Batman #357 (1983): Jason Todd's first appearance, and Killer Croc's, article illustration

Jason Todd first appears in Batman #357, dated March 1983, written by Gerry Conway and drawn by Don Newton, inked by Alfredo Alcala. The boy does not yet wear a costume: he is presented as the son of a circus acrobat duo. The same issue offers the first full appearance of Killer Croc, glimpsed a few weeks earlier, and it is this second name that today draws part of the buyers.

Buying Batman #357 raises a question that few 1983 issues raise so insistently: what exactly are you paying for? Two debuts coexist in these pages, one discreet and one spectacular, and listings readily mix them up. For a collector building a coherent line around the second Robin, the difficulty is not finding the copy, which is fairly common, but knowing where the real value lies and why two copies at the same grade can trade at very different levels depending on how the seller worded the title.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, issue numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.

Profile of Batman #357: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

What Batman #357 actually contains

The cover date is March 1983, which places the release at the end of 1982 according to the practice of the time, when printed dates ran two to three months ahead of the newsstand. Gerry Conway writes the script, Don Newton the pencils, Alfredo Alcala the inks. The cover is generally credited to Ed Hannigan and Dick Giordano; if that attribution matters for your record, confirm it on the copy and in the catalogue rather than on the listing.

The main plot follows a reptile-skinned criminal who takes control of rackets previously run by another crook. Jason Todd, for his part, occupies only a few panels toward the end: a boy in the world of the circus, son of two acrobats. He does not fight, barely speaks, and nothing on these pages hints that he will one day wear a costume. That is exactly the profile of an end-of-issue appearance, and it has direct consequences for how the market treats it.

Batman #357 is therefore a double-entry issue: it fits as well in a sidekick collection as in a villain collection, and few issues of that year carry such ambiguity.

The editorial context at the end of 1982

At that moment, Dick Grayson had left the role several years earlier to lead a team of young heroes elsewhere in the publisher's catalogue, and the costumed partner slot was vacant in the main monthlies. Introducing a child without a costume, in a circus setting that openly recalls the origin of the first Robin, is no scriptwriting accident: it is a calibrated setup, placed at the end of the issue, that readers of the time could recognize for what it was.

What followed confirms the mechanism. The boy takes on the costume in Batman #366, dated December 1983, and his official installation in the role happens in early 1984. Between the two, several issues prepare the handover. This chain of steps explains why Jason Todd's first appearance never concentrated the market's attention on its own: the value is spread across a sequence, not a single issue, and each link finds different buyers.

Why this issue became a key, and for whom

Three forces pull on Batman #357, and they do not pull in the same direction. The first is Killer Croc, whose first full appearance is here, after a brief sneak appearance in Detective Comics #523. This character has enjoyed a longevity nobody expected in 1983, carried by animated adaptations and then by video games, and his recognition with the general public today exceeds that of Jason Todd among the same audience.

The second force is Jason Todd's trajectory: killed in 1988, brought back into the story in the mid-2000s under the identity of a violent vigilante, he became a permanent name in the catalogue, with his own series. The third is more prosaic: print runs of this period were still high, so supply is comfortable.

The result is a solid but rarely explosive value, which reacts mainly to adaptation announcements involving either debut. Those who follow the Robin lineage buy it for Jason, a villain collector buys it for Croc, and the dealer lists it with both names.

The 1983 Jason Todd is not the one you know

This is the point listings systematically skip, and it deserves understanding before you buy. The boy introduced here is conceived as an echo of the first Robin: acrobat family, circus tragedy, adoption. He was even redheaded at the start, and dyed his hair to resemble his predecessor. Nothing in this version resembles the battered street kid who later imposed himself in collective memory.

That version came after the editorial overhaul of 1986, which reset the publisher's continuity. In 1987, a new origin was published: a child left to himself, caught dismantling the wheels of Batman's vehicle in the alley where Batman's parents were killed. The character became harsher and more unpredictable, and it is this rewrite that made credible, a year later, the storyline that kills him.

For a collector, the consequence is clear: Batman #357 is the first appearance of the name and the character in the catalogue's sense, but not of the characterization most readers have in mind. This gap explains part of the market's relative lukewarmness, and it is a perfectly legitimate negotiating point against a seller who oversells the piece as the genesis of the future Red Hood.

The 1988 vote and the return, drivers of value

In 1988, the publisher put Jason Todd's fate to a reader vote by premium phone line, on two lines, one to save him and one to kill him. The death camp won, by an extremely narrow margin relative to the number of calls, and the character is killed in the arc concerned. This device is one of the most commented in the medium's editorial history, and it gives Batman #357 a particular place: the first appearance of a character whom the public itself condemned.

The return, in the mid-2000s, changes the reading again. Jason Todd comes back under a pseudonym borrowed from a historic enemy, and this reappearance mechanically revives interest in all his earlier issues, the 1983 one included. Since then, the issue's value has followed a recognizable rhythm: calm plateaus, then short jolts with each announcement of an animated film, series or game featuring either this character or the villain of the same issue. To track these movements, reason by comparing recent sales at the same grade rather than by memory of prices.

What moves the value: condition, edition, print run

On a 1983 issue, condition is read first in three areas: the upper corners, marked by newsstand racks; the spine fold, which the stapled bindings of this period show from the very first flat opening; and the cover edges, whose dark tone makes micro-whitening far more visible than on a light cover.

1983 paper yellows unevenly depending on storage: a copy kept flat and away from light keeps a page quality that weighs heavily in grading. Conversely, a gaping spine signals repeated reading, and that flaw cannot be recovered.

On distribution, 1983 was a transition period between the newsstand circuit and direct sales in specialty shops. Copies from the two channels are usually told apart by the barcode area. Check this area in the photos before buying, and ask for a sharp shot if it is out of frame, since this difference is one of the rare variation markers on an issue of this year.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Batman #357 (1983): the sections of this guide, in reading order

Telling one edition from another

For this issue there is no forest of cover variants like on recent releases. The risk of confusion lies elsewhere: in collections. Jason Todd's story has been reprinted in volumes devoted to his origins and to the lineage of Batman's partners, and these reprinted pages circulate widely. A collection is a good reading tool; it is not the first appearance.

Four signs are enough to settle it: the date and number printed on the credits page, a cover price matching the 1983 price structure, the stapled format of a monthly, and period advertisements inside. An interior with no advertising at all should shift the discussion toward a request for photos.

Finally, beware of listings presenting Detective Comics #523 as Jason Todd's first appearance: that issue concerns the other character in the file.

The buying traps

The first trap is the two-name listing title. A seller who writes both debuts on the same line is not dishonest, since both are accurate, but they implicitly add two demands together to justify a price. It is up to you to decide which of the two debuts motivates your purchase, and to compare with sales at the same grade rather than with the price the same seller displays on another lot.

The second trap is the copy presented as Robin's first appearance without qualification. In the market's nomenclature, that title belongs to the 1940 issue that introduces Dick Grayson, and a hurried buyer may misread. Batman #357 is Jason Todd's first appearance out of costume, which is different and narrower information.

The third trap concerns photos: on such a dark cover, direct lighting masks fine creases. Ask for a raking-light view and a full spine view; a refusal will cost you at resale. Our guides gathered in the blog index detail this photo-check method issue by issue.

Neighboring issues that matter too

Around Batman #357, four landmarks structure a coherent collection. Detective Comics #523, first, for the villain's brief sneak appearance before his first full one. Batman #366 next, dated December 1983, where the boy first appears in costume. The 1984 issues that formalize the role interest collectors attached to narrative steps rather than debuts alone. And finally the 1988 arc that closes the character, whose demand comes from a quite different readership, more sensitive to the Joker's role in that episode than to the genealogy of the Robins.

Add the 1984 issue that installs Dick Grayson in his new adult identity, whose Nightwing hub details the chronology. Owning both ends of this shift gives a collection line a readability that the 1983 first appearance alone does not offer.

What grading changes, and how to track the piece

On this issue, grading produces a threshold effect rather than gradual progression. Copies in reading condition are numerous and their value remains accessible; the top of the scale is much rarer, because a 1983 newsstand monthly with a dark cover survives the distribution circuit poorly. The gap between a fine copy and a near-mint one is therefore measured in multiples, not percentages.

Practical consequence: grading an average copy rarely makes sense here, as the service and shipping cost weighs too heavily against the gain in value. Grading is justified for a copy already exceptional to the naked eye, or for a copy whose signature authenticity must be established. For everything else, an honest description and good photos do the job.

In a tracked collection, the stake is to distinguish what you own from what remains to be found in the sequence. Record Batman #357 with the mention of both debuts, and create a separate line for Batman #366: the two issues quickly blur together in a list, and that is the kind of duplicate that leads to rebuying what you already have. The Robin hub then serves as a thread to check that no step is missing.

Should you buy it now?

Batman #357 is an easy-to-find 1983 issue, hard to find in beautiful condition, whose value is split between two audiences who are not looking for the same thing. That is precisely what makes it a sound, reasoned purchase: supply gives you time to compare, and the double demand protects the piece from lasting disinterest. Aim for the best condition your budget allows rather than quantity, check the barcode area and the spine, and do not pay twice for the same issue because it contains two debuts.

You own a copy of Batman #357 and are torn between keeping it as is or having it graded? An appraisal places you on the scale before you decide.

Appraise my comic
Batman #357 (1983): the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

No. In this March 1983 issue, he is just a boy presented in a circus setting, son of two acrobats, without a costume and almost without a line. He puts on the outfit in Batman #366, dated December 1983, and his official installation in the role happens in early 1984. A listing showing a Robin on the cover therefore does not refer to this issue.

Because Batman #357 contains his first full appearance, after a brief sneak appearance in Detective Comics #523. His public recognition, carried by animated adaptations and video games, now exceeds that of Jason Todd. Many sellers therefore headline both names, which adds two demands together on a single copy.

Not in his characterization. The 1983 version is an echo of the first Robin, from the circus, redheaded at the start and dyed to resemble his predecessor. The street-kid origin, the one most readers know, was published in 1987 after the 1986 continuity overhaul. The name and the character debut here, but the version people remember comes later.

Indirectly, yes. The reader vote that condemned the character, then his return in the mid-2000s, made him a permanent name in the catalogue. Each adaptation that uses him revives demand for his earlier issues, including the 1983 one. The price jolts remain short, and the intermediate plateaus rather calm.

Check four things: the date and number printed on the credits page, a cover price matching the 1983 price structure, the stapled format of a monthly, and the presence of period advertisements inside. An interior with no advertising at all almost always betrays a collection. Also ask for a sharp photo of the barcode area.