The whole rating is based on NYX #3(cover February 2004, $2.99), script Joe Quesada, art Joshua Middleton. This number contradicts a stubborn preconceived idea:a recent comic can be authentically rare. Published in a confidential series with widely spaced releases, it was ordered in small quantities by booksellers — the exact opposite of the overproduced keys of the 1990s.
Most collectors follow a simple rule: old equals rare, recent equals abundant. This case shows why this rule is wrong, and why it is costly for those who rely on it.
Understanding the distribution mechanism of the 2000s explains most of what is happening here — and allows us to identify other comparable cases.
Why a 2004 comic can be rare
The reasoning is based on a transformation of the sales channel that few buyers have in mind.
Until the 1980s, comics were sold on newsstands, with returnable unsold items. The publisher printed widely and absorbed the risk. From the switch to specialized bookstores, the relationship reverses:the bookseller orders firmly, without possibility of return. He pays for what he orders and keeps what he doesn't sell.
The consequence is immediate. A bookseller only orders what he is sure of. On a series with a limited audience, he commands little. And the publisher prints based on those orders, not an optimistic estimate.
The title in which this character was born combined all the unfavorable factors: a narrow target audience, a format intended for an adult readership, and above all widely spaced releases. A series whose issues last for months loses its readers along the way, and booksellers adjust their orders downward with each episode.
The result is a 2004 comic whose copies in circulation are significantly fewer than those of many earlier keys from several decades. The idea clashes with common sense, and yet the market confirms it.
A character born elsewhere
Second singularity, the effects of which are felt even in the choice of the number to target.
The character was not created for the comics. It first existed in an animated series in the early 2000s, before being brought to the printed pages. His appearance in NYX is therefore not his creation, it is his entry into published continuity.
This nuance produces a situation that the market handles poorly. Part of the public met the character on screen, several years before the existence of any collectible comics. When these spectators turned to paper, they looked for a founding number which, in the strict sense, does not tell its origins.
For today's buyer, two lessons. First, don't look for an origin story in this issue: it's not there. Then know that the stories that really tell of its beginnings are elsewhere, in later series, and that they cost a fraction of the price.
What is popular, what is not
The hierarchy is clearer than on most files.
At the top,NYX #3, alone and far ahead. Its position combines first appearance status and the actual rarity described above. It is one of the rare modern keys where both factors combine.
Then, at a very lower level, the other issues of the same series. They share exactly the same conditions of circulation and distribution - therefore the same rarity - without bearing a first appearance. They are, in my opinion, the most interesting opportunity in the file: same production context, incommensurable price.
Finally come the series dedicated to the character, numerous since 2005. They have benefited from normal print runs and are easily found. Their interest is in reading, not in valuation.
A word about the variant covers modern, very abundant on this character. Some reach high levels, but it is a separate market, governed by an organized rather than an imposed scarcity. The price there depends on the rating of a designer much more than on the content of the issue - and this rating can turn around quickly.
Other keys of the same type
The mechanism described above does not concern this number alone, and knowing how to locate it is better than knowing a list.
Three signals, combined, designate a modern key likely to be truly rare. A series for restricted audiences— adult format, secondary character, unusual tone for the catalog. A erratic release schedule, which melts the orders with each episode. And one first appearance located late in the series, when the booksellers have already scaled back.
This last point is the most decisive and the least known. A first issue always benefits from orders inflated by curiosity; a third or fourth is already undergoing the downward adjustment. A key placed in the middle of a confidential series is therefore structurally rarer than the launch of the same title.
Conversely, be wary of symmetrical reasoning: a recent comic that is difficult to find in stores is not necessarily rare. Local availability says nothing about the number of copies in existence, and many titles missing from shelves circulate in abundance online.
The state of a comic from the 2000s
The criteria change completely compared to old periods, and many buyers apply them incorrectly.
Paper no longer poses a problem: it does not brown or become brittle over the course of two decades. The color of the pages, decisive on a key from the 1950s, is practically irrelevant.
What matters are the manufacturing and handling defects, because they are the only ones that distinguish otherwise identical specimens. Three points dominate.
Cover Alignment with the back. Controllable on a clear photo, and definitely uncatchable.
Staple defects: staples that are offset, pushed in too far, or have marked the paper.
Micro-wear on the corners, often due to transport in cardboard rather than reading. They are enough to lose the highest notes.
A fourth point, specific to recent comics, deserves to be noted: the traces of handling in store. These copies have been thumbed through by customers before purchase, sometimes several times, which leaves light but very real marks on the edges. A copy purchased sealed or ordered online is exempt; a copy rarely taken from the shelves.
The consequence is clear: on this number, the value is concentrated almost entirely in the top of rating scale. A merely clean copy has little to distinguish it, while a flawless copy belongs to another market.
The gradation here is justified
This is one of the rare issues where I seriously recommend thinking about it, and for specific reasons.
On old comics, certification is primarily used to eliminate the risk of restoration. On a comic from 2004, this risk is almost zero: no one restores an issue twenty years old.
What she brings here is different. As value is concentrated at the top of the scale, and as the defects that make the difference are tiny,the certified grade is the only way to prove that a copy belongs at the top of the basket. Without it, your very nice copy gets confused with the thousands of simply correct copies.
The calculation is therefore favorable in one case: you have a copy that you judge, after careful examination, likely to achieve high marks. In all others, the cost of the service will exceed the gain.
A precaution before you start: examine the centering and the staples first. They are the ones who most often block a copy that seemed promising, and you can check them for free at home.
How to estimate without making a mistake
Four stages, with a specificity specific to modern keys.
Check the number. The third in the series, not the first. Confusion is common because the reflex is to look for an inaugural number.
Identify the edition. The series has undergone reprints and reissues in collections. The cover price and the printing mentions decide.
Only compare with identical rating. On a file where the gap is played out in the last half points, mixing sales of different notes produces a meaningless average.
Favor recent transactions. Modern keys move faster than old keys: the supply can be replenished if dormant collections emerge, and demand depends on more frequent audiovisual news.
Three ways to approach the file
To decide before consulting any announcement.
Aim for the key. NYX #3 in the best accessible condition, accepting that this is a significant purchase for a comic from 2004. It is the only irreplaceable piece.
Exploit scarcity without paying for the key. Bring together other numbers from the same series: same drawing conditions, same search difficulty, unrelated prices. This is the option that I recommend to anyone starting out with this character.
Collect stories. Focus on the series devoted to him since 2005, where his true origins and his best arcs are found. Modest budget, maximum reading satisfaction.
For reading, refer to ourbest character runs; on the purchase benchmarks side,key numbers.
What we are asked about this issue
NYX #3, dated February 2004 on the cover, original price of $2.99, with Joe Quesada writing the script and Joshua Middleton drawing. This is his first appearance in comics, and one of the rare cases where key status and real rarity combine on a recent title.
Because of the sales channel. Since the transition to specialized bookstores, the bookseller orders firmly and without possibility of return: he therefore only takes what he is sure to sell. On a series with a limited audience, in an adult format and with very spaced releases, orders drop with each episode - and the publisher prints accordingly.
No, and it's a frequent disappointment. The character first existed in an animated series from the early 2000s before being imported into the comics: NYX #3 marks his entry into published continuity, not his creation. The stories that actually tell the story of its beginnings can be found in later series, at a fraction of the price.
This is one of the rare files where this is justified, but for a different reason than old comics: the risk of restoration is zero here. Since the value is concentrated at the top of the scale and the decisive defects are tiny, the certified grade is the only way to prove that an example belongs at the top of the basket. First check the centering and the staples.
Some go very high, but they belong to a separate market, governed by an organized rather than an imposed scarcity. The price depends above all on the rating of the designer, much more than on the content of the issue - and this rating can turn around quickly. Caution, therefore, for those looking for an investment that will last in the long term. There are dozens of these variants on this character, and their very abundance should raise alarms.
Not the color of the pages, which is practically irrelevant at this time scale. Three points decide: the alignment of the cover with the spine, stapling defects, and micro-wear on the corners often due to transport rather than reading. These are the only elements that distinguish otherwise identical copies.
By three cumulative signals: a series with a limited audience, an erratic publication schedule which reduces orders, and a first appearance late in the series. This last point is the most decisive: a first issue benefits from orders inflated by curiosity, a third is already undergoing the downward adjustment.
By the other numbers of the same series: same drawing conditions, same search difficulty, price without common measure. This is the most interesting opportunity in the file. The series devoted to the character since 2005 offer the other route, with a modest budget and most of the narrative material.
Follow the price of NYX #3 and your entire collection with My Comics Collection.
Discover the application