Fantastic Four #4, cover-dated May 1962 and written by Stan Lee with art by Jack Kirby, brings Namor the Sub-Mariner back into the pages of Marvel. Johnny Storm recognizes an amnesiac Bowery bum, restores his memory, and Namor returns to a ravaged Atlantis before unleashing the sea monster Giganto on New York. Be careful: this is not a first appearance, the character has existed since 1939. It is his reintroduction into modern continuity, and that distinction changes everything at the moment of purchase.
Few Silver Age issues cause as much confusion as this one. In a sales listing, "return of Namor" quickly becomes "first Namor", and the price follows the confusion rather than the bibliographic reality. If you are chasing the beginnings of Lee and Kirby's Marvel, Fantastic Four #4 is a must, but you need to know precisely what you are buying: the link that ties the Timely heritage of the 1930s to the series that had started only six months earlier, not the birth of a character.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of any panel or protected dialogue.
What Fantastic Four #4 contains
The issue carries the cover date May 1962 and the American cover price of twelve cents. The script is by Stan Lee, the art by Jack Kirby. The series has only three issues behind it at that point, and the episode opens on an internal dispute: Johnny Storm left the team in the previous issue, and while hiding in a Bowery flophouse he notices a bearded, silent vagrant of abnormal strength.
The sequence that follows became one of the most cited of the period. Johnny shaves the stranger, recognizes him, then throws him into the sea. Contact with the water restores the character's memory and identity: Namor, prince of Atlantis. The story then shifts from the urban to the disaster register. Namor returns to his kingdom, finds it devastated, blames human atomic tests for the destruction, and awakens Giganto to hurl it against the surface.
Two elements introduced here weigh on what follows: Namor's attraction to Susan Storm, which will fuel years of plotlines, and his ambiguous position, neither a clear enemy nor a clear ally.
A return, not a first appearance
This is the point to understand before taking out your wallet. Namor was born under the pencil of Bill Everett, at Timely Comics, in Marvel Comics #1 dated October 1939. An earlier version of the character circulated the same year in a promotional booklet of limited print run, which bibliographers debate; in practice, the 1939 issue is the reference copy for a first Namor, and it belongs to a rarity category that has nothing to do with that of a 1962 issue.
What Fantastic Four #4 brings is continuity. The character had disappeared from the newsstands after the war, except for an attempted relaunch in the mid-1950s. In 1962, Lee and Kirby do not create Namor: they decide that the 1939 Namor and the 1962 one are the same man, that the twenty years in between are explained by amnesia, and that the Timely heritage now belongs to the same universe as the Fantastic Four. It is a bridging operation, and that is precisely what gives the issue its value.
The nuance has a direct commercial consequence. A listing that writes "1st Sub-Mariner" on a Fantastic Four #4 is wrong, through ignorance or calculation. The exact phrasing is "first Silver Age appearance" or "return of Namor". If the seller resists this correction, the discussion of condition will be of the same kind.
The editorial context of 1962
In spring 1962, the house publishing this issue had only just emerged from the Atlas era and its giant-monster stories. Fantastic Four #1 is dated November 1961, issue 2 January 1962 with the Skrulls, and issue 3 March 1962 introduces the blue costumes and the Baxter Building. The rhythm is bimonthly, the print runs are those of a title that has not yet proven it will last, and Giganto, in issue 4, still looks very much like the creatures Kirby drew in the preceding months.
This context explains the scarcity of copies in fine condition. The first four issues were distributed on newsstands, read, folded, and kept with no thought of heritage: there were no comic shops and no protective sleeves in 1962. The high grades in circulation mostly come from unsold stock or from childhood collections preserved by chance.
Why this issue became a key
Three reasons overlap, and they are not equal in weight. The first is structural: with this issue, the Marvel universe stops being a collection of parallel titles and becomes a continuous whole, in which a character from 1939 can cross paths with a team from 1961. It is the first move of this kind, and it would be repeated later, notably with the return of Captain America in 1964 that you will find on the Avengers hub.
The second reason is the issue's place in the series. It belongs to the first block of four, the four issues that nearly every Fantastic Four collector seeks together. A number 4 completes a run; a missing number 4 breaks it. This serial logic, more than the individual value of the issue, sustains demand year after year.
The third reason is the character himself. Namor has carried a solo series since the late 1960s, has accompanied the great undersea sagas, and regularly returns to the news through adaptations. Each cycle of attention on the character echoes on this issue, because it is his modern gateway.
What moves the price
On a 1962 issue, condition dominates everything else. The gap between a read copy and a near-mint one is measured not in percentages but in multiples: a single grade step in the upper part of the scale can be enough to double the value, and moving from an average copy to an almost perfect one is measured in orders of magnitude.
Three specific defects weigh more heavily than the rest on this issue. Central staple condition comes first: comics of this period loosen at the spine, and a rusted or migrating staple drags the grade down. Next, the whiteness of the pages, because 1962 paper yellows, and a lot stored in an attic is recognizable at a glance. Finally, the reading creases along the left edge, a direct consequence of the newsstand format.
Two peculiarities of provenance also change the price. Copies destined for the British market carry a price in pence printed on or near the American price; depending on the buyer, this is either a sought-after curiosity or a discount, and the market does not agree. Copies bearing a regional distributor's sticker, or a handwritten subscriber's address, generally trade below an equivalent newsstand copy.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
Recognizing the original versus a reprint
This episode has been reprinted very often, which is good news for reading and a source of error for buying. Black-and-white reprint lines, color hardcover anthologies, bound complete editions and library volumes all carry this story. None of these formats has a collector value comparable to a May 1962 copy, and none seeks to suggest one: the confusion arises from listings, not from publishers.
The verification reflex is simple. An original bears the cover date and the American price of twelve cents in the logo box, a stapled-booklet pagination, and period advertisements inside: toys, correspondence courses, greeting-card sales. A reprint gives itself away through white paper, a glued spine, a barcode or a price out of step with 1962, or the complete absence of advertisements.
One case calls for more attention: modern facsimile editions, which reproduce the original cover exactly. They normally carry an edition notice and a contemporary price, but a cover photographed up close and cropped around the logo can look identical to an original. Demand a photo of the full back and of the indicia before committing, and if this issue has had such a print run, treat the ambiguity as real and ask for it to be cleared up in writing.
Buying traps
The main trap has already been named: the listing that sells a first appearance. There is a craftier variant, which writes "first Namor in Fantastic Four". The phrase is true and entirely useless, but it lets a hurried buyer read what he hopes to read. Read the wording word for word, and hold to the phrasing of a return.
Second trap: undeclared restorations. On an issue this scarce, cleaning, pressing, re-gluing a tear or replacing a staple are common. Pressing is not a restoration in the strict sense, but it changes the appearance; color touch-ups, glue repairs and hole filling must appear in the description. A seller who never mentions these points on a 1962 comic has not looked, or has chosen not to.
Third trap: the missing page. Interior coupons and cut-out advertising pages were commonplace in 1962, and a copy missing them sells legitimately, but for much less. Ask for explicit confirmation that the copy is complete, coupons included. If you are unsure what a reasonable relative price would be, our estimation gives you a benchmark before you negotiate.
Neighboring issues that matter
Fantastic Four #5, dated July 1962, introduces Doctor Doom, and is today the most sought-after issue of the series after the first. Issue 6, from September 1962, directly follows yours, since it pairs Doom and Namor against the team: the first villain alliance of the Marvel era, and it naturally completes a purchase of issue 4. Issue 3, from March 1962, brings the costumes and the headquarters.
Further along the series, issues 48 to 50 of 1966 form the trilogy featuring Galactus and the Silver Surfer, and issue 52, from July 1966, introduces Black Panther, which you will find on its dedicated hub. These issues belong to another layer of collecting, more accessible in high grade because print runs and storage habits had changed.
For the character himself, the trail continues in Tales to Astonish, where Namor gets a regular series from the mid-1960s, and then in his own title at the end of the decade. These issues are much easier to find, and they are a reasonable way to flesh out a Namor set when issue 4 remains out of reach.
What grading changes
On a 1962 issue, professional grading is not a luxury but a market infrastructure. It fixes a grade, seals the copy, and declares restorations. Without it, the remote buyer has only photos and a seller's word, on an object where a tenth of a point costs dearly. In the upper part of the scale, nearly all transactions go through graded copies, and a raw copy announced at a high grade almost always sells below an equivalent graded one.
The counterpart is that a grade is not an absolute truth: two assessments of the same copy years apart can differ by a step. Read the whole label, the banner, the qualification notice, the defect comment. On a copy of low or average grade, the cost of grading is rarely justified.
Tracking this issue in a collection
Good practice is to record in your inventory not only the number and the series but the three fields that will spare you repeating the mistake: the nature of the appearance, recorded as a return and not a first appearance; the exact edition, original May 1962, reprint or facsimile; and the provenance details, pence price or distributor sticker where applicable. Without these fields, an inventory blurs the reading copy and the collection copy within a few years.
The catalogue our app relies on already distinguishes the editions and reprints of a same story, which lets you attach your copy to the right line rather than a generic title. Add your own condition note and, if the copy is graded, the certificate number: that is the only way to find again, ten years later, exactly what you hold. For the same habits applied to the other founding issues of the series, the Fantastic Four hub brings together our records.
Then comes the purchase decision. Fantastic Four #4 is not an issue to rush: it requires knowing how to read a listing, accepting a modest grade if the budget demands it, and refusing without hesitation any description that promises a first appearance. Verify before you pay: the rule holds for the whole first block of 1961 and 1962.
Do you own a Fantastic Four #4 from May 1962, or a lot of the series' first issues, and want a value benchmark before selling or insuring it?
Estimate my comic
Frequently asked questions
No. Namor was created by Bill Everett and published by Timely in Marvel Comics #1, dated October 1939. Fantastic Four #4, from May 1962, is his first Silver Age appearance, that is, his reintroduction into modern continuity. Any listing that writes "first appearance" on this issue is inaccurate.
The script is by Stan Lee, the art by Jack Kirby, and the cover date is May 1962. As with all newsstand issues of the period, the printed date is a few weeks later than the actual on-sale date: it serves as a bibliographic reference, not a release date.
Johnny Storm discovers an amnesiac vagrant in a Bowery flophouse, whose contact with seawater restores his memory: it is Namor. Back in Atlantis, the prince finds it devastated, holds human atomic tests responsible, and sends the creature Giganto against New York.
An original from May 1962 is a stapled booklet bearing the American price of twelve cents and period advertisements inside. Black-and-white reprints, hardcover collections and complete editions have white paper, a glued spine and no 1962 advertisements. Be especially wary of facsimiles, whose cover is reproduced identically.
Issue 6, from September 1962, which gives the direct sequel by pairing Doctor Doom and Namor against the team. Issue 5, from July 1962, remains the series' key issue after the first, since it introduces Doom. To follow Namor alone, the Tales to Astonish anthology of the mid-1960s is much more accessible.