The three essential Captain America runs: Ed Brubaker (2004-2012) for the spy thriller and the return of Bucky, Jack Kirby (1976-1977) for the creative madness of the King, and Steve Englehart (1972-1975) for the post-Watergate political deconstruction.
Captain America is much more than a patriot in a costume: he is the moral mirror of America, and his best writers have used the character to question national values in every era. From World War II to the War on Terror, Steve Rogers embodies the heroic ideal confronted with reality.
The Captain America market offers a wide range, from premium priced Silver Age keys to still affordable modern Brubaker keys. This ranking identifies the runs that define the character and present the best potential for a coherent and valuable collection over the long term.
Top 1 — Ed Brubaker (Captain America vol. 5 #1-50 + vol. 6 #1-19 + vol. 1 #600-619, 2004-2012)
Screenwriter:Ed Brubaker |Designers:Steve Epting, Mike Perkins, Butch Guice
Brubaker accomplished the impossible: bringing Bucky back from the dead in a believable way. “The Winter Soldier” is a gripping spy thriller that redefined the superhero genre. The death of Steve Rogers and the succession by Bucky continue the saga brilliantly. Eight years of storytelling at its peak — the definitive Captain America run of the modern era.
Key numbers:#1 (Winter Soldier saga beginning), #6 (Bucky revelation), #25 (Cap's death).Current rating:#1 in NM: €40-70, #6: €25-40, #25: €30-50.
Top 2 — Jack Kirby (Captain America #193-214 + Annual, 1976-1977)
Writer/Draughtsman:Jack Kirby
The co-creator’s feedback on his creation. Kirby ignores continuity and rushes in a cosmic, paranoid direction — the Bicentennial Battles, the Madbomb, Arnim Zola redesigned. It's pure, unfiltered Kirby: ideas by the second, unparalleled graphic dynamism, raw creative energy. Essential for lovers of the King.
Key numbers:#193 (Kirby return), #208-212 (Arnim Zola).Current rating:#193 in NM: €40-60, Annual #3: €20-30.
Top 3 — Steve Englehart (Captain America #153-186, 1972-1975)
Screenwriter:Steve Englehart |Designers:Sal Buscema, Frank Robbins
Cap's most political run. Englehart confronts Steve Rogers about (thinly veiled) Watergate — “Secret Empire” culminates in a corrupt president committing suicide in the Oval Office. Cap gives up the costume and becomes Nomad. Committed comics, daring for the time, which still resonate fifty years later. An unmissable milestone.
Key numbers:#175-176 (Secret Empire climax), #180 (Nomad).Current rating:#176 in VF: €40-70, #180 in NM: €50-80.
Top 4 — Roger Stern & John Byrne (Captain America #247-255, 1980)
Screenwriter:Roger Stern |Designer:John Byrne
Nine masterful numbers. Byrne at the top of his form draws an athletic and dynamic Cap, while Stern writes a tight plot - Cap refuses the presidency, faces Baron Blood and Mister Hyde. Conciseness itself: not a superfluous panel, each page is a model of comic craftsmanship. Highly sought after by Byrne collectors.
Key numbers:#247 (start of run), #253-254 (Baron Blood).Current rating:#247 in NM: €25-45, #253 in NM: €20-30.
Top 5 — Mark Gruenwald (Captain America #307-443, 1985-1995)
Screenwriter:Mark Gruenwald |Designers:Paul Neary, Kieron Dwyer, Ron Lim
Ten years of absolute devotion to the character. Gruenwald is the guardian of the temple Cap: "The Captain" (Steve Rogers replaced by John Walker), "Streets of Poison", and dozens of solid arcs that maintain a remarkable level over an entire decade. A marathon run, the longest in the history of the title.
Key numbers:#332 (Steve Rogers loses the suit), #350 (return), #443 (last Gruenwald).Current rating:#332 in NM: €20-35, #323 (1st Super-Patriot): €15-25.
Top 6 — Stan Lee & Jack Kirby (Tales of Suspense #59-99, 1964-1968)
Screenwriter:Stan Lee |Designer:Jack Kirby
The origin of modern Captain America. Lee and Kirby bring Steve Rogers back from the ice and build his Marvel mythology: redesigned Red Skull, Batroc, MODOK, Agents of SHIELD. Half-size historical Kirby pages that burst with energy. Expensive in high condition but fundamental to understanding the character.
Key numbers:Tales of Suspense #59 (early Cap feature), #63 (origin retold).Current rating:#59 in VG: €100-200, #63 in VF: €150-250.
Top 7 — Nick Spencer (Captain America: Sam Wilson + Steve Rogers, 2015-2017)
Screenwriter:Nick Spencer |Designers:Daniel Acuna, Jesus Saiz
Controversial but striking: Spencer splits Captain America (Sam Wilson and Steve Rogers) then drops the bomb "Hail Hydra" which shook the industry. Secret Empire, despite the controversy, is a narratively ambitious event about the corruption of symbols. A run that will be re-evaluated with historical hindsight.
Key numbers:Steve Rogers: Captain America #1 (Hail Hydra), Sam Wilson #1.Current rating:Steve Rogers #1 in NM: €10-18.
Track your progress on each Captain America run with ourcollection management application. From Brubaker to Kirby, identify the issues missing from your collection.