Amazing Spider-Man #121 (1973): the death of Gwen Stacy, and the pair, article illustration

Amazing Spider-Man #121, dated June 1973, is the issue titled "The Night Gwen Stacy Died". It is written by Gerry Conway, pencilled by Gil Kane, inked by John Romita Sr. and Tony Mortellaro. The Green Goblin throws Gwen Stacy from the top of a bridge pylon, and the young woman does not survive. Collectors seek this issue because it marks a death that was never later undone, and because it forms a two-part story with #122.

Few issues pose a collector a problem as concrete as this one: you are not buying a single issue, you are buying a pair, and the two halves of that pair do not sell for the same price. #121 carries the event, #122 carries its immediate consequence, and the market settled long ago in favour of the first. Knowing by how much, and at what grade, is the difference between a reasoned acquisition and an impulse buy at auction.

As always on this guide, only verified information (creators, numbers, dates) is stated; the analysis is our own, without reproducing any panel or protected dialogue.

Profile of Amazing Spider-Man #121: issue number, year and why it is a key issue

The June 1973 issue and its creative team

The cover date is June 1973, which places the release a few weeks earlier, following the custom of the time. The script is by Gerry Conway, a recently established regular writer on the series. The pencils are by Gil Kane, whose nervous line and low-angle framing contrast with the roundness John Romita Sr. had established on the title in previous years. Romita inks, alongside Tony Mortellaro, and produces a cover that announces the death of a character without saying which one, lining up the faces of the hero's loved ones behind a silhouette seen from behind.

The story fits into a few pages: the Green Goblin, restored to himself after a long narrative amnesia, kidnaps Gwen Stacy and takes her to the top of a bridge pylon. The hero arrives, the confrontation begins, the young woman is thrown into the void, and a web catches her in mid-fall. She is dead by the time he brings her back to the platform. The episode closes on an accusation levelled at the hero by a witness, and pushes the final confrontation to the next issue.

A graphic oddity has accompanied this issue since its release: the bridge drawn on the pages and the bridge named in the text are not the same structure. The inconsistency, noticed very early by readers, has no effect on value, but it says something about how a monthly was put together quickly in 1973.

The editorial context of the series at the time

In the early 1970s, the title was emerging from an unusual editorial sequence: three issues published without the Comics Code Authority seal because they dealt with drug addiction, then the death of Captain Stacy, Gwen's father, some thirty issues before this one. The tone of the monthly had therefore already moved towards a social realism that superhero series had rarely tackled until then.

The handover from Stan Lee to Gerry Conway on the scripts falls within this movement, and the new writer inherits a saturated narrative situation: an established fiancée, an antagonist rendered harmless by amnesia, a status quo the title had maintained issue after issue. Killing Gwen Stacy solves all three problems at once. It is a workshop decision as much as an authorial gesture, and the accounts published since by those involved credit the idea to the editorial team collectively rather than to any single person.

Why it is seen as the dividing line between two ages of comics

The periodisation of the American market remains a collectors' convention, not an objective fact, and several issues compete for the role of hinge between the Silver Age and the Bronze Age. This one is among the most frequently proposed candidates, and the reason can be summed up in one word: irreversibility. Gwen Stacy dies and stays dead, with no clone recognised as the true person and no resurrection validated by the main continuity. Later attempts to circumvent this death have all been attached to copies or to parallel versions.

To place this issue within the trajectory of the hero and his circle, the Spider-Man hub lists the other milestones of the series, from its beginnings to recent periods.

The debate over the mechanism of death, never closed

Here is the point on which a seller will readily assert a certainty that the sources do not give. On the page, a sharp onomatopoeia appears near the character's neck at the moment the web halts the fall. For fifty years, two readings have stood opposed. The first: the sudden deceleration caused by the web broke the neck, so the hero caused the very death he was trying to prevent. The second: the character was already dead before the fall, or the height made survival impossible whatever move was attempted.

The debate has been fuelled by the editorial team itself: a letters page published a few issues later took a position in one direction, later statements by members of the creative team nuanced or contradicted that position, and the reuses of the passage in later series never converged. The sources diverge, and they diverge even among the people who made the pages.

A two-part story, two key issues, two prices

#122, dated July 1973, closes the story: the Green Goblin meets his own end in turn, killed by his own glider during the final confrontation. In itself, it is therefore another key issue, and it is indeed often presented as one. But the market does not treat the two parts equally. #121 concentrates the event the general public knows, and its price gap with #122 is counted in multiples at equal grade, not in percentages.

Three buying strategies emerge. Buying both at the same grade, which gives a coherent set in a box but ties up a large budget in a single sequence. Buying #121 at the highest grade you can afford and #122 one or two steps lower, which is the most common compromise. Or buying only #122 at first, as a waiting position, betting that a two-part story always ends up pulling its cheaper half upwards. None is wrong; each answers a different horizon.

The Green Goblin hub lets you place #122 within the long history of the antagonist, and identify the other issues where his appearances matter.

What moves the price of a 1973 issue

The comics of this period suffer from a structural weakness: the paper contains a lot of mechanical pulp and yellows quickly. On a high-print-run 1973 issue, it is therefore not the reading creases that separate the copies, since almost all have them, but the tint of the pages and the hold of the spine. A copy with pages still bright climbs a step in negotiation even if its cover shows visible defects. Add to that the two original staples, unreplaced and free of rust bleeding into the paper, and the centring of the cover at print, very uneven on the print runs of those years, which caps the attainable grade before wear is even discussed.

Finally, the gap in value between two neighbouring grade steps is not linear on this issue. In middling conditions, a gained step is paid modestly; in high conditions, the same step can double or triple the value, because the copies available are then counted in tens rather than thousands. This non-linearity is what makes an eyeball estimate so unreliable for a piece of this rank.

Do you collect this series?

Track what you own, what you are missing and what your collection is worth. 7-day trial.

Start my trial →
Amazing Spider-Man #121 (1973): the sections of this guide, in reading order

Telling an original printing from a reprint

First rule, mechanical and final: a barcode printed on the cover rules out the original printing. American comics only began to carry that block from the mid-1970s onward. On a copy presented as an original 1973 issue, the area at the bottom left of the cover must contain a graphic element, never a barcode.

Second rule: read the indicia, the block of legal text in small print on one of the first pages. It gives the publication date and the edition statement. A reprint, a collected edition or a facsimile almost always leaves a trace there: a more recent copyright line, a different volume number, a collection name. The classics of this period were reprinted many times, including under covers very close to the original, and it is the indicia that decides, not the visual impression.

Third rule: copies intended for the British market carried a price in pence printed at the time of printing. These are original printings, not reprints, but they form a separate category whose value follows its own logic depending on the market. If the cover price is not the one you expect, do not conclude forgery: first check the hypothesis of British distribution.

Pitfalls when buying

The most common pitfall, on this particular issue, is a mix-up of numbering in a listing. The two parts of the story sell side by side, their photographs look little alike, but listing titles are sometimes copied from one record to another, and a #122 presented with the description of #121 is not rare on general marketplaces. Read the number on the photographed cover, not in the listing title.

The second pitfall concerns undeclared restorations. On a piece of this rank, filling a spine loss, reinforcing a fold or chemically cleaning the pages all exist, and none is detectable in a compressed photograph. A restored copy keeps its value, but on a different scale, and the gap with an unrestored copy of apparently equivalent grade is considerable.

The third pitfall is more insidious: a cut-out order coupon from inside the issue. Comics of 1973 carried advertising inserts with coupons, and many young readers cut them out. A missing coupon caps the grade regardless of the overall condition, and this information almost never appears in a spontaneous description. Ask before buying.

The neighbouring issues that also matter

Around the two-parter, four milestones also trade above the series' usual price. #90, where Captain Stacy, Gwen's father, dies, directly sets up the logic of this issue and remains much more affordable. #96 to #98, published without the Comics Code Authority seal because of their subject, form a trio sought for documentary rather than narrative reasons. Finally #129, eight issues after the one we are looking at, carries the first appearance of the Punisher, whose value follows a trajectory largely unconnected to that of the two-parter, as detailed in the Punisher hub.

Note finally that the character of Gwen Stacy had a second editorial life forty years later, in a parallel version that became a series in its own right. This late afterlife has no measurable effect on the value of #121, but it explains part of the demand from recent collectors, as the Spider-Gwen hub shows.

What grading changes on this issue

Having a piece graded by a third party turns a debatable object into a comparable one. On an issue traded this much, it has three effects. Liquidity first: a graded copy sells faster, because the distant buyer no longer has to judge from a photograph. Dispersion next: prices observed at the same certified grade tighten considerably, which makes valuation easier. And detection of restorations, which appear under a separate notation instead of remaining invisible.

The trade-off remains economic. The cost of grading and shipping is fixed, while the added value it brings is proportional to the value of the piece. On a #121 in average condition, the operation is debatable; on a copy you judge to be high-end, it is almost always justified. On #122, which is more affordable, the break-even point sits higher on the grading scale.

Tracking the two-parter in a collection, and conclusion

In a well-maintained collection, this issue cannot be recorded on its own. Create both lines, #121 and #122, even if you own only one, and record for each the condition, the presence of the coupon, any grading and its date. This is what the application's catalogue allows: the line exists before the purchase, it serves as a target, and it keeps a record of the copies you examined and then declined, information that often matters as much as the record of the copy you acquired.

In the end, this issue calls for documentary discipline more than budget: a #121 in average condition, bought with an honest description and an intact coupon, is worth more than a flattering copy whose restoration history escapes you. And the debate over what killed Gwen Stacy, which nobody has closed since 1973, remains the best test of how reliable the person selling you the piece is.

Torn between the two parts of the two-parter, or want to know where your 1973 copy stands before having it graded?

Get my comic valued
Amazing Spider-Man #121 (1973): the frequently asked questions answered in this article

Frequently asked questions

The question has no established answer. The onomatopoeia placed near the neck at the moment the web halts the fall has fuelled the hypothesis of a fatal deceleration, while a later letters page and statements from the creative team have defended other readings. The sources diverge, including among the creators. Be wary of any seller who settles it.

The two parts form a complete story: #121 carries the death of Gwen Stacy, #122 the death of the Green Goblin. At equal grade, #121 costs several times #122. The most common compromise is to aim for the highest possible grade on #121 and accept one or two steps lower on #122.

Check for the absence of a barcode: this block only appears on American comics from the mid-1970s onward. Then read the indicia: a more recent copyright line, a volume number or a collection name signals a reprint. A price in pence indicates an original printing intended for the British market.

Yes, and it is the defect most often passed over in silence on this issue. Comics of 1973 contained coupon inserts that many readers cut out. A missing coupon caps the attainable grade regardless of how the cover looks. Ask the seller explicitly to check before concluding.

Because it establishes a death that the main continuity never undid: Gwen Stacy's later returns are clones or parallel-universe figures. This irreversibility, in a title with a very large June 1973 print run, makes it one of the most cited candidates for the hinge role, even though periodisation remains a collectors' convention.