spine, front and profile, in raking light.

The fourth pitfall is the signature. The three creators signed a great deal at conventions, and a felt-tip signature on a front endpaper is worth something only if it is documented. On a common printing, it does not make a 1988 copy, only an annotated copy.

Neighboring issues that matter too

Several threads cross around this album. The earlier appearances of the Joker, listed on his hub, form a progression of which this volume is the editorial culmination more than the starting point. On the side of related characters, the issues that feature the legacy of Batman's supporting roles are often sought out in parallel: see Nightwing and Robin for those threads, which went through editorial events of their own in the late 1980s.

Let us also mention the character who would accompany the Joker for a long time, born a few years later in another medium before moving into comics: see the Harley Quinn hub. A coherent set around the Joker generally brings together this album, the first appearances in monthly form, and the issues of the 1990s in which the character becomes a headliner.

What grading changes here

Grading an album with a square spine does not follow the constraints of a stapled comic. The defects that count are spine whitening, crushed corners, dust jacket wear and the warping of the paper block. The criteria that dominate on a monthly, center fold and staples, do not apply.

On this title, the value of professional grading is twofold: it fixes the condition, and above all the label states the printing rank. It makes public the check of the copyright page, which can no longer be done once the book is sealed. For a first printing in fine condition, that is the only way to make the rarity legible to a wary buyer. For a reprint, the cost exceeds the value of the object.

Between two first-printing copies, moving from a correct condition to a near-mint one can change the price by an order of magnitude, far more than on a monthly of the same period, because the albums were read and the copies spared are few.

How to track it in a collection

The habit to adopt is never to record this title without its printing rank. In your inventory, the useful line is not "Batman: The Killing Joke", which distinguishes nothing, but the pairing of the title and the notice found inside, plus the binding form. Write them down at the time of purchase, not later: once the album is shelved, nobody reopens the copyright page.

If you hold several copies, a frequent case here because you end up buying one to read, separate the keeping copy from the reading copy, and photograph the copyright page of each: it is the document any serious buyer will ask for first.

This is a title where knowledge pays more than budget. The 1988 story by Moore, Bolland and Higgins is found everywhere and for almost nothing; the 1988 object is rarely found, and it is recognized in thirty seconds if you know which page to open. Between the two, the gap in value is considerable and it cannot be read anywhere on the cover. Make a habit of asking for the inside before talking price, and you will never pay a reprint's price for a first printing.

Torn between a first printing and a reprint of the 1988 album? Have your copy estimated from its copyright page.

Estimate my comic
Batman: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

Open the page that carries the copyright and the credits. A printing-rank notice, "second printing" or equivalent, indicates a reprint. The absence of any rank notice points to a first printing, but it has to be cross-checked with the binding form and the publisher's wording, which has changed presentation over the decades.

No, and that is the peculiarity of this title. Brian Bolland's illustration was kept on most of the successive printings, with no reprint marking added to the outside. Unlike a monthly, the backlist album signals nothing on its cover: the distinction is made only inside.

The script is by Alan Moore, the art by Brian Bolland and the original coloring by John Higgins. Bolland redid the coloring himself for a deluxe edition published two decades after the 1988 original, which gives two distinct visual versions of the same story.

It has reading and comparison interest, because the coloring by Bolland noticeably changes how the panels read. However, it came out twenty years after the original, it was printed in quantity, and it never trades at the level of a 1988 first printing.

Because the gunshot wound she suffers in this story was not erased by the publisher. The character was rebuilt from that state in the following publications, under another identity. The album therefore becomes an essential landmark for anyone following that thread, regardless of criticism of that narrative choice.