Once & Future #1 was published by BOOM! Studios on August 14, 2019, with a script by Kieron Gillen, art by Dan Mora, colors by Tamra Bonvillain and lettering by Ed Dukeshire. Bridgette McGuire leaves her retirement home and takes her grandson Duncan along on the hunt for an Arthurian relic that a nationalist group wants to use to bring back King Arthur. The first print run was heavily under-ordered, which led to the reprints that followed, and demand was never driven by a screen adaptation.
This issue holds a special place in a collection: it is one of the few 2019 launches whose value is entirely explained by what readers said to one another. No trailer, no cast, no broadcast date came to support demand. For anyone buying recent first issues, Once & Future #1 is therefore a useful point of comparison: it shows the level at which an issue settles when the only engine is the perceived quality of the series and the scarcity of the first print run.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
What the issue dated August 14, 2019 contains
The first chapter sets up two characters and a mechanism. Bridgette McGuire, a resident of a home for older people, turns out to have once been involved in an activity she never told her family about. Duncan McGuire, her grandson, leads an ordinary academic life until the moment his grandmother pulls him out of his routine without a useful explanation. The issue fits this turn into some twenty pages, which remains one of the most cited arguments for this launch.
The second thread is as editorial as it is narrative: an English nationalist group gets hold of an object tied to the Arthurian cycle and uses it to bring Arthur back. Gillen treats the national myth as a weapon, and it is this political reading of the Arthurian material that gave the title its identity from the first issue. Nothing is postponed: the monster appears, the rules of the game are set, Bridgette acts.
On the visual side, Dan Mora handles pencils and inks, with colors by Tamra Bonvillain that pull the night sequences toward highly saturated contrasts. For a buyer, this division of labor matters: the issue is often sought as much for Mora's work as for the script, and the career the artist went on to build at a major American publisher reinforced that second motivation.
BOOM! Studios in 2019, a catalog changing scale
When Once & Future arrived on the specialty newsstands, BOOM! Studios was no longer a niche publisher, but it did not yet have the automatic ordering of a major house. Retailers then placed cautious orders on its new creator-owned titles, reserving their volumes for the licenses already selling. It is this caution, not a decision to create scarcity, that explains the short initial print run of this first issue.
2019 is also the year the same publisher launched Something Is Killing the Children, whose first issue followed a comparable demand trajectory a few months later, except that it was then linked to adaptation announcements. Setting these two launches side by side is the most instructive exercise one can do with Once & Future: same publisher, same year, same under-ordering mechanism, but only one of the two titles benefited from a screen relay.
Gillen himself came from a path that relied on reader trust more than on professional buyers' trust: he had launched Die in 2018 and had just finished The Wicked + The Divine, two creator-driven series whose readers followed him to this new title. Mora, for his part, had worked for the same publisher on Klaus. None of this figured in the sales pitch at the time of the orders.
How this launch became a key without passing through a screen
The sequence is documented by the successive reprints themselves: the first print run sells out, the publisher reprints, and demand continues. What circulated was not an announcement but recommendations from reader to reader, relayed by the shops that had liked the issue and by online critics. The title therefore climbed while the series itself had published only three or four chapters.
This chronology makes it possible to isolate a factor that most recent keys do not allow us to isolate. When an issue rises after a film is announced, it is impossible to say what belongs to the work and what belongs to the studio's calendar. Here, the series ended with its thirtieth issue in 2022 without any broadcast adaptation, and demand for the first issue nonetheless held up. In practice, that is the ceiling a launch can reach when carried by reading reputation alone.
For a collector, the lesson is directly usable: an issue in this situation moves more slowly, but it also falls less sharply, since it has no news to disappoint. No project cancellation can take away its engine, because its engine is the opinion of those who read it.
The value variables specific to this first issue
Three elements weigh, in this order. First the print run: a copy of the first print run and a copy of a reprint do not play in the same register, the gap being more marked here than on a launch that was properly ordered, precisely because the reprints were numerous. Next the cover: Dan Mora's main cover is the market reference, and the other covers of this issue trade according to their own scarcity rather than that of the title.
Finally, the condition. An issue from 2019 has no excuse of age: the paper and binding are recent, so the market expects a copy close to new. On a comic from this period, a reading crease on the spine or a blunted corner loses more relative value than the same flaw on an issue from the 1970s, where the buyer accepts wear as normal.
Telling the first print run from the reprints
The check is made on the credits page, not on the cover. On this issue, the legal notices block indicates the print run; a copy that carries no print-run mention corresponds to the original printing. Sources disagree on the exact number of reprints this first issue went through, and that is one more reason to trust the copy rather than a memorized list.
Reprints of this title most often reuse Mora's image, sometimes reworked in a flat tint or with a label added. In other words, recognizing a reprint by eye from an ad photo is risky: a low-resolution thumbnail shows neither the credits page nor a variation in color. Always ask for a readable photo of that page before concluding.
One more useful marker: the filing date given in that block. A copy presented as a first print run whose credits page carries a date later than August 2019 is, at best, a careless description by the seller.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
The traps when buying this specific title
The first trap is deliberate ambiguity. An ad that reads "Once & Future #1 BOOM! 2019" without specifying the print run counts on the buyer assuming the original printing. On this issue, that omission is frequent and almost never corrected spontaneously, because the displayed price remains consistent with a reprint.
The second concerns alternative covers. This launch had several, including versions reserved for pre-order channels, and some are harder to find than the original printing itself. An ad that simply mentions a "variant" without naming the artist or the distribution channel does not let you assess what you are buying.
The third is tied to paper freshness. Copies from 2019 were often stored upright in long boxes without dividers, which creates a spine curvature that is invisible head-on. On a title where the market demands near-mint, this defect makes all the difference, and it only shows in a photo taken at an angle or when the issue is held by its edge.
Other issues in the series worth attention
Demand concentrates very strongly on the first issue, much more than on the launch of a typical long series. The second and third chapters follow at a distance, for a simple reason: they were ordered with the success of the first in mind, and so printed more widely. The gap in availability between #1 and #2 is one of the most visible you can observe on a title from this period.
There is, on the other hand, a kind of neighborhood by author rather than by series. Die #1, published in 2018 by another publisher, and the Klaus episodes drawn by Mora form with this issue a coherent set for anyone who collects creators rather than characters. This acquisition logic by signature is in fact the one that best supports value on creator-led titles, as seen with successful independent series launches.
Finally, the thirtieth and last issue, published in 2022, interests some collectors who want to frame the series by its two ends. Its print run, for its part, matched the real audience at the end of the run, which makes it a rare object for the opposite reason to that of the first issue.
What grading changes for a 2019 issue
Having a recent comic graded follows a different logic from that of an old issue. For Once & Future #1, grading does not serve to certify that a copy has survived fifty years: it serves to establish that the copy is indeed from the original print run, since the print-run rank appears on the descriptive label. That point of identification, more than the grade itself, justifies the process for this title.
The effect on value follows a rule that can be stated without figures: on a recent issue, the market mainly rewards the top two or three grades, and a copy graded slightly below the high end sells for barely more than an ungraded copy in very fine condition. The cost of the service must therefore be weighed against the grade you hope for, not against the average grade.
Tracking this issue in a collection
Two pieces of information must be recorded together for the entry to be useful later: the print-run rank and the identity of the cover. A simple "Once & Future #1" in an inventory will not tell you, in five years, whether you hold the August 2019 print run or a reprint, and that is exactly the information that determines the value of the line.
Add a photo of the credits page at the time of purchase. It is the document that will spare you reopening the sleeve to answer a buyer, and it is also the piece that makes a resale credible without discussion. For a series that ended at thirty issues, also note the completeness of the run, so that you do not buy the same chapter twice at a convention.
Finally, track value by comparison rather than by a remembered amount. The useful benchmarks are the sales concluded on copies of the same print run and the same condition, and reading those series of sales is worth more than a one-off estimate. Our other guides to key issues detail this method of record-keeping.
What this launch teaches about demand
Once & Future #1 is a textbook case because it answers a question that collectors often ask without being able to test it: what is a first issue worth when no studio is interested in it? The answer, for this title, is that it is worth something lasting, at a level below that of adapted keys, but with much lower volatility.
This has a practical consequence for how to buy. On an issue carried by word of mouth, there is no window of opportunity to seize before an announcement: you can wait for the right copy, of the right print run, in the right condition, without fearing a market drop while you search. That is the opposite of the discipline imposed by character keys such as those gathered around The Walking Dead, where news dictates the calendar.
To conclude: this issue of August 14, 2019 deserves its place in a collection for what it demonstrates as much as for what it contains. It shows that a well-made launch, championed by its readers, holds up without outside support, and it gives whoever buys it a reliable yardstick for judging every other recent key on the shelf.
You own a copy of Once & Future #1 and do not know whether it is from the August 2019 print run or a reprint? Have it identified before you sell it.
Appraise my comic
Frequently asked questions
The issue came out on August 14, 2019 from BOOM! Studios. That date is the reference for identifying the original print run: the legal notices page of a copy presented as a first print run must be consistent with that release, and any later date signals a reprint, even when the cover reuses Dan Mora's image.
Kieron Gillen wrote the script, Dan Mora drew it, Tamra Bonvillain colored it and Ed Dukeshire lettered it. This team has remained the main draw of the title for readers, and the reputation Mora later built on superhero series added a second reason to buy the first issue.
Because the retailers' initial orders were placed before any reading reputation existed, for a creator-owned title from a publisher that did not yet have automatic ordering. The print run sold out faster than expected, and the publisher reprinted several times. Sources disagree on the final number of print runs, so verify it on the copy.
It is mainly justified for a copy of the original print run in near-mint condition, because the descriptive label then fixes the print-run rank in black and white. For a reprint copy, grading certifies what limits the value and brings almost nothing at resale.
It caps the grade lower than that of an adapted key, but it also makes it more stable: there is neither a spike of announcements nor a fall after a production delay. The series, which ended with its thirtieth issue in 2022, keeps a demand fueled by recommendation between readers.