Monstress #1 (2015): the launch issue guide for collectors, article illustration

Monstress #1 came out in November 2015, written by Marjorie Liu and drawn by Sana Takeda. The issue opens the story of Maika Halfwolf, a teenager who has lost an arm in a world at war, bound to an entity she does not control. It was released as a double-length issue, thicker and more expensive than the launches of its time. The series has since piled up awards, including a Hugo, which keeps demand for this first issue alive.

The case of Monstress #1 is interesting because it contradicts a collector's habit. We learn to spot launches that climb on the strength of a film or series announcement; here, nothing of the kind was ever broadcast. Demand was built on critical recognition and on an object that was physically different from the other first issues of the same season: a booklet with a near-square spine, whose thickness determined how the copies aged in their boxes.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is asserted; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of protected art or dialogue.

Profile of Monstress #1: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

Monstress #1: November 2015, Marjorie Liu and Sana Takeda

The first issue of Monstress came out in November 2015. Marjorie Liu wrote the script, Sana Takeda handled the art and colors. The two writers knew each other before this launch from working together on superhero titles, and Monstress is their own project, the one they own the rights to.

The episode sets up a fantasy universe crossed by a war between humans and a population with animal attributes. The heroine, Maika Halfwolf, has lost an arm, and this missing limb is not a decorative scar: it harbors a presence that speaks, that is hungry, and that sometimes acts in her place. The issue devotes most of its pages to establishing this cohabitation, describing a market and a militarized religious institution, and delivering the first demonstration of what the arm can do.

Sana Takeda's art is a highly worked direct color style, with settings that blend mechanical and ornamental inspirations. This graphic choice has two consequences for a buyer. First, the cover has almost no areas of flat color that could forgive a scratch. Second, the dark solid areas and gradients reveal the slightest handling mark, which weighs heavily in grading. We come back to this below.

A first issue sold in double length

This is the material particularity that sets the November 2015 launch apart: the issue does not follow the standard page count of a monthly booklet. It is noticeably thicker, with a good sixty pages of story, and it was sold at a cover price above the norm of the period. The decision reflected the density of the narrative: the universe needed room before the plot could start.

This thickness changes three things in the life of a copy. The spine becomes wide, and therefore visible: a spine crease on a thin booklet is barely noticeable, on Monstress #1 it can be read from a meter away. The staples work harder, and a badly centered signature leaving the printer shows on the edge. Finally, the issue does not shelve like its neighbors: slipped into a run of thin booklets, it creates a step that warps the covers around it, or warps itself.

For a collector, the practical consequence is simple: the high-grade copies of this particular issue are proportionally rarer than for a thin launch of the same season. This is not a question of print run, it is a question of physical survival.

Why this launch became a key

Monstress #1 is not a first appearance of a character that can be recycled in a shared universe. Its key value rests on three distinct supports.

The first is position: it is the single entry point into a series that then ran for several dozen episodes and several arcs. When a long series keeps its audience, its opening issue becomes the only link that no one can replace with a collected edition, from the standpoint of a collector of single issues.

The second is the awards record, which we detail in the next section. It turned a fantasy title into a recommended read outside the circle of comics fans, and widened the pool of people likely to want the first issue.

The third is the relative scarcity of fine copies, a direct consequence of the format. On a thin issue, a patient buyer eventually finds a near-perfect copy. On this one, the sorting happens quickly: copies read once already show a marked spine. Those that stayed clean were often set aside as early as 2015, so by people who do not sell.

Awards in a row, with no adaptation

Monstress has been widely honored. The series won a Hugo for best graphic story, an award given by the science fiction and fantasy community rather than by the comics world, and it received several Eisners, first for the series itself and then for Sana Takeda's work. Other prizes have been added over the years; if a seller cites a precise awards record, check the year announced rather than the count.

This point is worth understanding for what it is, because it changes how the market reads. Demand driven by an adaptation announcement is abrupt and reversible: it rises within days and falls back when the project stalls. Here, no adaptation has been broadcast to date. The demand comes from readers brought in by the awards and by recommendations, so it is slower, more steady, and it does not collapse all at once.

The downside is that there is no spike to exploit. Anyone who buys Monstress #1 hoping for a quick multiplication is in the wrong file. Anyone who buys it as a core piece, in fine condition, on a series that stays in print and in circulation, is acting in line with the title. The same reasoning applies to other creator-owned series that have become library staples, such as Watchmen, whose price rests first on an established status.

What moves the price of this issue

Three variables dominate, in this order.

The condition of the cover comes first. On a direct-color illustration this busy, surface rubbing hides nowhere. Examine under raking light: micro-scratches on the dark areas appear, when the scan in a listing did not show them. This is the first cause of disappointment on receipt.

The condition of the spine comes next, for the thickness reasons already explained. A flawless spine on this issue is worth a full grade notch, and a grade notch on a sought-after launch can move the value by a large ratio, out of all proportion to the gap observed on a regular episode of the same series.

Finally, the nature of the copy: launch printing, later printing, or cover variant. Monstress #1 had several alternate covers from the outset, and not all of them are equal on the secondhand market. A low-print alternate cover can outrank the main cover; the reverse also happens. The useful reflex is to treat each cover as a separate object, and never to compare one listing with another without first identifying which cover is for sale.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Monstress #1 (2015): the sections of this guide, in reading order

Telling a launch copy from a later printing

Because the series has been reprinted, the copies in circulation do not all date from November 2015. The checks to run, in order of reliability:

The legal notices page, at the start or end of the booklet, carries the printing line. It is the most reliable source, and also the one a listing almost never photographs. Ask for it before buying, every time, for this issue as for any sought-after launch.

Next, the advertising and the end-of-issue content. A later printing often updates what announces the following episodes or collected editions: if the end of the booklet points to volumes released after 2015, you do not have a launch copy in hand.

Finally, the paper and the varnish, secondary clues but useful when you have both objects side by side. Compare the look of the cover: a different tint or a shinier varnish signals a separate press run. On its own this clue settles nothing, and the catalog remains the reference for knowing which printings exist for a given issue.

The traps at purchase

The most common trap is vocabulary. A listing that says "first issue" without specifying the printing describes content, not a collectible object. The absence of detail is not always a deliberate trap, but it forces you to ask the question, and a seller who dodges it twice tells you something.

The second trap is the format. Because the booklet is thick and almost square-backed, some sellers describe it as a collected edition, or file it with their collections. You will sometimes find this issue shelved in the wrong place, which can work in your favor, but also a collected volume sold as issue one, which works against you. Count the announced pages: a volume of several episodes has nothing to do with sixty pages.

The third trap is the copy that is well kept flat but was pressed. On a thick booklet, a copy that was compressed for a long time under a stack shows a slightly bowed spine or a cover that does not close flat. Ask for a photo of the page edges, at an angle, not head-on.

The neighboring issues that matter

Beyond the launch, the episodes of the first arc have their own interest. The very first issues of a creator-owned series are printed according to bookstore orders, and those orders rose over the first year of Monstress rather than falling, as the title found its audience gradually. On many series, issues two to four are therefore harder to find in fine condition than what follows, and they sometimes trade above much later episodes.

Also check for the presence of specials or one-shots tied to the universe: they appear after the fact in the catalog, and many collections stop at the main numbering without realizing a piece is missing. For a title with a dense universe, this is the classic gap between a complete collection and a collection that thinks it is complete. The same thing happens with long-running series that have a broad readership, whether it is The Walking Dead or fantasy titles in a monthly format.

What grading changes on a thick issue

Grading Monstress #1 answers a precise question: proving the condition of a cover that photographs poorly. On this issue, the interest is real, because the heavy direct color is exactly the case where a distant buyer doubts, and where an independent assessment settles the doubt better than a written description.

Two caveats, however. Grading has a fixed cost, and it is only justified if the copy is already well above average: on a read copy, it merely formalizes an average condition and creates no value. And on a thick booklet, the holder protects all the more because it stops the spine from continuing to work, which is a preservation argument more than a resale one.

If you have it graded, do it before the first move, not after. Experience shows that transport is what finishes off wide spines.

Following Monstress in a collection

For a title like this one, the inventory should keep more than the issue number and year. Record the exact cover, the printing, the spine condition separately from the overall condition, and the fact that the issue is in double length, because this last piece of information explains why it does not have the same storage place as its neighbors. A record that distinguishes the main cover from the alternate covers saves you the most common duplicate in this series.

The rest comes down to simple discipline: a sleeve of the right size, a rigid box suited to the thickness, and vertical storage that does not wedge the booklet between two thin neighbors. Monstress #1 degrades through mechanics, not light, so it is storage, more than exposure, that will decide its condition in ten years.

In short: a November 2015 launch by Marjorie Liu and Sana Takeda, unusual for its double-length format, carried by an awards record that includes a Hugo and several Eisners, and with no adaptation to stir its price. It is a core key, to buy in fine condition and to check with the legal notices page in hand.

You own Monstress #1 and you are not sure whether your copy is a launch printing, or what its spine is worth in this thick format?

Estimate my comic
Monstress #1 (2015): the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

Because it was published in double length, with a good sixty pages of story instead of the usual page count of a monthly booklet, and with a correspondingly higher cover price. Marjorie Liu and Sana Takeda had an entire universe to establish before Maika Halfwolf's story could really start.

No adaptation has been broadcast to date. That is precisely what makes this issue's price atypical: demand comes from the series' awards record and from reading recommendations, not from a casting announcement. It rises more slowly, but it does not collapse when a project is abandoned.

A Hugo for best graphic story, presented by the science fiction and fantasy community, along with several Eisners, first for the series and then for Sana Takeda's graphic work. Other honors have been added over the years. If a listing cites a detailed awards record, check the years it gives.

The legal notices page carries the printing line: it is the only reliable marker. As a second check, look at the end-of-issue content: if it points to collected editions released after 2015, you have a later printing. Paper and varnish settle nothing on their own, except through a direct comparison between two copies.

Only if the copy is clearly above average. The interest is real here, because Sana Takeda's very busy direct color makes micro-scratches invisible in photos and a distant buyer has doubts. On a read copy, whose wide spine is already marked, grading only formalizes an average condition.