Tales of Suspense #57: Hawkeye's First Appearance Collector's Guide, article illustration

Hawkeye first appears in Tales of Suspense #57, dated September 1964, in a story written by Stan Lee and drawn by Don Heck. Clint Barton starts out on the wrong side there: a carnival archer turned improvised vigilante, he is mistaken for a thief, then turned against Iron Man by the Black Widow. Collectors seek this issue because it contains the complete birth of the character, original costume included.

This issue occupies an awkward place on purchase lists: it is expensive for a single installment of a regular series, yet less famous than the great first appearances of 1962 and 1963. As a result, its price moves in fits and starts, often in step with screen releases rather than with underlying demand. Knowing exactly what you are buying, and in what condition, changes the price you pay here more than on many other keys of the same decade.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is ours, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

Profile of Tales of Suspense #57: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

What Tales of Suspense #57 contains

The cover is dated September 1964. The story that interests collectors is titled "Hawkeye, the Marksman!", written by Stan Lee and drawn by Don Heck. Clint Barton is presented there as a showman sharpshooter, admiring of the heroes he sees at work, who builds himself a kit of trick arrows and decides to use it in public. A misunderstanding makes him pass for the thief he was chasing, so his career begins under an accusation.

The second half of the story introduces the element that will shape the character for years: his encounter with the Soviet spy who had appeared a few issues earlier in the same title. She steers him, recruits him and sends him against the man in armor. Hawkeye is therefore not a hero just starting out, but an opponent under influence, and that ambiguity is exactly what readers of 1964 discover when they open the issue.

One last point, often underestimated: the costume in this first story is not the one the general public associates with the character. Full mask, dominant purple and blue, the silhouette of a carnival performer more than an Avenger. The outfit shown on toys and posters comes later. A buyer looking for "the cover with Hawkeye as we know him" will not find it in this issue, and several listings play on that confusion.

The editorial context of the series in 1964

At this date, the title was not yet the shared magazine it would become: the editorial change happens two issues later, when Captain America takes over the second half of each issue starting with number 59. Tales of Suspense #57 therefore belongs to the last handful of issues where the series still works under its earlier formula, which also explains the length of Hawkeye's introductory story, more generous than the installments of 1965.

This pivotal position has a practical consequence. Collectors building a complete run often stop at the 55 to 60 stretch, because it concentrates both this first appearance and the title's shift. Demand for issue 57 is therefore driven by two different audiences, first-appearance hunters and series completists, and that is one reason average copies sell faster than one would expect.

The character, for his part, does not remain a supporting player in a single title for long. He joins the team in Avengers #16, dated May 1965, alongside Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch, in the reshuffled lineup that follows the founders. Less than a year separates the adversary of one issue from the archer who holds a place on the team, and this quick attachment is what made Tales of Suspense #57 a key rather than a curiosity.

Why this issue became a sought-after key

Three forces combined. First, lasting membership: since 1965, the character has never really left the team's roster, as a member, a resigning member, the leader of a breakaway lineup or a mentor. A first appearance gains value when what follows proves it right, and forty years of continuous presence have proved this one right.

Then came screen adaptations. The archer's face appears briefly in the 2011 Thor film, then as a full member in the 2012 team film, with Jeremy Renner in the role. Each announcement and each release produced a visible push in auction results for the issue, following a pattern found on many first appearances carried by the screen.

Finally, the 2021 television series had a more particular effect: by staging the handing down of the name to a second bearer, it lifted not only Tales of Suspense #57 but also the first appearance of that successor, published in 2005 in Young Avengers #1. Two keys from very different eras therefore moved together, which is rare and worth knowing when you are weighing one against the other.

What moves the price from one copy to another

On a 1964 issue, the gap between a read copy and a preserved one is measured not in percentages but in multiples. The top grades are thinly populated for this issue, and relative scarcity produces sharp jumps there: a single grade point gained at the top of the scale can be worth more than the difference between two average copies. Conversely, in the lower half of the scale the curve is flat, and a grade point hardly gets negotiated.

The defects that weigh most are those of the stapled spine and the right edge of the cover. Marvel's paper of those years yellows unevenly depending on storage, and the whiteness of the interior pages has become a pricing criterion in its own right: two copies graded at the same level can sell very differently depending on whether the pages are cream or clearly browned.

A last factor is the original market. American newsstand copies remain the reference, but this issue also circulated through secondary distribution channels, with covers sometimes stamped or overprinted by the dealer. Those copies exist and are collected, but they cannot be compared directly with the first ones as far as price is concerned.

Telling one edition from another

There is no cover variant for this issue in the modern sense: in 1964, the print run was unique. Confusion therefore comes from elsewhere, mainly from later reprints of the story. The introduction of Hawkeye has been reprinted in collections, then in the hardcover volumes and trade paperback omnibuses the publisher has issued since the 1990s. These volumes contain the same story and have no value relationship with the original issue.

The most concrete point to watch concerns possible facsimiles. The publisher regularly produces them for its classics, with a cover that is almost identical to the original. If a facsimile of this issue circulates, it carries a barcode or a block of contemporary legal information, often on the back, and paper that is distinctly whiter and thicker. Always check the back and the inside back cover before concluding, and ask for a photo of the interior legal-notice page.

A third case is foreign editions. The story has been translated in many countries, often with completely different pagination and cover, sometimes years after 1964. A French or Italian publication containing the first appearance is not "a Tales of Suspense #57": it is a local first publication, with its own, much narrower market.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Tales of Suspense #57: the sections of this guide, in reading order

Purchase traps

The most common trap is the listing that mentions the first appearance without specifying that it is a reprint or a collection. Read the lot title to the end, and require a photo of the issue flat, back included. A seller who shows only a cropped cover almost always hides something, usually a detached spine or a replaced staple.

Second trap, undisclosed restoration. On issues from this decade, filling in missing areas, reinforcing the spine and chemical cleaning are common, and they downgrade the copy once detected. A restored copy is not a bad purchase in itself, provided its price reflects the restoration and not the apparent condition.

Third trap, more insidious: the neighboring issue sold at the price of the key. The covers of the series look very alike in this period, and the number is small. Check the number on the cover and, if possible, on the first interior page. Before committing to a high-end copy, a prior estimate keeps you from pricing one grade tier using the price of the neighboring tier.

The neighboring issues that also matter

The first to know is Tales of Suspense #52, which contains the first appearance of the Black Widow, the one who manipulates the archer in issue 57. The two issues go together commercially: they cite each other in listings, and a buyer chasing one often ends up taking the other in the same month.

Next comes issue 59, which opens the second half of the magazine to Captain America and has become a series key in its own right. And of course Avengers #16, which marks entry into the team. This last issue remains much more accessible than the first appearance, which makes it a reasonable entry point for anyone who wants a significant issue of the character without aiming for the summit.

For collections oriented toward the team rather than the character, the 1965 and 1966 issues of Avengers form a coherent set in which the archer holds a central role, often in conflict with the rest of the group. They can still be found in decent condition, and they document the character better than isolated issues bought at random.

What grading changes for this specific issue

Having a 1964 copy graded only makes economic sense above a certain condition level. Below it, the cost and the delay outweigh the gain, and a raw copy that is well photographed sells quite well among informed collectors. Above that level, the reverse holds: certification opens access to specialist auctions, where the reference prices for the issue are formed.

Grading also serves as proof on two points that are hard to establish from photographs: restoration, and the possible absence of a missing insert. On issues from this period, a central advertising page is sometimes torn out, and this defect escapes a quick visual check. An independent opinion settles the doubt, which matters if you are considering reselling.

Finally, remember that grading freezes a judgment at a given date. For this issue, the color of the paper keeps changing after encapsulation, and the market increasingly values page-quality notations. Two copies certified fifteen years ago at the same level do not look the same today.

How to track it in a collection

An issue of this importance deserves a detailed entry rather than a single line. Record the exact edition, the cover month, the declared condition, the provenance, and the fact that it is the original issue and not a reprint. That last piece of information is the one most often missing from older inventories, and it is what costs time at the moment of a sale or an insurance claim.

Also link the entry to the issues that accompany it: the spy's first appearance, issue 59, Avengers #16. The catalog lets you build these sets and see at a glance what a sub-collection is missing. A collection documented this way is worth more, with the same contents, than a pile without history.

For value tracking, bear in mind that this issue's price is jumpy: it reacts quickly to screen announcements and then partly falls back. Checking an estimate once a year is enough for the lower tiers; for a high-end copy, a half-yearly check is more prudent, keeping in mind that recent public sales weigh more than printed price guides.

What to keep in mind before buying

Tales of Suspense #57 is a solid key for a simple reason: the character introduced in September 1964 joined the team eight months later and never really left it. But it is a demanding key, because the story has been reprinted many times, because the original costume does not resemble the one the occasional buyer has in mind, and because condition gaps are paid for dearly at the top of the scale.

The right approach is therefore to set first the condition tier you are aiming for, then to compare only copies from that tier, photographed back included. If you are building a set around the team, place this issue alongside its key roster issues rather than buying it in isolation: it makes full sense only within that series.

Do you own a Tales of Suspense #57, a neighboring 1964 issue or an Avengers #16 and want to know where it stands today?

Estimate my comic
Tales of Suspense #57: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

No. Clint Barton starts out there as an opponent: mistaken for a thief after his first public intervention, he is then steered against the man in armor by the Black Widow. His move to the heroes' side happens over the following months, and he becomes a team member in Avengers #16, dated May 1965.

No, and this is a frequent source of error in listings. The September 1964 outfit has a full mask and the silhouette of a stage performer. The familiar costume, associated with the team, appears later. If a listing shows the archer in his modern look, it does not concern this issue.

The story "Hawkeye, the Marksman!" is written by Stan Lee and drawn by Don Heck. In period credit listings, the lettering and inking credits are sometimes incomplete or differ from one source to another; for writing and art, however, the attribution is stable and consistently repeated.

It is a coherent solution. Avengers #16 marks entry into the team in May 1965, remains clearly more accessible and is easier to find in good condition. It does not replace the first appearance in terms of price, but it tells the decisive step in the character's story and usefully complements a team-oriented collection.

Because it stages the handing down of the name. Demand went both to the 1964 first appearance and to that of the title's second bearer, published in Young Avengers #1 in 2005. This double effect is unusual, and it explains part of the price volatility since that period.