Deathstroke, real name Slade Wilson, enters the story in The New Teen Titans #2, dated December 1980 at DC, written by Marv Wolfman and drawn by George Pérez. The mercenary appears at the end of the issue to take over the contract placed on the team by the H.I.V.E. organization, a contract on which his son Grant has just failed. Collectors seek this issue because it contains the first appearance of an adversary who, four years later, becomes the driving force of the series' most famous storyline.
This issue occupies an unusual place in a collection: it is not a first issue at all, it does not feature the character on the cover as the headline draw, and yet it is the one people look for when they build a Titans shelf. The difficulty for a buyer comes down to two things: knowing exactly what you are buying, since the series launched in two stages and the notion of "first issue" is ambiguous there, and understanding that the value of this #2 was built in hindsight, long after its publication.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is asserted; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of protected art or dialogue.
The issue: December 1980, Wolfman and Pérez, a handful of decisive pages
The New Teen Titans #2 carries a cover date of December 1980. Marv Wolfman writes the script, George Pérez handles the art. The duo had just brought together, in the first episode, a seven-member lineup: Robin, then Dick Grayson, Wonder Girl, Kid Flash, Changeling, Raven, Starfire and Cyborg, the last three being creations or reworkings specific to this relaunch.
The plot of #2 follows directly on from this recruitment. A contract has been opened against the new team, and it is Grant Wilson, under the name Ravager, who takes it on first. His attempt goes wrong and costs him his life. Only then does his father, Slade Wilson, appear, announcing his intention to finish the job. Deathstroke therefore holds a role of a few pages in this issue, in the position of a promise rather than a fully deployed threat.
This point should be kept in mind before any purchase, because it explains both the nature of the key and its perceived level of rarity: the character is neither explained nor promoted commercially there. Nothing on this booklet signals to the 1980 buyer that they are holding something important.
The two-stage launch, and the confusion over "the real first issue"
This is the editorial particularity you need to master in order to buy without making a mistake. The lineup was not presented to the public in The New Teen Titans #1, but in a preview insert placed in DC Comics Presents #26, a monthly team-up title centered on Superman, dated October 1980. In other words, the team's first appearance and the first issue of its series are not the same booklet, and they sit in two different titles.
This two-stage structure muddies the vocabulary of sales listings. You regularly see a #1 described as the "first appearance" of the lineup, which is inaccurate, and sometimes an issue of the Superman title described as "the first Titans issue", which is no more accurate. For Deathstroke, on the other hand, there is no ambiguity: he is not in the October insert, he is not in the November #1, he arrives in the December #2. A seller who mixes up all three does not know their merchandise, and that is useful information about the rest of their lot.
Why this issue became a key, and only later
The trajectory is the reverse of that of an issue sought after from the moment it hit the stands. During his first years, the mercenary remains one antagonist among many in a title that lines up plenty: H.I.V.E., the creatures tied to Raven, the threats from space around Starfire. Nothing about him structurally sets him apart.
The shift came with the arc published in 1984 in issues 42 to 44 of the title, then called Tales of the Teen Titans, which readers call the Judas Contract. Slade Wilson stops being a paid henchman there and becomes the architect of a betrayal, through Terra, who had for her part appeared in #26 of 1982. This story establishes the character as the team's defined adversary, and it is also in its final chapter that Dick Grayson adopts the Nightwing identity.
The sequel confirmed this promotion: the mercenary received his own regular series in 1991, then a second career thanks to animated and live-action adaptations, which made him known well beyond the readership of single issues. Each wave of visibility pushed demand back toward the 1980 #2, that is, toward an issue printed at a time when nobody set it aside.
What moves the price: condition, paper freshness, edition
For an issue of this period, three factors dominate, and none of them reduces to a single number. The first is the condition of the cover, especially the two upper corners and the spine fold, which are the first to show wear on a stapled 1980 format. The second is the freshness of the black ink, very present on the covers of this series, where a rub shows immediately. The third is the origin of the copy: a 1980 newsstand print is not a later reprint, and that is where most of the price gap lies.
In relative terms, moving from a clearly read copy to a nearly new one shows up as a multiple, not a percentage, and that multiple widens as you climb into the high grades, where the available copies are counted rather than searched for. Conversely, between two average copies the gap stays small: this is the segment where you buy to read and to complete, and where a visible but stable defect costs little.
Recognizing an original printing from a reprint
The content of this issue has since been reprinted in bound collections and in digital editions, which is good news for reading the episode and a source of errors for buyers. A few markers settle the question without expert help: a 1980 booklet is stapled, printed on paper that yellows at the edges, and carries on its first page the editorial notices of its time, with the publication code and the advertising format of that year's interior pages.
A reprint or collection, by contrast, gives itself away through the whiteness of the paper, the absence of 1980 advertisements and, for volumes, the glued spine. In remote sales, the question to ask is simple and unambiguous: request a photograph of the interior title page and of the stapled spine, not just the cover. If the listing shows only the cover, it shows nothing.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
The traps at purchase specific to this issue
The first trap is the label swap between son and father. Grant Wilson, known as the Ravager, also makes his first appearance in this same #2, and some listings stress one of the two appearances while implying they are two separate issues. Both are in the same booklet: that is a sales pitch, not a reason to buy twice.
The second trap comes from the title itself, which changes name along the way: the series becomes Tales of the Teen Titans from #59, in 1985, while a second series once again bearing the name The New Teen Titans is launched for the specialty shop market. The result: several issue 2s exist under similar titles. The only one that contains the first appearance you are after is the 1980 one. Always check the year printed on the cover or in the interior notices, never just the title stated by the seller.
The third trap is the lot. The early issues of this series often circulate in "first issues" bundles, where the #2 is sometimes the only worn copy, or sometimes the only one missing. Count the issues one by one before you validate.
The neighboring issues that matter too
Around this #2, several booklets deserve to be tracked for different reasons. The October 1980 insert in the Superman team-up title remains the true first appearance of the lineup, and it is an object found in a different bin from the Titans, which makes it an opportunity for those who know where to look. The November 1980 #1 keeps its value as the first issue of the series, independently of the question of the first appearance.
Further on, #26 of 1982 brings Terra's arrival, whose role in the 1984 betrayal cannot be separated from the mercenary's, and issues 42 to 44 of 1984 carry the arc itself, with Dick Grayson's change of identity. A collector building a coherent set around the character is better off thinking of these milestones together rather than concentrating the budget on the #2 alone, whose demand is the most exposed to news effects. The pages devoted to Robin and Nightwing detail this identity shift.
What grading changes here
Having a copy graded makes sense when the price gap between two adjacent grades clearly exceeds the cost of the operation, and when the copy is likely to reach a high grade. On this issue, two elements favor grading: the stapled 1980 format makes the high grades genuinely rare, and demand is driven by buyers who purchase remotely, and therefore cannot handle the object, and who rely on an outside assessment.
Conversely, an average copy, with a marked spine fold or blunted corners, gains almost nothing from grading: the cost is fixed, the price is not. Grading also protects against an edition confusion, since the label carries the title and year, which settles in one line the question of the same-named issue 2s discussed above.
Tracking it in a collection
This issue illustrates well why a collection is better kept with an inventory than with memory. There is a 1980 series and another that takes up the same name a few years later, a tryout appearance in a third-party title, a secondary first appearance inside the same booklet, and a three-part arc under a third title. Six catalog lines, and as many opportunities to buy again what you already own.
In My Comics Collection, the catalog lets you record the copy with its exact title, year and issue number, then attach the observed condition and, if one exists, the grading case number. The rest of the Titans set is then built through visible gaps, which avoids both duplicate purchases and forgetting a milestone. To broaden the view, the Wonder Woman and Flash hubs help link the identities of this lineup's young heroes to their original titles.
Conclusion: a catch-up key, to buy with full knowledge
The New Teen Titans #2 is a key that did not announce itself. Nothing in December 1980 pointed to the final pages of this booklet as the starting point of a forty-year career. That gap explains both the difficulty of finding fine copies and the strength of the demand surges at each adaptation. Buying it properly takes little: aim for the 1980 year and not a namesake, demand photographs of the interior, position your budget between the #2 and the 1982 and 1984 milestones, and accept that a high grade is paid for in multiples.
Do you have a 1980 copy of this issue, or a lot of early Titans whose details you do not know? Have it identified before you sell or send it for grading.
Estimate my comic
Frequently asked questions
No. The first issue, dated November 1980, sets up the seven-member lineup assembled by Marv Wolfman and George Pérez, but Slade Wilson is not in it. His first appearance comes in the next issue, dated December 1980, where he emerges after his son Grant's failure on the contract placed on the team.
Because the lineup was first presented in a preview insert placed in DC Comics Presents #26, dated October 1980, a title devoted to Superman's meetings with other characters. The team's first appearance and the first issue of its series are therefore two different booklets, published under two different titles.
Yes, and he is in fact the one who leads the attack before his father. Both first appearances are in the same December 1980 booklet, which means there are not two issues to buy. A listing that sells "the first Ravager" and "the first Deathstroke" separately describes the same object twice.
By the year. The title becomes Tales of the Teen Titans with issue 59 in 1985, and a second title reusing the name The New Teen Titans is launched for specialty shops. Several issue 2s therefore coexist under similar titles. Only the one dated 1980 contains the sought-after first appearance.
They play different roles. The December 1980 booklet carries the first appearance, and therefore the key status. Issues 42 to 44 of 1984 carry the story that made the character the series' central adversary and that includes Dick Grayson's move to the Nightwing identity. A coherent set brings them together.