Two forces govern this coast. A author bonus : the founding number — Daredevil #168(October 7, 1980, 50¢) — is written et drawn by Frank Miller, which adds to the character's market that, independent, of collectors of a creator. And one editing question: three draws coexist, kiosk, specialized and British circuit at 15p.
Most files come down to one request: that of the character. Here, two requests overlap on the same objects, and they do not obey the same signals.
Knowing which of the two is the price of a given issue completely changes the way you buy it — and the way you resell it.
The author's bonus
This spring controls everything else, and it is rarely explained.
When a comic is written by one person and drawn by another, its demand is essentially based on its content: what character, what event, what first time. When a single person assumes both roles, one second request appears, carried by buyers who collect a designer rather than a universe.
These buyers think differently. They are not looking for first appearances but for stages of a work: the moment when a style asserts itself, where a method is put in place, where an author takes control of a title. Their logic is that of the art market more than that of the collection of booklets.
Three concrete consequences arise from this.
First, the demand is more stable: it does not depend on any adaptation or any editorial news. A recognized work remains so.
Then, it concerns numbers that the character market ignores. Booklets where the author signs alone, even without a notable event, interest this audience.
Finally, she makes the easier resale. Two distinct populations are looking for the same item, which reduces the risk of finding yourself without a buyer.
The run as a market unit
Direct consequence of the above: on this issue, the market does not think only by number but by author block.
The period in which the creator holds the title sells as an identifiable set. Sellers offer it grouped, buyers seek it grouped, and the prices of the numbers that compose it evolve in a united manner.
This produces an interesting situation for the methodical buyer. THE keyless numbers inside this block benefit from real demand, but remain very affordable compared to the identified numbers. They constitute, in my opinion, the best report in the file.
Be careful, however, of a common pitfall: lots presented as “the complete run” are not always so, and the most expensive number is almost always missing. Ask for a list of numbers, not an overview photo.
Three editions, three markets
The founding issue exists in newsstand version, in version for specialized bookstores, and in British version. For the first two, everything is at the top left corner of the cover; for the third, at the printed price.
In terms of value, remember three principles.
Never compare sales of different editions. No mistake comes up more often, nor does it cost more. An average calculated over distinct circuit examples does not describe any real object.
The hierarchy depends on the year. It is not fixed: the relative weight of the two American circuits has evolved over the decade, which makes the less common example variable depending on the period.
British publishing constitutes a separate market. It trades lower on the benchmark US market, but it has its own buyers and offers the least expensive access to this issue.
What death and return has changed
A narrative element has a direct impact on the structure of this market, and it deserves to be explained.
The character was brought to fruition by his creator, shortly after his introduction, in an identified issue. It was later brought back and then reused by other authors for decades.
For many other characters, a return devalues the conclusion: if nothing is definitive, the number which closes loses its force. Nothing of the sort happened in this specific case, and the explanation lies in the division of the market.
The audience that buys author's block isn't interested in what others wrote next. For him, the work is closed, and its conclusion retains exactly the value it had. Later publications belong to another corpus, with its own buyers and its own levels—much lower.
The lesson goes beyond this case:when a work is identified as that of an author, it becomes insensitive to subsequent rewritings. This is a factor of stability that files depending on continuity alone do not have.
The state of comics from 1980-1981
This period occupies an intermediate position that must be treated for its own sake.
The paper ages less badly than that of previous decades, but it still browns after forty years. The edge of the block, seen from the side, remains the quickest control.
What weighs more are the manufacturing defects. Quality control at the time tolerated off-centering and oblique cuts that the current market harshly punishes. These defects are original, definitive, and they cap the rating of even a perfectly preserved copy.
Two areas concentrate the usage problems. THE back pleat, where the dark areas of this cover whiten at the slightest friction. And the angles, particularly the upper right corner, which you grab to browse.
A word on gradation: it is justified here as soon as the copy appears clearly above average, because the double demand – character and author – makes a fine copy more liquid than elsewhere. Below that, the cost exceeds the benefit.
Sell on this file
The subject deserves to be treated, because the double request also changes the way of transferring a copy.
Specify the edition in the title of your ad. This is the first question any informed buyer will ask. Answering them straight away sets you apart from the mass of vague ads and attracts serious buyers, who are also those who pay the best.
Photograph the upper left corner. Place this image in a good position in the ad: it answers the editing question in advance and avoids the exchange of messages which often leads to the loss of a sale.
Name the author. An ad that only mentions the character will not be seen by half the market. Collectors who follow a creator search by name, not character — it's an indexing difference that costs you buyers if you ignore it.
Sell the block or the piece, but choose. A lot without its important numbers sells poorly and gives a bad impression; a well-described isolated piece sells quickly. The worst result comes from heterogeneous lots sold without inventory.
Also note that this file does not lend itself well to rushed sales. The buyers there are few in number but informed, and they compare. A sloppy ad remains online for a long time, whereas an accurate ad finds buyers quickly, often at a better price.
A final point on the calendar: unlike the files carried by the adaptations, this one does not experience any marked peaks. So there's no right time to wait, which makes the decision simpler — sell when it suits you.
Estimate correctly
Five steps on this file.
Identify the edition first of all, by the upper left corner and the printed price.
Date by the cover price. Fifty cents for the two American versions. A different amount indicates a reprint, collection or foreign edition, and the check takes a second on a clear photo.
Check the exact number. The character appears in many neighboring fascicles; only the first carries the starting bonus.
Distinguish between original defects and use defects. The former are definitely plateauing, the latter are being negotiated.
Compare to identical edition and rating, and only on concluded sales.
Ask yourself who is buying. Step specific to this file: if the price observed seems high to you for an issue without a narrative event, it is probably the author's demand which carries it. This doesn't mean it's overrated — it means you should compare it to other issues by the same author, not other issues of the same character.
One final observation on liquidity. This file sells better than average, precisely because two distinct audiences are interested in it. A seller who fails to interest collectors of the character may affect those of the author, and vice versa. This double release reduces the risk of being left with a copy on your hands, which matters as much as the price level when you commit a significant sum.
Three ways to approach the file
Decide before looking.
The key alone. The founding issue, in the edition and condition that fits your budget. Simple and readable objective.
Author's block. The entire period where the creator holds the title. This is the most consistent approach, the one valued by the market, and it exploits the modest price of keyless numbers.
The later corpus. The series devoted to the character after this period, very accessible, for those who want to read a lot without committing a large sum.
The details of the founding number appear in ourdedicated article; reading side, see ourrecommended runs.
Your questions about the rating
Daredevil #168, his first appearance, went on sale October 7, 1980 for 50 cents. Its value is based on two superimposed demands: that of the character, and that of the collectors who follow Frank Miller, who here alone provides the text and the image.
The extra value that comes when just one person writes and draws. Added to the character market is that of buyers who collect a creator: they are not looking for first appearances but for stages of a work. This demand is more stable, does not depend on any adaptation, and concerns numbers that the character market ignores.
This is the best report on the file. Inside the block held by the author, the booklets without narrative events benefit from a real demand while remaining very affordable. Just be wary of lots sold as “complete runs”: the most expensive number is almost always missing. Ask for a list of numbers, not an overview photo.
No, and it's instructive. The public who buys the author's block is not interested in what others wrote next: for them the work is closed, and its conclusion retains its value. When a work is identified as that of an author, it becomes insensitive to subsequent rewritings — a factor of stability that files depending on continuity alone do not have.
More than average, and that's one of its strengths. Two distinct audiences are interested in it: that of the character and that of the author. A seller who does not interest the former can affect the latter, and vice versa. This double release reduces the risk of being left with a copy on your hands - which matters as much as the price level when you commit a large sum.
Ask yourself who is buying. If the amount seems high to you for an issue without a narrative event, it is probably the author's request that carries it. This does not mean that it is overrated: it means that it should be compared to other issues by the same author, and not to other issues of the same character.
Specify the edition from the title: this is the first question of any informed buyer, and answering it straight away attracts those who pay the best. Also name the author — collectors who follow a creator search by the name, not the character, and an ad that omits it remains invisible to half the market. Finally, avoid heterogeneous batches without inventory.
As soon as the copy appears clearly above average, yes: the double demand makes a good copy easier to resell than an ordinary file. Below that, the cost exceeds the benefit. First check the centering and the cut, original defects that nothing corrects and which limit the score whatever the state of conservation.
Follow the price of your Elektra comics and your entire collection with My Comics Collection.
Discover the application