Just decided to start collecting comics but don't know where to begin? This is one of the most common questions new collectors ask, and for good reason: the market is vast, prices range from a dollar to thousands, and early mistakes can be costly — both literally and figuratively. The first comics you buy define your experience, your motivation to keep going, and potentially the future value of your collection.
This guide covers 20 first comics to acquire based on your profile, your budget, and your tastes — to build a solid, coherent collection that, if you choose, grows in value over time. We cover Marvel, DC, independents, and affordable options for every budget.
Define your budget and goals before buying
Before buying anything, ask yourself two fundamental questions: why am I collecting? and how much am I willing to spend? The answers determine everything else. A collector who buys for the love of reading won't invest the same way as one targeting long-term appreciation.
Casual Beginner
You want to read great stories and get familiar with the comics universe. Focus on TPBs (trade paperbacks), facsimile editions, and accessible modern issues.
Investment-Minded Beginner
You want key issues with appreciation potential. Target first appearances of popular characters in raw (ungraded) form or low-grade CGC copies.
Passionate Beginner
You're going after important key issues right from the start. New Mutants #98, Ultimate Fallout #4, Edge of Spider-Verse #2 — issues that combine narrative value with investment potential.
Pro tip: always start with what you love. A collector passionate about Spider-Man will learn the subtleties of the market far faster than one buying "strategically" for characters they don't care about. Passion is the best filter against bad purchases.
The 20 first comics to buy based on your profile
Here is our selection of 20 foundational comics to start your collection, organized by universe and profile. For each one, we note whether an original is accessible or whether a reprint is a fine starting point.
If you love Marvel
Amazing Fantasy #15 (1962)
The first appearance of Peter Parker / Spider-Man is THE absolute Marvel key issue. An original CGC 9.6 sold for $3.6 million in 2021. For a beginner, the original is out of reach — but Marvel regularly publishes Facsimile Editions and Marvel Milestone reprints that faithfully reproduce the content. Perfect for reading and owning without breaking the bank.
Uncanny X-Men #141 (1981)
"Days of Future Past" is the most influential X-Men arc in history, the starting point for all Marvel time-travel stories and the direct inspiration for the 2014 film. UXM #141 is the first chapter of this two-part arc. In raw Good/VG, it remains very affordable. An ideal first Silver/Bronze Age key issue — tangible, collectible, and narratively exceptional.
Iron Man #128 (1979)
The central issue of the "Demon in a Bottle" arc, which explores Tony Stark's alcoholism with a depth and honesty rare for its era. This is the arc that defined Tony Stark as a complex character beyond the superhero role — and one that partly inspired the MCU films. In raw Good/VG, prices are very reasonable and the story remains a Bronze Age masterpiece.
Amazing Spider-Man #300 (1988)
ASM #300 is the first full appearance of Venom / Eddie Brock, the alien symbiote anti-hero who became one of Marvel's most popular characters. Issue #300 of any series is always a collector milestone, and this one has it all: a top-tier key issue, an iconic McFarlane cover, and a character proven at the box office. In raw, it stays within an accessible range for a first investment.
If you love DC
Batman #404 — "Batman: Year One" (1987)
The first chapter of Batman: Year One, the arc that tells Batman's first year and Jim Gordon's early days in Gotham. Considered the best Batman origin story ever written, it directly inspired Batman Begins. Available as a TPB for a few dollars, or as original issues for a quality collection. An absolute must-have for any DC fan.
Watchmen #1 (1986)
Watchmen is considered by Time Magazine to be one of the 100 greatest English-language novels of the 20th century. Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons's miniseries deconstructs the superhero myth with narrative, visual, and thematic depth that has no equal. The TPB is available for $15-20. The 12 original issues in good condition make a highly prized collector's set.
Green Lantern #76 (1970)
Green Lantern #76 kicks off one of DC history's most important runs: the O'Neil/Adams collaboration that tackled social issues (racism, drugs, poverty) head-on through superheroes. This issue was the first to explore these themes with radical sincerity and permanently changed what comics could be. A high-quality Bronze Age key issue with exceptional narrative merit.
If you want to invest
New Mutants #98 (1991)
The first appearance of Deadpool / Wade Wilson is one of the most profitable key issues of the past 30 years. Mass-printed in the '90s, it's still accessible in raw — but high-grade copies are increasingly scarce. With the Deadpool & Wolverine films driving demand, this is one of the best risk/reward plays for a beginner. Pick up a copy in solid condition, bags & boards included.
Edge of Spider-Verse #2 (2014)
Spider-Gwen / Gwen Stacy is one of Marvel's most popular creations of the 2010s. Her first appearance in Edge of Spider-Verse #2 is a high-demand key issue, fueled by the Spider-Verse films and MCU integration announcements. CGC 9.8 copies are the most sought-after, but a raw copy in good condition offers a reasonable entry point for a first modern investment.
Ultimate Fallout #4 (2011)
The first appearance of Miles Morales / Spider-Man, the new Spider-Man of the Ultimate Universe, is a steadily climbing Modern Age key issue. With the Spider-Verse films and his announced MCU integration, demand shows no signs of slowing. The issue is still affordable in raw VF/NM and makes an excellent first key issue for a collector looking to bet on rising MCU characters.
Batman Adventures #12 (1993)
Harley Quinn first appeared in the Batman animated series (1992) before being adapted to comics in Batman Adventures #12. This issue marks her first official comics appearance. With the character's explosive popularity thanks to the Suicide Squad and Birds of Prey films and animated series, this key issue has seen spectacular appreciation. Still a profitable investment in raw.
If you love independent comics
Saga #1 (2012)
Saga is universally regarded as one of the best comics of the 21st century: an intimate yet sweeping space opera epic with first-rate storytelling and art. The first printing of #1 is the most sought-after key issue among 2010s Image comics. In raw, it remains in an accessible price range. A TV adaptation is regularly rumored, which keeps demand strong.
Spawn #1 (1992)
The first issue of Spawn marks the birth of Image Comics, founded by star Marvel artists who wanted to own the rights to their creations. Todd McFarlane, Spider-Man's star artist, created Spawn as a symbol of this industry revolution. The Spawn franchise is seeing massive renewed interest with an announced film. The #1 remains very affordable despite its historical importance.
Mistakes to avoid as a beginner
Comic book collecting is full of pitfalls that beginners consistently run into. Knowing them in advance saves you time, money, and a lot of frustration.
- Buying without checking condition: the condition of a comic determines 80% of its value. Always request detailed photos of the cover, back cover, and interior before any online purchase
- Paying catalog price without checking eBay: the "catalog price" (Overstreet, etc.) is often disconnected from real-world market prices. Always check eBay Sold Listings to see actual sale prices from the past 90 days
- Starting with Golden Age that's too expensive: comics from 1938 to 1956 are rare, fragile, and usually out of reach for beginners. Start with Bronze Age (1970-1985) which offers excellent value for money
- Skipping bags & boards: every comic should be immediately stored in a bag (polybag) with a backing board. A comic that deteriorates loses value irreversibly
- Buying variants without knowing the print run: some variants are extremely rare and very valuable, others are printed by the millions. Always verify the print run before paying a premium
- Ignoring import fees on US purchases: a purchase from MyComicShop or Midtown Comics may be subject to customs duties and taxes. Calculate the full real cost before buying
My Comics Collection lets you manage your comic wish list, track market prices, and avoid costly duplicates. Start by cataloging what you already own before buying what you still need — discover the wish list feature.
Where to buy your first comics
The buying channel largely determines the price you pay and the quality of what you receive. Here are the best options depending on your needs:
Specialty Comic Shops
Local comic book stores are ideal for TPBs and new releases. Prices are fixed but you can see exactly what you're buying. A great starting point for beginners who want guidance.
eBay
The largest secondhand comics marketplace. Prices vary wildly between sellers. Always check "Sold Listings" to see real sale prices. Watch out for shipping fees from US sellers.
Comic Conventions
The best deals are often found at conventions, where sellers want to move inventory. You can negotiate, examine comics in person, and meet fellow collectors. Most major conventions have a comics section.
US Specialty Sites
MyComicShop.com and Midtown Comics have huge catalogs and reliable grading notes. Watch out for shipping costs and import fees from the United States (add 20-30% to the total price).
- Facebook Marketplace: surprisingly effective for lots and local sellers who don't always know the value of what they're selling
- Facebook collector groups: active communities with sales between enthusiasts
- Garage sales and flea markets: the ultimate treasure hunt — rare finds still happen, especially in smaller towns
How to grow your collection after your first 20 comics
Once you've bought your first comics, the real question becomes: how do you develop your collection intelligently? Here are the steps that separate a stagnant collector from a progressing one:
- Follow MCU/DCU announcements: every film or series announcement drives up key issue prices for the characters involved. Following conventions (SDCC, D23) lets you anticipate price spikes
- Join communities: collector forums and groups are gold mines of free information. You'll learn more in a month of discussion than in a year of solo research
- Use My Comics Collection: catalog every comic you acquire, manage your wish list, track your collection's value, and avoid costly duplicates with our dedicated tool
- Learn grading: being able to assess a comic's condition yourself is the most profitable skill you can develop. Start with the free CGC grading guides available online
- Diversify: don't put all your eggs in one character or universe. A diversified collection is less vulnerable to fluctuations tied to a single character
FAQ — First Comics to Collect
Manage your collection from day one
Catalog your acquisitions, manage your wish list, and track your collection's value — free 14-day trial, no credit card required.
Start your free trial — 14 daysNo commitment · Cancel anytime · Instant access