Krypton versus the comics: a prequel whose outcome is annihilation

Telling about a world that we know is doomed. Decryption source by source, without disclosing the outcomes.

As in each article in this series, only verified information (creators, distribution, dates, publishers) is stated; the comparative analysis is ours, without reproducing dialogue or protected images.

A planet whose function is to have disappeared

Action Comics #1(1938) opens on a doomed world from which a scientist saves his son. Two panels, and the story moves to Earth.

This framing has never really changed, and we must measure its impact. For decades, Krypton has been not a place but a cause: which explains why the hero is alone, why he is powerful, why he is there. Its narrative function is to be already destroyed.

The authors of course returned there, through flashbacks and additional stories.World of Krypton(1979) is in this respect a unique piece: three issues entirely devoted to the planet, which constitute one of the very first limited series published by the publisher - a form that is commonplace today, then unpublished.

But even there, the regime remains the same: we visit a dead place, knowing that we know the end. Krypton is told in the past tense.

The central gesture: moving to the present

The transformation carried out by the series can be summed up in one word, and it is not about casting: the time.

Krypton is no longer a memory but a place where we live. There are factions, a capital, a caste system, house rivalries, an official religion. The characters do not know that they are living in a coming catastrophe: they are living in their time, with its own problems.

It is a complete inversion of the usual narrative regime, and it produces something that this body of work has not encountered elsewhere.

InGotham, the known destination was a consecration—Bruce will become Batman. InPennyworth, she was modest— Alfred will become a butler. Here she is a annihilation: Everything we see on the screen will be destroyed, and all the characters will die.

Neither of the previous two strategies works. One can neither wait for fulfillment nor be interested in the path to a modest place. We have to find something else.

The solution: threaten the birth of the hero

The series resolves this problem with a straightforward device — the narrative places at stake not the survival of Krypton, but the very existence of Superman.

The reasoning is clever. If the end of the planet is certain, we cannot make it the issue. On the other hand, the lineage that should emerge from it is not guaranteed: break it, and known history collapses.

The spectator then finds an uncertainty, moved up a notch. He no longer wonders whether Krypton will survive — he knows it won't — but whether the future he knows will hold.

This corpus indicates that this device has a cost. It makes the interest of the story depend on a prior knowledge: a spectator who does not know who Superman is does not perceive the threat. The series thus closes itself on the audience already acquired, which is a problem when we set it on another planet, two centuries earlier, with unknown characters.

The characters, from paper to screen

• Seg-El— Superman's grandfather; almost unexplored on paper.
• Adam Strange— Showcase #17 (1958); ferryman between worlds.
• Brainiac—Action Comics #242 (1958); collector of cities.
• General Zod—Adventure Comics #283 (1961); the convicted officer.
• The houses— Caste system developed on paper.

Adam Strange, a choice that is not trivial

The presence of Adam Strange(Showcase #17, 1958) deserves development, because it is not a wink.

This character is an Earthling transported to a distant planet by a ray, where he becomes a local hero. Its native function is that of a ferryman: it makes the link between Earth and elsewhere.

This is exactly what the series needs. A fully Kryptonian story lacks grounding — there is no one to explain this world to, no one to hold the viewer's gaze. Adam Strange provides this entry point, without having to invent it.

This corpus has observed this mechanism several times: the adaptations will look, in the catalogs, for characters whose structural function solves a writing problem. It is not notoriety that guides the choice – Adam Strange hardly has any – but narrative utility.

Kandor, the only surviving Krypton

The number that introduces Brainiac,Action Comics #242(1958), introduces a second thing: the city of Kandor, miniaturized and enclosed under glass by the collector.

This idea is one of the most fruitful in the Superman corpus, and it's worth understanding why.

Kandor is a fragment of Krypton that has escaped destruction. The planet may have exploded, but one of its cities still exists, with its inhabitants alive – reduced, prisoners, but there. The hero therefore keeps his original world in the form of an object, and keeps it at home.

It is a remarkable discovery of conciseness. It transforms an abstract loss into a physical presence, and gives the character a permanent reminder of what they cannot repair.

For a series set on Krypton before its end, this idea is obviously central: it is the only one gateway logic between the world told and the one that will follow. What the series shows is not entirely condemned, since part of it will remain under cover.

The collector will note that this 1958 issue thus concentrates two lasting contributions - a leading adversary and a mythological object - which explains a good part of its price.

A planet by turns warm and icy

One point often escapes recent readers: the representation of Krypton has changed completely over time, and the series must decide between them.

The ancient versions make it an advanced and living civilization, the loss of which is a tragedy. John Byrne's 1986 redesign in Superman: The Man of Steel takes the opposite side: a cold, sanitized society, where human connections have been rationalized. Destruction almost becomes a deliverance.

This 1986 choice was consistent with its objective — to make the hero a man of Earth, and not a nostalgic exile. But it makes a series like this impossible: we don't devote two seasons to a world that the reader is supposed not to regret.

The series therefore returns to the warm versions, and it is an assumed choice. She needs us to attach ourselves to Krypton for her end to weigh.

This switch illustrates a reality useful to the collector: in an old catalog, there is no a canonical version of a setting. There are successive states, sometimes contradictory, and each adaptation chooses the one that serves its purpose.

Collection side: which numbers to aim for after the series

Action Comics #242(1958) contains the first appearance of Brainiac, and it's the strongest piece of the lot. The character is a lasting figure among Superman's major adversaries, and this permanence supports his rating.

Showcase #17(1958) features the first appearance of Adam Strange. This title is an interesting case: it was the publisher's trial magazine, where concepts were tested before giving them a series. There are several considerable first appearances included, which has made this collection a sought-after segment in its own right.

Adventure Comics #283(1961) introduced General Zod. Its rating has been boosted by the adaptations, this corpus has noted it elsewhere: an adversary brought to the screen sees his first appearance follow.

World of Krypton(1979) remains accessible and is especially valuable for its historical interest as an early limited series.

As always, condition and gradation determine value; relying on real recent sales is strongly recommended.

Where to start reading

Start with World of Krypton(1979) for the planet as the comics explored it. Continue with Superman: The Man of Steel(1986) by John Byrne for the cold version, then Superman: Birthright(2003-2004) by Mark Waid, which restores a habitable Krypton. These three readings are enough to see the amplitude of the decor.

Timeline to know

• 1938— Action Comics #1: a doomed world, in two boxes.
• 1958— Brainiac and Adam Strange, the same year.
• 1961— Adventure Comics #283: General Zod.
• 1979— World of Krypton: the planet for itself.
• 1986—Byrne makes her cold and unrepentant.
• 2018— The series brings it back to the present.

Its place in the saga and for the collector

This series will remain as the prequel to the most unfavorable of the corpus: where Gotham promised consecration and Pennyworth a modest place, it promises total annihilation. His response — putting the hero's existence at stake rather than the survival of the world — is clever but costly, because it assumes an already informed spectator. Above all, it illustrates that an old decor has no canonical version but successive states, between the warm Krypton of the origins and the icy one of 1986. For the collector, it leads to two first appearances of 1958 and to the essay magazine which served as a laboratory for the publisher.

The verdict: the decor preserved, the narrative regime reversed

• Loyalty: the announced end of the planet, the El lineage and its marginalization, the caste system, Brainiac collector of cities and Zod's military ambition.
• Freedoms: a story in the present rather than in flashback, an almost unexplored protagonist, a threat to the existence of Superman, two centuries of difference with Jor-El and a political register.
• Collectible numbers: Action Comics #242 (1958), Showcase #17 (1958), Adventure Comics #283 (1961), World of Krypton (1979).

Two seasons on an exploding planet. The undertaking was more difficult than it seemed, and its termination is less due to its faults than to an impossible equation: to keep a story alive in a world whose only established fact is that nothing will remain of it.

Frequently asked questions