Tales to Astonish #27: Henry Pym's First Appearance Collector's Guide, article illustration

Henry Pym's first appearance is in Tales to Astonish #27, dated January 1962, in a short story titled "The Man in the Ant Hill", scripted by Larry Lieber from a plot by Stan Lee, drawn by Jack Kirby and inked by Dick Ayers. Pym is a scientist who tests a shrinking formula on himself and finds himself trapped in an ant hill. No costume, no hero name: that gap is what makes the issue interesting.

Many collectors arrive at this issue through the Avengers door, and leave disappointed not to find a mask, a helmet or a tamed ant. Yet that is where the issue's value lies: Tales to Astonish #27 is the first appearance of a character without the first appearance of a hero, a rare configuration that splits demand between two distinct issues, at two different price levels. Knowing which one you are buying, and why, is worth several grade points.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is ours, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

Profile of Tales to Astonish #27: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

The issue: January 1962, thirteen pages and a scientist in a hurry

Tales to Astonish #27 carries the cover date January 1962. Like all the issues of the period, this date is a newsstand withdrawal date, not a release date: the copy reached newsdealers in the fall of 1961. This nuance matters when you date a lot, and even more when a seller advertises "a 1962 comic" for an object printed the year before.

The story that concerns us, "The Man in the Ant Hill", takes up only part of the table of contents. The rest of the issue is made up of other short stories, following the anthology model. Stan Lee is credited with the initial plot, Larry Lieber writes the script, Jack Kirby pencils and Dick Ayers inks. This division of labor is that of a well-oiled production line: Lieber wrote many of these twist-ending stories for the anthology titles, and Kirby turned them out with the speed of an artist drawing several series in parallel.

The content itself is proudly simple. A biochemist develops a substance able to shrink matter, takes a dose himself, and discovers that a garden plot becomes a jungle when you measure a few millimeters. The ants are not allies but a threat. He gets out, returns to normal size, and concludes the invention is too dangerous to exist. End of story, end of the character, or so its creators believed.

What Tales to Astonish was publishing at that date

At number 27, Tales to Astonish is not a superhero title: it is an anthology of science fiction and giant monsters, a direct heir to the Atlas catalog of the 1950s. You find creatures with unpronounceable names, flying saucers, scientists punished by their own curiosity. This format then occupied several of the publisher's titles at once, and it served as a laboratory: dozens of ideas were tested over twelve or thirteen pages, with no commitment.

Place the date in the house chronology. Fantastic Four #1 is from November 1961, so it immediately precedes it. The anthologies did not stop for all that: they kept running while the costumed series were launching, and it was inside these anthologies that several heroes appeared, by grafting rather than by launch. Pym is the clearest example, because his graft took place eight issues later, in his own original title.

This pivot position explains the dual nature of issue 27 on the market. It belongs to the end of the so-called pre-hero period, which some collectors hunt for its own sake, and it also belongs to the Avengers genealogy. Two audiences, two motivations, one print run.

Why this issue became a key, and which key it is

The key status is not obvious in hindsight. For a long time, the story of the scientist and the ant hill was just one twist-ending tale among hundreds. What transformed it was the editorial decision to bring the character back, and then the fact that this character co-founded the team that now carries the franchise.

Hence the exact formulation to remember, the one that will keep you from paying for one issue when you want another: Tales to Astonish #27 is the first appearance of Henry Pym, as a civilian, with no costumed identity. Tales to Astonish #35, dated September 1962, is Pym's first appearance as Ant-Man, with helmet and costume. Both are keys. They do not substitute for each other, and they are not priced the same way.

On the market, the hierarchy between the two has shifted over time and between audiences. Buyers who think in terms of the "character's first appearance" push issue 27; those who think in terms of the "hero's first appearance" push issue 35. You will come across listings that deliberately blur the distinction, illustrating a lot of issue 27 with a picture of the costume. Read the issue number printed on the cover, not the text of the listing.

What moves the price: condition, page color, provenance

On a 1962 issue, the price gap between two copies of the same issue is played out almost entirely on preservation. Three defects dominate this generation: rusted staples, which stain the central signatures from the inside out; corners rounded by handling at the newsstand; and yellowing paper, which is not a mechanical defect but weighs on the overall assessment.

Page color has become an explicit criterion. At the same grade, a copy with bright pages sells clearly above one with browned pages, and the gap widens as you move up the top grades. For an issue like 27, where high-quality copies are scarce, this detail moves bids more reliably than half a grade point does.

Provenance also plays a role, through an indirect mechanism: lots from known collections, kept from the start in stable conditions, offer lighter pages and therefore attract a premium. You are not paying for the name; you are paying for the probability of good paper.

Telling one edition from another

The issue had only one original American print run, in the single-issue format, with a cover price of twelve cents. Any copy whose printed price differs must be examined closely, and two legitimate cases exist.

The first is the price variant made for the British market, where a sum in pence replaces or overprints the American price. These copies have their own market and should not be confused with the standard print run; on an issue from this period, check whether the price is printed into the plate or applied by stamp, since both methods were used depending on the year and the distributor. When in doubt, the note to enter in your record is "to be verified on the copy," not an assumption.

The second is the reprint. The story has been reused in collections and in reprint volumes devoted to the early years of Ant-Man and Giant-Man. These objects have their use, which is to read without handling a fragile issue, but they do not carry number 27 or the 1962 date on their covers, and none should be placed in your collection in the original's stead. If a facsimile edition circulates, it normally carries a publisher's notice and a modern date on the back: that is where to look, not on the front.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Tales to Astonish #27: the sections of this guide, in reading order

Purchase traps on this particular issue

The main trap is semantic, and it is specific to this issue: the blurring between Pym's first appearance and the first appearance of Ant-Man. A listing that reads "1st Ant-Man" for a copy of issue 27 is wrong, whether through ignorance or intent. The costume does not yet exist in these pages.

The second trap is undisclosed restoration. On issues from the early 1960s, the usual interventions are filling in missing areas on the back cover, cleaning the paper and replacing staples. None of this is illegitimate, but all of it must be disclosed. A cover whose white looks too even for its age deserves a direct question to the seller, in writing.

The third trap is the central signature. On an anthology issue, the pages in the middle often belong to a different story from the one you are buying, which does not prevent some copies from having lost a double page. Ask for a photo of the open center, not just the cover. An incomplete copy resells poorly, even if it is well graded on the rest.

The neighboring issues that also matter

Around issue 27, the series offers a sequence of milestones that you can treat as a coherent set. Tales to Astonish #35, September 1962, puts Pym in costume and turns the anthology into a hero series. Tales to Astonish #44, dated June 1963, introduces Janet van Dyne and the Wasp, the other half of the duo; it is an issue that buyers of issue 27 often add in the same session, and the Wasp hub covers it in detail. Tales to Astonish #49, November 1963, marks Pym's switch to the Giant-Man identity, and so the first transformation of a character who would go through many.

Outside the series, Avengers #1, September 1963, counts in the same collecting logic, since Pym is among its founding members. The Avengers hub places this arrival in publication order.

Finally, the title's later fate interests those who want a complete series rather than an isolated key: Tales to Astonish hosted Hulk and then Sub-Mariner in its second half, in a shared format, before its numbering was taken over by the series devoted to the green giant. Fans of this period will find their way through the Hulk hub.

What grading changes on a 1962 issue

For an issue of this age, going through an independent grading service changes the price less than it changes liquidity. A sealed, graded copy sells faster, to a wider audience, and above all it sells at a distance without any negotiation over condition. On an issue where the gap between two neighboring grades can be a multiple of the price, that certainty has measurable value.

Grading also serves as a referee on two points that are hard to judge from photos: page color, which is recorded explicitly, and restoration, which is flagged with a separate qualifier. An ungraded, unrestored copy remains a very good purchase if you know how to examine it; an ungraded copy sold with low-resolution photos is a gamble.

The reverse calculation also exists. Grading a copy of average grade costs a fixed amount that weighs heavily against its value, and the gain in liquidity does not always compensate. Reserve the process for copies you estimate to be in the upper part of the range, or for those you intend to resell later.

How to track it in a collection

This issue is a textbook case for the rigor of data entry, because its interest lies in a distinction your record must carry. In My Comics Collection, enter it under its exact series title, Tales to Astonish, with issue number 27 and the year 1962, and record the nature of the appearance in the note: first appearance of Henry Pym, without costume. Without that mention, you will reread your own record in two years believing you hold the first Ant-Man.

If you are aiming for the full sequence, create a watch list that brings together issues 27, 35, 44 and 49 of the series. You will see at once which ones you have, at what grade, and where the gap is. It is also the best way to avoid the opportunity duplicate, the one you buy because the listing was attractive and you had forgotten you already owned the copy.

Finally, remember to record the grade and the page color if you know them, even approximately. On an issue whose price is as sensitive to condition, a documented collection is worth more than one that is merely inventoried, and the Ant-Man hub will give you the rest of the issues to watch.

Conclusion

Tales to Astonish #27 does not look like a key when you hold it: an anthology cover, a creature, a twist-ending story title. That is precisely why it still trades with wide gaps from one sale to the next, and why it stays within reach of collectors who would balk at the most famous first appearances of 1962. On the condition that you know what you are buying: a scientist in a lab coat, not a hero in a helmet, and a story whose sequel was written only eight issues later.

Your copy of Tales to Astonish #27 deserves an estimate that distinguishes Pym's first appearance from that of Ant-Man, because the two issues are not worth the same.

Estimate my comic
Tales to Astonish #27: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

No. It is the first appearance of Henry Pym, a scientist with no costumed identity, in the story "The Man in the Ant Hill" from January 1962. The character returns as Ant-Man, with helmet and costume, in Tales to Astonish #35 dated September 1962. Both issues are keys, at distinct price levels, and listings often confuse them.

Stan Lee is credited with the initial plot, Larry Lieber wrote the script, Jack Kirby handled the pencils and Dick Ayers the inks. This team matched the production system of the publisher's anthologies at that date, where short stories were entrusted to fast, well-practiced pairings rather than to a dedicated series.

Because the date printed on the issues of the period was a withdrawal date from points of sale, not a release date. The copy therefore circulated at newsstands in the fall of 1961. This convention applies to all American production of the period and explains the discrepancies you will see between catalogs.

A reprint does not carry number 27 or the 1962 date on its cover: it appears under the title of a collection or a reprint volume. Always check the legal notices on the inside front cover, which give the publisher and the real year of printing. On a possible facsimile, that page is the only reliable place to look.

It depends on what you collect. If you follow the characters, issue 27 comes first since it holds Pym's birth. If you follow the costumed identities, issue 35 is your target. Collectors of the series take both, often adding issue 44 for the Wasp and issue 49 for Giant-Man.