Barbara Gordon first puts on the Batgirl costume in Detective Comics #359, cover-dated January 1967, written by Gardner Fox, pencilled by Carmine Infantino and inked by Sid Greene. Commissioner Gordon's daughter goes to a police costume ball dressed as an improvised Batgirl, then steps in when Killer Moth goes after Bruce Wayne. The issue is sought after because it founds a heroine who is still active today, and because an earlier Bat-Girl muddies the market.
Few issues from the late sixties pose as many identification problems at the point of sale. You search for the first Batgirl, type "Bat-Girl" into a search engine or an auction site, and end up with two distinct characters, two decades apart, with two values that have nothing to do with each other. The one that matters for Barbara Gordon carries a single number, #359 from January 1967. This article is here so that you never again pick the wrong line in a sale, and so that you know what you are paying when you buy it.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
The January 1967 issue, in detail
Detective Comics #359 carries the cover date January 1967, which, by the custom of the time, means it reached the newsstands a few months earlier, in autumn 1966. The lead story is credited to Gardner Fox on script, Carmine Infantino on pencils and Sid Greene on inks. This is the trio then running the series, and it is within this framework, with no particular announcement the month before, that one of the publisher's most durable heroines makes her entrance.
The story is mechanically simple. Barbara Gordon, a librarian and the daughter of Commissioner James Gordon, makes herself a costume inspired by Batman to attend a police costume ball. On the way, she gets caught up in an attempted kidnapping of Bruce Wayne, orchestrated by Killer Moth. She intervenes, she gets away, and she acquires a taste for it. What could have remained a one-evening disguise becomes an identity, and that identity never leaves the catalogue again.
The cover puts the newcomer clearly in the spotlight, which matters to a collector: the key is readable on the copy, not buried in an end-of-booklet feature as in other first appearances of the same period.
What the title published in autumn 1966
By the time of #359, the booklet's format had been stable since the graphic overhaul of 1964, the one that gave art direction to Infantino and redrew the Batman emblem inside a yellow oval. It carried a main adventure of the Dark Knight and a backup feature, often devoted to Elongated Man, drawn in a lighter register. This two-part structure explains the modest page count of the stories and the speed with which a new idea could be introduced, tested, then kept or dropped.
The editorial context is also that of a title whose sales were benefiting from sudden fame coming from another medium. The first two seasons of the television series broadcast since January 1966 had pushed demand for the character back up, and the publisher was then producing quick, colourful stories, readable for a young reader and attuned to the expectations of a television audience. Barbara Gordon arrives precisely within that window.
A heroine born with an outside calendar
This is the feature that makes this issue interesting beyond its simple function as a first appearance: Batgirl was not born solely from a comic-book idea. Her conception partly answers a request from the television production, which was looking for a female character who could join the cast for an additional season. The role would be played on screen by Yvonne Craig from 1967. In other words, the January 1967 booklet and the broadcast belong to the same movement, the printed page taking a few months' lead over the airing.
For a collector, this dependence on an outside schedule has two concrete consequences. First, it explains why the character was pushed immediately, with close reappearances, instead of being left dormant for years like so many secondary silhouettes of the same era. Second, it ties part of the demand to the history of audiovisual media: each time a new adaptation brings the costume back on screen, pressure on this issue revives, sometimes for only a few months. A purchase made in the trough of an announcement cycle does not cost the same as one made at the peak.
Why this issue became a key
What sustains demand for #359 is the longevity of a character who has changed nature several times without ever disappearing. Barbara Gordon wore the costume through the seventies, shared stories with Robin, was paralysed in a 1988 story by Alan Moore and Brian Bolland, then was reinvented as a wheelchair-bound coordinator under the name Oracle, a role that made her central to entire teams, before regaining the costume in the editorial reset of 2011. Each of these stages brought in new readers, and each new wave of readers came back looking for the starting point.
On top of this comes the relative scarcity of durable first appearances of women in the Gotham universe: the list of names that have held up over six decades is short, and #359 opens it. For anyone building a collection around the Gotham police department, it is a piece one cannot avoid.
The 1961 Bat-Girl, a constant source of confusion
Before Barbara Gordon, there was already a Bat-Girl. Betty Kane, niece of Kathy Kane alias Batwoman, first appears in Batman #139, cover-dated April 1961, in a story credited to Bill Finger and Sheldon Moldoff. The name is then written with a hyphen, and the character has no link to the Gordon family: neither the same civilian identity, nor the same costume, nor the same narrative function.
This homonymy produces errors in both directions. Some sellers describe Batman #139 as "the first Batgirl" and ask a price calibrated on Barbara Gordon's fame. Others, conversely, sell a #359 cheaply because they believe it comes after a first appearance already used up. Before any offer, check three things: the series title, the number, and how the name is spelled in the description. If the listing talks about Bat-Girl with a hyphen and mentions Batwoman, you are not looking at the right issue. The character guide details the successive incarnations and their respective issues, which will spare you from having to decide in a hurry in the middle of a sale.
What makes the value vary
On a 1966 booklet, condition outweighs everything else. Paper from this period yellows, staples rust, and the cover, printed on thin stock, shows the slightest fold. The gaps between a read copy kept in reasonable shape and a near-mint copy are counted in multiples, not percentages, and moving one grade step at the top of the scale produces the most brutal jumps.
Three specific defects weigh heavily here. The first is the spine fold, visible as soon as you hold the copy flat under raking light. The second is paper discolouration, assessed on the edges and inside margins. The third is the possible absence of a page, especially when the booklet contained an order form or a game page that readers cut out; an incomplete copy drops out of the reference-copy market whatever its general appearance. There are also copies from identified, documented collections, whose provenance is valued separately; it is a niche, but it explains some listings that look out of line.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
Telling one edition from another
The original January 1967 printing is the only one that carries the original date and numbering in its legal information block, usually at the foot of the first inside page. It is this block you should read, not the cover, because reprints readily reuse the cover art unchanged.
Three families of reprint circulate for this story. First, the collections, which gather the first Batgirl adventures in a hardback or paperback volume: they are recognised at once by their squared spine and their pagination. Next, the large-format anthologies published in the following decades, which reproduce the story without its cover. Finally, the facsimiles, which replay the complete layout, advertisements included: when a facsimile exists for an issue, it carries a reprint notice and a modern barcode, and its paper does not have the tint of its model. If a listing shows neither the spine nor the legal block, ask for these photos before committing to anything.
Pitfalls at the point of purchase
The costliest pitfall remains confusion with Batman #139, already mentioned. The second is the vague description of the "first Batgirl appearance" type applied to a Detective Comics issue later than #359: the reappearances in the following months are interesting, but they are not firsts. Always check the number, not the formula.
The third pitfall is undisclosed restoration. On a booklet of this age, discreet reinforcement of a corner, mending of a tear or chemical cleaning of the paper turn up regularly, and they change the category of the item as much as its relative price. A restoration mention appears on the label of a graded copy; on a raw copy, it is detected by light and by touch, or not at all. The fourth is less clever but common: a cover that has come loose and been put back in place, invisible in a front-on photo, so demand a view of the staples.
The neighbouring issues that matter
Around #359, several issues interest the same collector. The close reappearances of Batgirl in the months that follow document how the publisher established the character; they can still be bought without difficulty and serve as an entry point when #359 is out of reach in the condition sought. Batman #139, from April 1961, deserves its place in a thematic collection precisely because it explains the confusion: having the two side by side is the best way never to mix them up again.
In another direction, 1966 is also the year of another lasting female arrival at the publisher, with the first Poison Ivy in Batman #181. The two issues sit a few months apart and cover the same production period. Finally, the 1988 story that upends Barbara Gordon's trajectory was published as a graphic album, not a monthly booklet, which makes it a collectible of a different kind: see the landmarks gathered in the Joker guide to place its successive printings.
What grading changes
For an issue of this age and this demand, third-party grading plays three distinct roles. Authentication matters little, since the booklet is not especially counterfeited; two real contributions remain, namely fixing the condition on a common scale and detecting a restoration invisible to the eye. It is this last point that justifies the step for a high-end copy.
In practice, the logic is arithmetical. At the bottom and middle of the scale, the cost of grading weighs heavily on the copy's value, and the step only pays off if you plan to resell. At the top of the scale, the gap between two neighbouring grades far exceeds that cost, and the absence of grading becomes a discount factor in itself, because no distant buyer will agree to pay a top-end price on a simple photo. Between the two, the choice depends on your horizon: a copy meant to be read and kept has no need to be sealed away.
Following the issue in a collection
An issue like this one is poorly managed in a spreadsheet, because the useful information is not a single line but a bundle: the series, the exact number, the edition, the condition, the purchase date, and the history of prices observed on comparable copies. The catalogue behind My Comics Collection separates the original printing from its reprints, which avoids precisely the error on which this issue's market thrives: recording a collection or a facsimile in place of the January 1967 booklet, and then believing you own a key you do not own.
The useful habit is to enter the condition and the edition at the moment of input. Six months later, you will no longer remember whether the spine fold was light or medium, and yet that nuance will determine the copy's relative value on the day you want it valued or insured.
Detective Comics #359 remains, at bottom, a readable issue: one number to remember, an explicit cover, a January 1967 date, and a single real difficulty, that of the 1961 homonym. If you retain this distinction, you will buy the right piece; if you add the discipline of checking the legal block before paying, you will buy it in the right condition. That is all this issue asks, and it is more than most buyers manage.
Do you own a Detective Comics #359 and not know where it sits between a read copy and a top-end one? Have it placed before you consider grading.
Estimate my comic
Frequently asked questions
Batman #139, cover-dated April 1961, introduces Betty Kane as Bat-Girl, niece of Batwoman. Detective Comics #359, cover-dated January 1967, introduces Barbara Gordon as Batgirl, the commissioner's daughter. Two different characters, two different costumes, two unrelated values. The hyphenated spelling is the first clue in a listing.
The story is credited to Gardner Fox on script, with Carmine Infantino on pencils and Sid Greene on inks. Infantino was then the title's art director. The character's conception also partly answers a request from the television production of the day, which was looking for a heroine for an additional season.
Killer Moth, whose attempted kidnapping of Bruce Wayne triggers Barbara Gordon's first intervention in costume. The starting point is a police costume ball, for which she had made her outfit without any intention of making it a lasting identity. That shift is what structures the story.
Read the legal information block at the foot of the first inside page: it carries the original date and numbering. Collections are recognised by their squared spine, facsimiles by their reprint notice and their modern barcode. The cover alone proves nothing, since reprints reproduce it exactly.
It depends on the condition. At the top of the scale, the gap between two neighbouring grades exceeds the cost of the step, and grading reveals a restoration invisible to the eye, so it is justified. On an average copy meant to stay in your collection, it ties up money without changing how the copy is used.