Avengers #4, cover-dated September 1964, is written by Stan Lee and drawn by Jack Kirby. It shows Captain America trapped in a block of ice, recovered, then revived, before he joins the team. This is not his first appearance: the character has existed since 1941. It is his reintroduction into Marvel's modern continuity, and for that reason collectors treat it as the most sought-after issue of the series.
A buyer's file on Avengers #4 always starts with a correction of vocabulary, and that correction has a market value. Listings that present this issue as the first appearance of Captain America are wrong by twenty-three years, but they are not wrong about its scarcity: it is indeed the copy a Marvel-era collector seeks first in the series, and the only one whose price clearly stands apart from the pack of early issues. Understanding why the reintroduction weighs more than the creation will keep you from both paying for a false argument and underestimating a true key issue.
As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated as fact; the analysis is our own, with no reproduction of panels or protected dialogue.
The issue: September 1964, Lee and Kirby, a block of ice
Avengers #4 carries the cover date of September 1964. Stan Lee writes the script, Jack Kirby the pencils, and the inking of this issue is credited to George Roussos, who was credited under a pseudonym at the time, as was common in Marvel publications of those years. The cover makes the event clear without hesitation: Captain America joins the team. For a 1964 publication, this is a promise of a different order than the arrival of a new character, because it calls up a name that older readers had known as children.
The narrative mechanism has become one of the most cited in American publishing history. Captain America is found floating in a block of ice, preserved intact since the end of the Second World War, and brought aboard by the team. The Sub-Mariner plays a part in the block's journey: his anger sends it adrift, which places it on the Avengers' course. Revived, the character discovers an age that is no longer his, and the story gives him a personal loss that explains his isolation.
What this issue sets up goes well beyond an arrival in a group. It supplies a mechanical explanation for an absence of nearly twenty years, and the explanation is so effective that it has never been replaced. Everything Marvel has since told about the character, including the stories that exploit his time displacement, rests on the find of September 1964.
1941 first: why this is not a first appearance
Captain America was born at Timely, the ancestor of Marvel, in Captain America Comics #1 dated March 1941, with pencils by Jack Kirby and a script by Joe Simon. The character led the sales charts through the war, then disappeared from newsstands when the costumed genre collapsed at the end of the forties. Twenty-three years separate his birth from his return in the 1964 series, and no commercial presentation can smooth over that gap.
The nuance has very concrete consequences in a market. A first appearance trades on the scarcity of the original title; a reintroduction trades on its role as an entry point into a continuity still read today. Both issues are expensive, for different reasons, and they do not address the same buyer. Someone hunting war-era publications looks at 1941. Someone building a Marvel-era collection looks at September 1964, because that is where the character becomes contemporary with Thor, Iron Man and the other figures born in the sixties.
The editorial context: two attempts before this one
Marvel did not improvise this return. In the mid-fifties, the publisher had already tried to revive the character in a short-lived series, an episode generally treated since as outside the main continuity, and rebuilt much later by stories that made it a plot element. Then, in 1963, a Human Torch story featured a man in a Captain America costume who turns out to be an impostor. This trial balloon, published a few months before the 1964 issue, looks very much like a gauge of readers' appetite.
The quartet that fishes the block of ice out in September 1964 is not, moreover, the one from the first issue of the series: the green giant left the group very early, and only two couples of characters remain, one reduced or bombastic, including the Wasp and her partner with the size-changing power. This detail matters to the collector, because it explains why the arrival of a fifth name was sold as reinforcement rather than as a simple guest appearance.
Why this issue became the most expensive key of the series
In a series with hundreds of issues, one concentrates the demand, and it is not the first. Three forces add up on the September 1964 issue. The first is the event itself, instantly recognizable to a buyer who knows nothing about the rest of the series. The second is the character's longevity: he has not left the catalog since, which guarantees a steady flow of new readers tracing back to the modern origin. The third is the physical scarcity of 1964 copies in good condition, a subject covered further below.
Add to this an effect of outside notoriety. Each time the costume reappears in a mainstream production, demand shifts to two targets only: the 1941 publication, out of reach for most budgets, and this issue. The price gap between Avengers #4 and its immediate neighbors has widened across these waves, and it has not closed between them.
What moves the price: condition, price variant, paper quality
On a 1964 issue, condition does almost everything. The paper of the period yellows, the staples rust, and cover colors show the slightest fold. Between a readable but tired copy and a fresh one, the difference is not a few percent: it is counted in multiples, and it accelerates at the top of the scale, where every half notch of grade costs far more than the one below.
Four defects weigh particularly on this issue. The vertical reading crease, almost systematic on the issues of this decade. Rust stains around the staples, which signal humid storage. The browning of the paper, which disqualifies a copy for high grades even without a mechanical defect. And the cutting of the interior coupon, when the publication included one: check the completeness of the pages before any offer.
On the editions side, American releases of 1964 also circulated in the United Kingdom with a price in pence, stamped or printed in place of the American price. These copies are authentic and contemporary, but they form a separate market, generally less valued than the American-price edition. Read the price block before comparing two listings against each other.
Telling the original from a reprint or a facsimile
This story has been reprinted often, which is a good thing for reading it. It is, however, a source of confusion at purchase, because reprint covers frequently reuse the 1964 image. Three reflexes settle the question.
First reflex: the indicia, the block of legal text in small print, usually on the first or last interior page. It gives the real publication date and the name of the publishing company. A modern indicia on a 1964 cover signals a reprint or a facsimile, whatever the fidelity of the image.
Second reflex: the price block. A cover price unrelated to 1964 rates settles it in a second. Third reflex: the advertising pages. Comics of the period are full of advertisements of a very dated nature, and their absence, or their replacement by ads for recent publications, betrays a late edition. Marvel has also published facsimiles of several of its founding issues from the sixties: they are beautiful objects, sold as such, and the only problem starts when a listing leaves out the word facsimile.
Do you collect this series?
Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.
Start my trial →
Buying traps
The main trap is the wording. A listing that promises the first appearance of Captain America on a 1964 copy is either badly informed or opportunistic, and in both cases it is reason enough to read the rest of the description with suspicion.
The second trap is undisclosed restoration. On an issue of this age, interventions are frequent: reinforcing the spine, filling a loss, retouching color on a worn edge. An honestly disclosed restoration has its place on the market, at a lower price level; a concealed restoration is a dispute in the making. Ask for photos, flat and in raking light, of the edge and the spine.
The third trap is subtler: confusing this issue with a foreign edition. The story has been translated and republished in many countries, sometimes with a very similar cover and a local numbering. These editions have their documentary interest; they do not carry the value of the original American edition. Check the language of the indicia, not just the language of the cover.
Neighboring issues that matter in this dossier
Around September 1964, several issues are collected in continuity with this one, and it is useful to rank them before spending. The March 1941 publication remains the summit of the dossier, out of reach for most budgets at correct grades, and it is bought for its own sake, not as a substitute. The 1963 Human Torch story with its false Captain America interests collectors documenting the preparation of the return, and it trades at a level out of all proportion.
On the sequel side, the issues that settle the character into his anchoring role within the team through the sixties form a coherent and still accessible set, which makes it a good building zone when the main key is out of budget. Later, the dossier widens to the figures who extend the character, including his aerial partner and, much later, the return of his wartime companion under another identity, which you will find on the Winter Soldier hub.
What grading changes here
Grading a 1964 copy is easier to justify than on a recent issue, for two reasons. First, the price gap between neighboring grades is wide enough to absorb the cost of the operation. Second, grading settles the restoration question, which is precisely the blind spot of a remote sale on an issue of this age.
Grading is not magic, however. It locks a copy under plastic, does not make it any more attractive, and on paper that has already browned it caps the result mechanically. Before sending, assess the probable grade honestly: if the copy does not reach the middle of the scale, the gain is often smaller than the cost, and a raw copy that is well photographed sells very reasonably.
Tracking it in a collection
This issue deserves a more detailed record than average, because it piles up points of confusion. In your inventory, note the series, the number, the September 1964 cover date, then the exact edition: American price, pence price, reprint or facsimile. Add the nature of the event in plain words, return to the Marvel era and not first appearance, so that the line stays accurate on the day you sell.
Also record what you have checked on the copy: indicia read, pages counted, coupon present or absent, photos of the edge archived. This information serves no purpose for years, then it makes the difference at the moment of transfer, when a buyer asks for exactly that. My Comics Collection lets you attach these notes and photos to the record, and to follow the issue among the other milestones of the dossier of the team's founders.
What to remember
Avengers #4 of September 1964 is the issue through which Captain America becomes a living character of the Marvel catalog again, thanks to an explanation, the block of ice, that justified twenty years of silence without ever being replayed. It is not the character's birth, which dates to March 1941, and that distinction should appear in your listing as well as in your record. It does not diminish its value: it is indeed the most expensive issue of the series, and the only one whose demand comes simultaneously from fans of the hero and fans of the group.
At purchase, focus on three checks: the indicia to rule out a reprint, the price block to identify the edition, and edge photos to detect a restoration. The rest is a matter of patience and budget.
Do you have a 1964 copy with the block of ice on the cover, or a doubt about the edition you hold? Have it examined before setting a price.
Appraise my comic
Frequently asked questions
No. The character first appears in Captain America Comics #1, dated March 1941, created by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby at Timely. The September 1964 issue is his reintroduction into Marvel's modern continuity and his entry into the team. Listings announcing a first appearance are off by twenty-three years.
Stan Lee on the script and Jack Kirby on the pencils, with the inking credited to George Roussos, who signed under a pseudonym at the time. This team partly explains the issue's status: Kirby had co-created the character in 1941, and he redrew him twenty-three years later in an entirely different editorial context.
It provides the justification for an absence of nearly twenty years without aging the character. Found preserved in ice since the end of the war and then revived, he wakes in an era he does not recognize. The device has never been replaced and still underpins every story that plays on his time displacement.
Read the indicia, the legal block in small print inside: it gives the real publication date. Then check the price block, which is inconsistent on a reprint, and the advertising pages, which are very dated in a 1964 comic. A faithful cover proves nothing; the interior settles it in seconds.
Because it combines two demands on a single print run: collectors of the character and collectors of the group. Add the scarcity of 1964 copies on fresh paper and the reflected notoriety of each reappearance of the costume in mainstream productions. The gap with neighboring issues has widened wave after wave.