Bone #1 (1991): Why the Indicia Decides Whether Yours Is a First Printing, article illustration

Bone #1 came out in July 1991 from Cartoon Books, the company Jeff Smith created to publish his own series. Smith wrote, drew, inked and lettered it, in black and white. The issue introduces Fone Bone, Phoney Bone and Smiley Bone, chased out of their valley, and opens a story the author would carry through to issue 55, in 2004, without ever handing it off. The very small initial print run explains the search this issue attracts.

A collector interested in Bone #1 is not chasing a rare issue by accident of the market: they are looking for the starting point of a fifty-five-part series that one man wrote, drew, printed and shipped over thirteen years. The difficulty is not finding a copy, they circulate. It is knowing which one you hold, because this first issue was reprinted an unusual number of times, and because the series then exists in a second form, in color and from another publisher, which has nothing to do with the 1991 booklet.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is ours, with no reproduction of any panel or protected dialogue.

Profile of Bone #1: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

Bone #1, July 1991: date, author, contents

The booklet carries the date July 1991 and the name Cartoon Books in its indicia. Jeff Smith handled all of the graphic and narrative work. There is no colorist, the series being conceived in black and white, and the lettering is by the author's hand, which has a practical consequence for the buyer: there is no variant in the credits capable of distinguishing two states of the issue. Everything that separates one copy from another is read in the production, not in the credits.

The story sets up three cousins with the family name Bone, Fone Bone, Phoney Bone and Smiley Bone, separated after leaving their hometown, and follows the first of them into an unknown valley where he meets talking wildlife and a threat that slowly takes shape. The tone mixes social comedy and adventure, and the first issue works as a complete opening: it introduces the three protagonists, sets up the displacement and leaves the conflict hanging.

The format is that of a standard comic book of the period, stapled, with a cover drawn by Smith. The printed cover price is a useful dating clue, which we return to below, because it changed from one reprint to the next.

Cartoon Books in 1991: a publisher that fits on one address

Cartoon Books was neither a subsidiary nor a label: it was the structure set up by Jeff Smith and Vijaya Iyer to release Bone, handling invoicing, relations with distributors and shipping. That means the decision on the print run, in 1991, was made with the means of a household and not with those of a sales department. This is the mechanical explanation for the rarity of the first issue: nobody printed tens of thousands of copies of a title nobody was waiting for.

This independence held, with one interruption. In the mid-1990s, part of the series appeared under the Image Comics label before Smith brought it back to Cartoon Books to bring it to its end. The exact boundaries of this interval vary depending on the sources, and the indicia of each issue settle it: check it on the copy rather than relying on a copied list. This parenthesis does not concern issue 1, but it creates a frequent confusion among sellers, who sometimes list an "Image" series in bulk.

The point that matters for collecting value is the ending: the series concludes with issue 55, in 2004, after thirteen years of publication. Smith did not sell Bone, did not hand the continuation to a team, and did not let the series dilute into parallel titles during its run. A first issue whose series is finished, complete and closed by its author cannot be compared with a first issue whose continuation was taken over by others.

Why this issue became a key

Three reasons combine, and they weigh differently depending on the buyer's profile.

The first is arithmetic. The initial print run is generally put at around a thousand copies, a figure to handle as an order of magnitude rather than as a certified datum. At that scale, the share that survived in fine condition after thirty-five years of handling, reading and amateur storage is small, and it will not be rebuilt.

The second is the reputation acquired later. Bone piled up professional awards through the 1990s and established itself as a reference for long-form storytelling in American comics. The first issue was therefore sought retroactively, by readers who came to the series through the collected volumes, that is to say by an audience that did not exist in 1991 and that today looks for the original object.

The third is the legibility of the milestone. There is no earlier issue zero, no prepublication in a high-circulation anthology to muddy the question of the "true" first. Bone #1 of July 1991 is the entry point, without competitors, which is rarer than it appears and simplifies the purchasing decision.

What drives the price: condition, printing, provenance

On a booklet of this age and print run, the dominant factor is condition, and it weighs more heavily than on an issue printed at a hundred thousand copies. When the stock available at the top of the condition scale is counted in dozens of copies, one grade step can more than double the value, whereas the same gap remains moderate on an abundant title. The gap between a copy that was read and one that stayed flat since its origin is here a question of multiples, not of percentages.

The second factor is the identification of the printing. A first printing and a fifth reprint of the same issue do not belong to the same market: one is a collector's piece, the other a reading copy. It is the most profitable check you can make before paying.

The third is the signature. Jeff Smith signed a great deal at conventions during and after the series' run, which makes signed copies relatively common and undocumented signatures of little added value. A signature without proof of how it was obtained adds little, and can even complicate a resale if it cuts into the cover.

Recognizing a first printing from a reprint

Bone #1 was reprinted many times, and that is good news for the careful buyer: Cartoon Books generally indicated the printing rank. The notice is in the indicia, in small print, most often in the first pages. The absence of any reprint notice is the positive clue you are looking for, but it is not enough on its own.

Cross three elements. First the printing notice itself, when it exists. Next the printed cover price, which changed across the reprints: a price higher than that of 1991 signals a later edition even if the indicia is illegible. Finally the copyright notice and the publisher's address, which changed when the structure moved.

Be wary too of anniversary editions and facsimile reissues published later, which reproduce the 1991 cover very faithfully. With these objects, the quality of the paper and the whiteness of the whites will put you on the right track before any reading of the indicia: paper that is too clean for its announced age is young paper.

One last confusion to rule out, the most common: the family of color editions. Starting in 2005, Bone was reissued as colorized volumes by the educational publisher Scholastic, under the Graphix label, with coloring by Steve Hamaker. These volumes are collections, not booklets, and the first of them contains the content of issue 1 without being a reprint of it. A seller who offers "Bone 1" in color is not selling the 1991 issue, and the misunderstanding is often in good faith.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Bone #1 (1991): the sections of this guide, in reading order

The pitfalls when buying

The most costly pitfall is the listing that says "Bone #1" without photographing the indicia. For this particular title, it is the only information that counts, and a serious seller supplies it without being asked. Require a legible image of the small copyright lines before any commitment.

The second is the staple. On these printings, stapling is sometimes irregular from the factory, and you must distinguish a manufacturing defect, which is not damage, from a staple forced by the removal of a sleeve. Ask for a view of the fold lying flat.

The third concerns lots. "Complete series 1 to 55" sets very often contain a number 1 that is a reprint, sellers having completed their collection with whatever they found. This is not dishonest, but the price asked for the set sometimes assumes a first printing that is not in it. Have issue 1 valued separately from the rest.

The other issues of the series that matter

The very first issues that follow share the condition of the first: printings that were still very small, built up gradually as orders came in. Issues 2 to 5 are thus clearly harder to find in fine condition than issues further along in the series, once distribution had grown. For a collector who wants a consistent set from the beginning, the effort should go to these issues, not to issue 1 alone.

The issues published under the Image Comics label form an intermediate segment: easier to find, often better preserved, with no particular premium.

Issue 55, which closes the story in 2004, interests a section of collectors by symmetry, those who look for the pair of opening and conclusion. Its print run is incomparable with that of 1991, but its demand is steady, and its relative price remains modest next to the first issue.

Finally, spin-offs and specials published around Bone circulate at low levels and are not a source of value. Including them in a collection is a reader's choice.

What professional grading changes here

On a booklet with a very small print run, encapsulation with a grade plays a particular role: it does not serve first and foremost to prove condition, it serves to fix the identification. The label carries the printing notice, which cuts short the riskiest question of the transaction. For Bone #1, that is the main argument in favor of grading, ahead of the question of the grade itself.

The calculation still has to be made case by case. On a copy that is visibly read, the cost of the procedure and the waiting time are hard to justify: the grade will only confirm what the photos already showed. On a copy that looks very fresh and whose indicia carries no reprint notice, the operation can be justified, because it turns a debatable object into a comparable one.

Keep in mind that grading does not create scarcity. A copy graded high remains one among those that survived, and the market for Bone #1 is narrow enough that two sales close together can move the price reference in either direction.

Following Bone in a collection

The entry rule is simple to state and easy to forget: record the printing rank in the file, not only the title and the number. A collection that holds "Bone 1" without further detail is a collection whose value cannot be estimated, because the gap between the two hypotheses is too wide. Note the exact notice read in the indicia, the printed cover price and, if you have it, the acquisition date.

Then separate two sets in your inventory: the Cartoon Books booklets and the color collections. Mixing them produces apparent duplicates and makes any value tracking unreadable, since the two families do not follow the same curve. Sorting by publisher settles the question once and for all.

For the rest of the series, aim for consistency of condition rather than quick completion. A mismatched set 1 to 55 resells poorly, whereas a coherent block of first issues finds a buyer. If you are unsure what your copy is worth in its actual condition, an estimate based on the identified printing is worth more than an average of small listings.

What to remember

Bone #1 of July 1991 is an issue whose value rests on a precise combination: a tiny starting print run, a series completed by its author in 2004 at issue 55, and a reputation that came afterwards. Its difficulty is not in finding it but in identifying it, because the reprints are numerous and the colorized collections published from 2005 onward blur the nomenclature.

The method comes down to one line: read the indicia before looking at the cover. Everything else, condition, signature, grading, is decided afterwards. To go deeper into the mechanics of value on independent series, the other blog guides and the series pages such as Spawn detail neighboring cases.

You have a Bone #1 and do not know whether its indicia announces a first printing or a late reprint: have it placed before any sale.

Estimate my comic
Bone #1 (1991): the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

The figure most often cited is around a thousand copies for the initial July 1991 print run. Cartoon Books was then a family structure with no sales department, and no certified data circulates. Treat this number as a useful order of magnitude for understanding the rarity, not as a reference to quote.

Read the indicia, in the first pages: reprints generally carry a notice of their rank. Then cross-check with the printed cover price, which rose across the printings, and with the publisher's address, which changed. The absence of a reprint notice combined with the original price is the most reliable clue.

They are collections published from 2005 by Scholastic, under the Graphix label, with coloring by Steve Hamaker. They were printed on a very large scale for the school market and cannot be compared with the 1991 booklet. Their interest is in reading, and their collecting value remains marginal.

The two approaches are distinct. Issue 1 is treated as a piece, with a check on the printing and attention to condition. The complete series up to issue 55 is treated as a reading set, much more accessible. If you buy a lot advertised as complete, have issue 1 valued separately: it is often a reprint.

Generally very little. The author signed a great deal at conventions during and after the series' run, and signed copies are relatively common. A signature without documentation of how it was obtained adds almost nothing, and a heavy inscription on a fragile cover can even lower the condition grade at resale.