Something Is Killing the Children #1: First Printing Guide, article illustration

Something is Killing the Children #1 is the first issue of the series created by James Tynion IV and Werther Dell'Edera at BOOM! Studios, cover-dated October 2019, colored by Miquel Muerto and lettered by AndWorld Design. It follows the disappearance of children in Archer's Peak, Wisconsin, the only teenage survivor, and the arrival of a bandana-masked monster hunter, Erica Slaughter. Collectors look for it because its first printing was run well below the demand that appeared afterwards.

If you want to understand, in a single object, how the value of a modern single issue is built, take this one. Nothing in its release listing singled it out: a mid-sized publisher, a writer still far from his current fame, an Italian artist little known to the French public, and a title brutal enough that several bookshops ordered it reluctantly. Six weeks later, the same bookshops had no copy left to sell, and first-printing copies were already changing hands at several times their cover price. That gap between what was printed and what was demanded is the only thing that matters in this file, and it is also what makes it a textbook case.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact. The analysis is our own, with no reproduction of any panel or protected dialogue.

Profile of Something is Killing the Children #1: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

The issue: October 2019, Archer's Peak, Erica Slaughter

The issue carries the October 2019 date in its indicia, following the American practice of placing the cover date a few weeks after the actual on-sale date. The script is by James Tynion IV, the art by Werther Dell'Edera, the colours by Miquel Muerto, the lettering by AndWorld Design. The main cover is by Dell'Edera himself, in the same dark, grainy palette as the interior pages, which is uncommon: many horror titles hand the cover to an outside illustrator to catch the eye on the rack.

The story opens on a group of teenagers in the woods around Archer's Peak, a small town in Wisconsin. Only one of them comes back, James, and nobody believes what he says. The town has already lost several children, the police are floundering, and the parents blame one another. Then a young woman armed and with her face half hidden by a bandana arrives and asks James the one question the adults have not thought to ask: what he saw. Erica Slaughter is introduced in this issue, and it is her first appearance.

This first issue explains almost nothing. We do not know who Erica works for, where her tools come from, or why only children can see the creatures. The organisation that employs her and its hierarchy are only detailed in the later arcs. This withholding of information is precisely what led the first readers to talk about it, and word of mouth is the engine of the whole affair.

The editorial context: what BOOM! Studios was publishing then

In 2019, BOOM! Studios was no longer a small publisher, but it did not carry the weight of the two major houses on bookshop orders. Its catalogue was split between children's licences, creator-driven series and a few genre titles. In that landscape, a new horror series by a writer mainly known for superhero stories did not trigger a buying reflex among retailers.

The American distribution chain then worked on firm, non-returnable orders: the bookseller committed weeks before release, from a pre-order catalogue, and could not restock if the print run sold out. This mechanism is the mechanical cause of what happened. The initial orders were calibrated on what booksellers knew of the writer and the publisher, not on what the issue was going to trigger among readers.

The title itself played a part: a family-run shop hesitates to put in its window an issue announcing that something is killing the children, and several retailers ordered low for that reason alone.

Why this issue became a key

The sequence is documented and comes in three stages. First, a modest first printing, sold out quickly. Then a demand that grew through word of mouth, social networks and in-store recommendations, not through an advertising campaign. Finally, an editorial response in the form of a series of reprints, each with a different cover, intended to satisfy readers who had arrived late.

It is this cascade of reprints that makes this issue such a readable case. On a classic title, one argues about the importance of a character, his future, his place in continuity. Here, the signal is purely arithmetical: the scarcity of the first printing is attested by the number of times the publisher had to print again. The market did not have to interpret anything, it counted.

Add to this the trajectory of the writer. Between 2019 and the years that followed, James Tynion IV moved from the status of a respected author to that of a name that sells, and several of his creator-owned series followed the same path. A launch bought in 2019 for the pleasure of reading it found itself, three years later, among the sought-after first issues of a creator. Erica Slaughter, for her part, gained a spin-off series, House of Slaughter, launched in 2021, which extended interest in the character and therefore in this original issue.

What moves the price: condition, printing, cover

On this specific issue, the printing outweighs everything else. A first printing in average condition trades above a flawless reprint, and the gap is not marginal: it is counted in multiples, not in percentages. This is the opposite of what one observes with a comic from the sixties, where condition governs and the edition is rarely ambiguous.

Next comes the cover. The first printing came, besides Dell'Edera's main cover, with alternative covers, some of them in limited distribution. Not all of them are equal, and the ranking among them shifts with demand for a given illustrator. Before buying an alternative at the price of a rare piece, check in the catalogue which edition it belongs to: a reprint alternative also exists, and it does not have the same value as a first-printing alternative.

Condition, finally, plays its usual role but on a particular basis. A 2019 issue has no excuse: it has not lived fifty years on a newsstand. The market therefore expects a copy close to mint, and punishes handling defects severely. A spine crease, a soft corner, an off-centre staple from the factory is enough to drop a copy from the top of the scale to the middle, with a loss of value unrelated to the visual seriousness of the flaw.

Telling a first printing from a reprint

This is the technical point that decides the value of your purchase, and it takes thirty seconds to settle if you know where to look.

The most reliable marker is the indicia, the small block of legal notices printed at the bottom of one of the first pages or on the last page. A reprint carries an explicit printing mention there, such as "second printing" or "third printing", and a later print date. A first printing carries no printing mention: the absence of that mention is the positive sign, and it is the only check that counts as proof. Do not rely on the look of the paper or the vividness of the colours, which vary from batch to batch without saying anything about the printing.

The second marker is the cover. Reprints were distributed with different illustrations, sometimes in brighter tones than the original cover, and some carry a banner. Learning to recognise the first-printing main cover saves you time on a listing photo, but it does not spare you from asking for a readable picture of the indicia. A well-meaning seller who inherited a lot often does not know what they are selling themselves.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Something Is Killing the Children #1: the sections of this guide, in reading order

The traps when buying

The first trap is the cover photo alone. Because a reprint's cover differs from that of the first printing, a listing that shows only the front can be perfectly honest and still mislead you if you confuse two similar illustrations. Always ask for the inside cover.

The second trap is the lot. "Complete first arc" bundles circulate in which the first issue is a reprint and the following ones are first printings. The seller announces a consistent overall price for the set, but you are paying for issue one as if it were rare when it is not. Always break the lot down before accepting it.

The third trap is more insidious: the signed copy. A convention signature, even a genuine one, does not mechanically add value to a recent issue, especially when it is written in marker on a dark cover. Worse, it can close the door to a standard grading. If you are buying to keep, a blank copy is often the better choice.

The neighbouring issues that also matter

The rest of the first arc, published straight after, was printed in quantities that demand quickly caught up with, which gives several of these issues a first printing that is also sought after, but at a much lower level. The phenomenon fades quickly: after the first episodes, the publisher adjusted its print runs and the following issues are no longer scarce.

On the spin-off side, House of Slaughter #1, published in 2021, deserves a place in a collection built around Erica Slaughter, all the more so as its launch benefited from a very large number of alternative covers. Be careful: an abundance of covers here means an abundance of copies, and most of these alternatives are not rare pieces despite their presentation.

If you collect by independent-launch logic rather than by character, the natural comparison is with other first issues from publishers outside the two majors, several of which we detail in our files on Spawn and Watchmen, two opposite trajectories of value outside the conventional market.

What grading changes

On a 2019 issue, grading has a particular function: it does not primarily serve to certify a condition, it serves to lock down an edition. A sealed copy states the printing rank on its label, which permanently removes the ambiguity that accounts for most of the buying risk on this issue. That is its real contribution here.

On condition itself, the scale is merciless with modern books. The highest grades are common on a recent title, so the market expects them, and the difference in value between the top grade and the one just below remains significant even though the eye sees nothing. Having a copy graded that you consider perfect is a gamble: the result may confirm your estimate or collapse it.

How to track it in a collection

This issue shows why a modern collection inventory has to go further down than the "series, issue number" line. Two copies both labelled "Something is Killing the Children #1" can belong to unrelated value categories. For each copy, therefore, record the printing rank read from the indicia and the identification of the cover, not just the title and year.

Also note the provenance and the acquisition date. On a title whose price was built in a few weeks, knowing when and where you bought tells you whether you hold a 2019 copy from the shelf or one bought back on the secondary market, useful information on the day you want to sell or insure the whole collection.

Finally, if your collection mixes older issues with recent launches, keep them apart in your value tracking. A sixties issue moves slowly and according to its condition; this one moves according to its edition and the news about its creators. Lumping them together in the same average teaches you nothing about either. Our collecting guides detail this separation of methods.

Conclusion: the lesson of issue one

Something is Killing the Children #1 did not become a key because an important character appears in it, even though that is the case. It became one because the number of copies put into circulation in 2019 had no relation to the number of readers who would want one three months later. This is the clearest definition of scarcity on a recent title, and it can be checked without any expert opinion, simply by counting the reprints.

The practical lesson is less flattering for someone buying at release. Nobody, in September 2019, had a solid reason to bet on this issue rather than on the dozens of other launches that month. Buying new in the hope of the next Erica Slaughter amounts to buying a lottery ticket: the only defensible strategy is to buy what you want to read, then be able to identify later exactly what you actually have in hand.

A first printing of Archer's Peak and a reprint with a different cover do not have the same value: have your copy identified before you file it.

Estimate my comic
Something Is Killing the Children #1: the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

Read the indicia, the block of legal notices printed in small type on the first pages or on the last page. A reprint carries an explicit printing mention there, "second printing" for example, with a print date later than 2019. The absence of any printing mention indicates a first printing. Neither the paper nor the colours constitute proof.

Yes, the October 2019 issue is where the character is introduced, after the attack suffered by the teenagers of Archer's Peak. Her employer and the structure she answers to are not explained in this first episode; those elements come later in the series, and then in the spin-off House of Slaughter launched in 2021.

Several, each time with a different cover, which is unusual for a mid-sized publisher's launch. The precise counts differ between sources and depending on whether later collected editions are included. What to remember: the rank is printed in the issue, and it is that rank that sets the value category.

It keeps a reading value and a completeness value, but it sits well below the first printing, in a ratio counted in multiples. Having it graded would cost more than the gain you could hope for. Keep it if you like its cover, and treat it as a reading copy rather than an investment piece.

The main cover, drawn by Dell'Edera himself, is the reference for the first printing and the most traded, so its price is the best established. Alternatives in limited distribution can fetch more, but their market is too narrow to be stable. For a first purchase, the main cover remains the most readable choice.