Wonder Woman #1 carries a Summer 1942 cover date and launches the heroine's first solo series, from All-American Publications. The script is by William Moulton Marston, under the pseudonym Charles Moulton, and the art is by Harry G. Peter. The contents unfold the Amazon origin across several chapters: the island, Queen Hippolyta, the animated clay statue, and the contest that selects the emissary sent into man's world. Collectors look for it for exactly this reason: it is where the origin becomes a complete story.
For a collector, this issue occupies an awkward place. It is not the heroine's beginning, yet it remains one of the three or four issues you aim for when building a pre-war shelf around her. The market knows this, and so do the sellers. As a result, a middling copy often trades at the price of a decent copy, for lack of recent comparison points. Knowing what this issue contains, under which publisher's imprint it came out and how often it appeared changes the way you read a listing.
As always in this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact. The analysis is ours, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
The issue: date, creators, what it contains
The cover date is Summer 1942. This seasonal mention is not decorative: it indicates a quarterly title, so four issues a year at most, and it serves as the first check when someone shows you a photo. A copy whose cover announces a specific month is not this issue.
The script is credited to Charles Moulton, the pseudonym under which William Moulton Marston worked on all of the heroine's stories. The visual treatment is by Harry G. Peter, whose stiff, decorative, almost engraved line is recognizable at a glance and serves as a mark of authenticity on the interior pages as much as on the cover.
The content is the real subject. The issue devotes its opening to the origin as it was developed: Queen Hippolyta, the island forbidden to men, the clay figure shaped and then brought to life, the accidental arrival of aviator Steve Trevor, and the competition organized to choose the woman who will bring him back. The following chapters move on to the heroine's early days outside the island. Where the first appearance had taken a few introductory pages, this issue establishes a complete mythology, with its gods, its rules and its taboos.
The publisher: a name you do not expect
The point most listings gloss over: in 1942, this title does not come out under the imprint now associated with the heroine. It was published by All-American Publications, a separate sister company that then ran its own roster of characters before the merger that unified the logos. The publisher banners on the covers of this period therefore carry a mark that is no longer in use.
This nuance has three practical consequences. First, a buyer searching a catalogue by modern publisher name can miss the correct entry. Second, the logo printed on the cover is a usable period marker: a cover bearing a later imprint is not a 1942 printing. Third, the contemporary titles from the same house share these visual cues, which gives useful comparison points when you learn to recognize an original printing.
The editorial context: quarterly and rationed paper
In 1942, the country had entered the war, and paper had become a controlled resource. Publishers balanced their titles, cut page counts and spaced out releases. Choosing a quarterly rhythm for a new title was not a lack of editorial confidence: it was what the paper allocation allowed, alongside a monthly presence already assured by the anthology magazine that carried the heroine.
For today's scarcity, the mechanism is simple. Fewer issues per year means fewer print runs, and a 1942 print run then went through the paper drives of the war effort, which destroyed large quantities of comics. Add the format: stapled, printed on cheap paper that yellows and breaks, sold at the ten-cent cover price to a child audience. Surviving copies in good condition are rare not by accident but by construction.
Why this issue became a key
Three reasons add up, and they are of different natures. The first is narrative: this is the episode where the origin stops being a sketch and becomes a reference text, the one later retellings return to, whether they respect it or contradict it. The second is bibliographic: the first issue of a solo series is a landmark every long-term collector sets for themselves, because it opens a numbering sequence that can then be completed.
The third is a question of supply. At this level of scarcity, the price no longer depends only on demand but on how many copies actually circulate in a given year. An issue can stay expensive without making any noise, simply because nobody is selling it. That is exactly the situation of this Summer 1942 booklet, whose notable copies are rare, clustered, and therefore very visible when they do appear.
What moves the price: condition, pages, integrity
On an issue from this period, the gap between two copies is not a nuance, it is a change of price category. The factors that weigh most are, in order: the integrity of the cover and its staples, the presence of all pages including the coupons and game pages that early readers often cut out, the pliability of the paper, and whether or not the pages have yellowed.
Two pitfalls deserve naming. Old restorations, very common on 1940s booklets, sharply lower relative value even when they are well executed, and they are not always disclosed. And a detached cover, even partly at the staples, costs proportionally more than a surface defect of similar size, because it affects the structure of the object. Conversely, a cover whose colors have held up can support the price of an otherwise tired copy.
Neighboring series from the same imprint, such as the early issues of the Flash title, follow the same grading logic and offer methodological reference points when sales of the issue you are interested in are lacking.
Telling one edition from another
The issue had no second period printing, which simplifies one point and complicates another: anything that is not the 1942 printing is an identifiable reprint, but these reprints are numerous, and some copy the cover exactly.
There are three families to tell apart. The large-format reprints of the 1970s, noticeably taller and wider than a standard booklet, recognizable by feel even before reading the indicia. Modern facsimiles, in the original format, which reproduce the cover but carry a barcode, a contemporary indicia and a regular white paper that no 1942 printing has. And the collected and omnibus editions, which leave no ambiguity but flood search results and bury listings of period copies.
The most reliable check remains the indicia page, then the paper. Uniformly white, smooth paper, with no cream tone and no smell of aged pulp, settles the question without debate.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
The pitfalls at purchase
The first pitfall is the listing title. Many sellers write "Wonder Woman #1" to describe the first issue of a later relaunch, since the numbering has been restarted several times over the decades. Without the Summer 1942 cover date and the period publisher mark, the listing says nothing.
The second is the partial photo. A tightly framed cover alone shows neither the spine, nor the staples, nor the edge, which means none of the places where costly defects hide. Require the full spine, the edge and at least one central interior page.
The third is incomplete pagination. On 1942 booklets, the game pages and promotional coupons were often cut out. A mutilated copy is still saleable, but at a much lower price ratio, and that information must appear in the description, not be discovered when the parcel is opened.
The neighboring issues that also matter
Immediately after, Wonder Woman #2 is dated Fall 1942 and continues the pantheon opened by the first issue. The series' following issues introduce the recurring antagonists that later adaptations would draw on: Cheetah and Doctor Psycho both appear in this first cycle of the series, at issue numbers to be checked against the catalogue before buying, since sources do not always agree on creation credits.
Outside the series, the monthly anthology magazine that had carried the heroine since early 1942 forms the other half of the collection, and its first issues are hunted with the same reflexes. If you widen the scope to the female figures of the same publisher's catalogue, the hubs for Black Canary and Zatanna provide useful publishing references.
What grading changes
On a Summer 1942 booklet, encapsulation is not primarily there to reassure about grade. It documents restoration. That is its decisive contribution, because a skillful old restoration escapes the naked eye and divides the relative value of a copy.
Beyond that, one grade step on this issue represents a price gap far larger than the same step on a 1970s booklet, simply because the curve of available copies collapses at the top of the scale. Grading a copy that is already damaged rarely makes economic sense. Grading a clean, unrestored copy almost always does, if only to be able to sell it outside your region.
A final point: the page-quality mention appears on the label and genuinely affects this type of issue. Two copies with the same grade but different page quality do not trade at the same level.
Tracking it in a collection
An issue of this caliber deserves a more detailed record than the rest of your ongoing series. Record, in addition to the series and the issue number, the seasonal cover date, the publisher mark printed, the exact nature of the copy (original printing, large-format reprint, facsimile), the verified pagination and, if the copy is graded, the certification number and the restoration note.
In My Comics Collection, this information fits in the issue's record and prevents the most frequent confusion: the one between the various "number ones" of a heroine whose numbering has been restarted several times. The same discipline applies to the other 1942 foundations you may already own, and the Wonder Woman hub lists the reference points series by series.
Also photograph the copy before it goes into a sleeve: spine, edge, staples and indicia page. These images are worth an expert opinion when you resell, and they spare you from reopening the object.
Conclusion
Wonder Woman #1, Summer 1942, is not the issue where the heroine arrives. It is the one where her origin becomes a workable story, under a publisher mark that has since disappeared and at a quarterly pace imposed by paper rationing. These three elements together explain both its scarcity and the frequency of confusion in listings.
For a collector, the right approach is patient: verify the seasonal date, require structural photos, reject facsimiles on the basis of their paper, and accept that an honest middling-grade copy is sometimes a better deal than a fine restored copy sold without disclosure. To compare the reference points of the same decade, the Superman and Batman hubs offer solid anchors.
Do you own a copy dated Summer 1942 under the All-American mark and want to know where it stands before having it graded?
Estimate my comic
Frequently asked questions
No. The heroine was already in print before the summer of 1942, in an anthology title and then in a monthly. This issue is the first of her solo series and the moment her origin is developed over several chapters. The distinction matters: the two objects are not collected at the same price level, nor with the same reference points.
Because the title was launched on a quarterly schedule, hence the Summer 1942 date. This was a consequence of wartime paper rationing, which forced publishers to space out their releases. For you, it is a quick test: a cover bearing a specific month does not match this issue.
The script is by William Moulton Marston, credited under the pseudonym Charles Moulton, and the art is by Harry G. Peter. Peter's angular and highly decorative line also serves as a mark of authenticity: it bears no resemblance to the styles of later reprints, and it quickly confirms the period of the interior pages.
By the paper and the indicia page. An original printing has cream to brown, brittle paper with a characteristic smell. A modern facsimile has regular white paper, a barcode and a contemporary indicia. The large-format reprints of the 1970s are identified even faster, by their noticeably greater dimensions.
If the copy is clean and shows no visible restoration, yes: on a 1942 booklet, the label mainly documents the absence of restoration, which is the most disputed information. If the copy is heavily damaged or visibly restored, the cost of the process is harder to justify, except to secure a remote sale.